StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Progress Can Kill - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Progress Can Kill" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the statement that progress can kill. Like everyone else, the discovery of an indigenous population deep in the rainforest of New Guinea aroused my curiosity…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Progress Can Kill
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Progress Can Kill"

Progress Can Kill Like everyone else, the discovery of an indigenous population deep in the rain forest of New Guinea aroused my curiosity. I could not help, but marvel over the fact that this population managed to survive and move forward for millennia without the use of technology and in a complete isolation from the outside world. At the same time, I was completely fascinated by the fact that this tribe occupies a territory that is likely rich with untapped oil reserves. However, as an advisor from one of our permanent members to the UN, I also realized that we had a responsibility to proceed with the extreme caution. I know that it is tempting to assume that we can solve the world’s oil shortage problems by exploiting the territory occupied by this indigenous population. However, the main issue is whether or not we can do this without exploiting the rights and dignity of this indigenous population. Let us first consider the rights and dignity of this indigenous population. They have been occupying this territory for centuries, not ten or thirty years. Mostly in the world, when an individual occupies a home or a piece of land for 12 years without an objection from the true owner, the state recognizes and protects the occupant’s right to claim and use the property absolutely as he or she wishes. Can we honestly deny that this indigenous tribe does not enjoy the same right, continued and unmolested, to occupy their territory? I would take this step further and argue that given the long and continued occupation of it by the indigenous tribe, it is not only our legal, but also our moral responsibility to protect and recognize their right to claim and use that territory absolutely and free of outside influences and intrusions. This is not just a question of the right to occupancy. This is also about the protection of the universal human rights. In particular, this tribe has adapted itself to a particular way of living and preservation consistent with their animistic religious beliefs. As members of the UN we have pledged that no state shall disrespect the religious beliefs of the individual. How then can we justify even asking this tribe to move aside and allow us to exploit their territory for the purpose of looking for oil? Let us consider the Holy City of Mecca. What if we think suddenly that the Holy City of Mecca most likely sits on untapped oil reserves. Could we in good conscience approach Muslims in the holy city and talk to them about the possibility of turning their city upside down for oil exploration purposes? I don’t think that we would even consider taking this approach because we respect the right of religious organizations to practice their religion as long as that practice does not involve activity causing harm to others. On the contrary, far from causing harm to others, this indigenous people have preserved the rain forest at the time when concerns about the destruction of the rain forests globally have been a major issue for environmentalists. We should, therefore, be celebrating the fact that this tribe has preserved the rain forest and not think of ways that we can deplete yet another portion of the world’s rain forest. While we are considering the possibility of oil exploration in this particular area, let us also consider the dignity of this tribe. The dignity of indigenous people has been assaulted throughout our history. Colonial and imperial powers have mercilessly uprooted indigenous people, exploited their territories and with the total disregard for their right to self-determination have left them without dignity and without their own system of governance. Unfortunately, history dictates that indigenous people have a long history of exploitation and injustice. Do we want to stop the cycle of exploitation or do we want to re-establish it? The UN International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights informs that we have a duty to protect the right of indigenous population to self-determination. Similarly, Article 1 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 1966 provides that all people have the inherent right to “determine” for themselves what their “political status” should be and to “freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development” (Article 1). Our obligations as signatories to these two international covenants are quite clear. We have a duty and an obligation to respect the right of this tribe to self-determination, and this means the right to continue living in isolation, peace, and in community with nature as prescribed by their religious and cultural norms and beliefs. It may be argued that the rest of the world is in dire need of oil reserves as it can solve a number of problems associated with the high cost of food production and transportation. However, those problems have been created by our choices and how we choose to live. This tribe has chosen a different way of living and not caused our problems; therefore, they should not pay the price for resolving our issues. Moreover, do we even know that oil reserves exist or are we merely anticipating that oil reserves are on this territory? Even if we were certain that this tribe lived on untapped oil reserves, these oil reserves would only temporarily fix the world’s shortage problems, but would permanently uproot and irreparably harm the life of this tribe. We, therefore, need to adopt a solution that is more tangible and long-lasting and does not harm the lives of these people. Let us leave them with their dignity and their right to self-determination and continue to explore and develop policies for alternative energy. We need to realize that eventually we will run out of oil reserves; when that happens we will have no more rain forests and our eco-system will be entirely compromised. I, therefore, suggest that we do not solve one problem by creating a larger and more far-reaching problem. It is the time that we should take alternative energy policies more seriously and dispose the idea of oil exploration is only a temporary answer. I would like to leave you with one thought: let us learn from this tribe. Just as they have preserved their land for future generations, let us find long-term solutions to our energy problems for our future generations. In other words, let us invest all of our resources into developing alternative energy means for long-term solutions that will benefit future generations. We have learned that progress can kill; and this indigenous population has proven that progress is not necessary for survival, peace, and security. Works Cited International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 1966. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Progress Can Kill Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1479211-progress-can-kill
(Progress Can Kill Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1479211-progress-can-kill.
“Progress Can Kill Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1479211-progress-can-kill.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Progress Can Kill

Film editing process

Video clips can be improved significantly by simply discarding unwanted or flawed bits.... Techniques such as visual effects and mood music can have a great influence on the reaction of the audience.... The editor can also give the video a certain angle, which is tailoring the video in a way that it supports a certain viewpoint, serves an agenda, or imparts a message....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Analyzing Group Process and Skill Selection

Additionally, who is to say that people are comfortable sitting at such close proximity to each other In a physical structure where members might feel they can't manage the intensity of the group experience physically, i.... This paper will offer an analysis of the group dynamics in the video clip provided....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Employment at Will and Due Process

dditionally, although Werhane and Radin tried to say that private businesses are like public businesses because they can be deemed as putting efforts towards achieving the common good, I believe it may more often be the other way around.... In the paper “Employment at Will and Due Process,” the author discusses an article by Patricia H....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Will special programs for reconvicts reduce recidivism

Recidivism can be defined as behavior which may be legal but giving rise to an opportunity for the person convicted for committing the crime again.... The growing threat of recidivism needs to be addressed by social scientists and criminologists.... The measures to be taken for this task will entail tougher measures and new techniques....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Process of How a Bill Becomes a Law

This paper "The Process of How a Bill Becomes a Law" focuses on the laws that are legislated to regulate human behaviours and which will serve as a framework to nurture an orderly civilization.... It is ordained by authorities to put a legal and binding effect to all constituents of a nation.... nbsp; … It's a body of rules which are stipulated as statutory and constitutional enactments....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Process of Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer

The paper 'The Process of Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer' presents the procedures that created the sheep Dolly which could also be applied to human cells.... The process of somatic cell nuclear transfer involves transferring a donor's nuclear DNA into an oocyte from where the nucleus came from.... hellip; Reproductive cloning is described as the application of SCNT....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

The Film-making Process

Hence, being a person concerned with the future of the environment and how it will affect life, I was inspired into thinking of creating a film that can deliver the same message.... Transformers 3 depicts hyper-real scenes such as the army of robots to describe the intensity that mass destruction can rise to....
2 Pages (500 words) Admission/Application Essay

The Skill of the Mediator in Managing the Mediation Process

Without the use of any specific technique or conflict resolution mechanism, conflict can neither be eradicated nor can it be exterminated.... We can say that mediation is a process which is carried out by a person who is called a negotiator.... The basic aim of a mediator is to reach such an appropriate agreement which can be agreed by both of the disputing parties.... ) states that workplace mediation, in particular, can be an effective way to resolve work-related and interpersonal conflicts....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us