StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Modern vs Traditional Medicine - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper 'Modern vs Traditional Medicine' aims to critically compare and contrast modern medicine and traditional medicines. Medical research has advanced incredibly in all streams of medical interventions. Methodologies and techniques to tackle serious medical conditions have been standardized by researchers…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
Modern vs Traditional Medicine
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Modern vs Traditional Medicine"

Medical research has advanced incredibly in all streams of medical interventions. Methodologies and techniques to tackle serious medical conditions has been standardised by researchers. Advances have been made in the detection and prevention of diseases and other medical conditions. These days, nations are setting aside a good portion of their budget for researches and developmental programmes in medicine. This must be read together with the fact that the factors relating to health and medical conditions of the population of a particular country are important determinants of the development index of that nation. It can also be seen that international organisations which are involved in developmental activities also spend a lot of effort in the area of medicine. While the modern advancements in medicine rely on calibrated usage of chemical substances and mechanical methods, there are medical interventions which were traditionally followed with the aid of naturally available materials and their combinations. Both these approaches in medicine have its own advantages and disadvantages. The objective of this essay is to critically compare and contrast modern medicine and traditional medicines. The Approach In order to analyse the two different streams in medicine, it is important to understand the approaches of both modern medicine and traditional medicine. As explained earlier traditional medicine is the branch of medicine which does not depend on manmade systems and chemicals to intervene with the body and tackle a medical condition. On the other side, it utilises naturally available materials, its combinations, its extracts and traditionally shared knowledge to deal with medical conditions. Wherein, modern medicine relies on different combinations of chemical substances to suppress medical conditions. Here we can observe that the methodologies vary to a vast extend. Taking this observation into account and while analysing the reason for this wide gap, it can be assumed that the approach of these two different kind of medical interventions differ a lot within itself. Steig (2011) has opined that the basic difference between traditional medicine and modern medicine is in their approach towards diseases and health. However, there are literatures available proving that there is ample difference between disease and illness. Disease is an abnormality in either the function or structure of organs and systems associated with it or a combination of both. This is merely a biological condition. However, illness has a larger perspective covering the psychological, physical and social status of the patient. Illness has been defined as the patient’s perception and experience of certain states which are disvalued in social terms. This would mean that illness extends its effect beyond a disease. In other words, all diseases are illness, but all illnesses are not diseases. This principle has been widely agreed upon by researchers and has been confirmed by Dr. Arthur Kleinman, a noted medical anthropologist (Steig, 2011). The basic difference in modern medicine and traditional medicine can be related to this principle. It is these two different approaches that make the two streams of medicine so different from each other. To explain it further, modern medicine deals merely with a biological condition of the body. Wherever, there is an abnormality in human organs or systems, modern medicines and methodologies intervene to correct these. Modern medicine detects this disorder precisely and either cure or delay the damage being caused by the abnormality. In contrast with this, illness which covers a larger spectrum including the spiritual, psychological condition in association with the disease is dealt by natural medicine. This would mean that traditional medicines involve a holistic intervention not limiting to the physical situation. This must be read together with the fact that the psychological and spiritual wellness of a person is important for a long term impact of a medical intervention. In this context, it can be said that traditional medicines are more holistic and its curative capacity is more long term than modern medicines. The Philosophy The philosophy of modern medical system is entirely based on scientifically calibrated principles, theories, practices and understandings. Various national and international organisations have formulated principles and ethics for medical practitioners to follow. These are formed and updated according to observations and findings made in the medical industry time to time. Another interesting fact on this philosophy of modern medicine based on code of conduct is that, it differs from region to region and system to system. For example the European medical standards are very much different from Asian or African medical system. Adding to this, it is also observable that different medical organisations within a geographical location have different medical standards. It will be interesting to note here that a practitioner of modern medical system who is trained in Asia is not allowed to carry out medical interventions in Europe without getting professionally adapted to and getting professionally qualified according to European standards. This proves that though the theories and science behind modern medical system are the same universally, its philosophy varies with many social theories associated with hygiene, values etc. Traditional medical systems are largely based on philosophical systems traditionally known and shared through generations. Many philosophical thoughts like worship of nature, Buddhism, thoughts from animism, pantheism and many other philosophical approaches (Bang, 2009). However, the generic philosophy of tradition medicine is that it helps human body to adapt to the systems of nature. (Bang, 2009). There are evidences in almost all forms of natural medicines which relates to this philosophy. In the case of Ayurveda, the Indian traditional medical stream, the philosophy is that everything in the universe is connected with each other. Based on this connections Ayurvedic interventions try to reinstate the lost balance between human body and other natural systems which will help the patient to regain balance of mind and purity (Bang, 2009). Another system of natural medicine, Shamanic medicine is based on the philosophy of driving out evil spirits and blessing the body to have effective relationship with nature. It involves psychological treatment of patients (Bang, 2009). Chinese system of traditional medicine also is based on a similar philosophy. It balances the systems of the body so that human is in unison with nature. Unhealthy thoughts, behavioural problems and imbalanced lifestyle are observed by the Buddhist system to be the causes of illness. The simplest medicine for many of the illnesses in this system is a perusal of a simple life style (Bang, 2009). However, it must be noted that these philosophies are passed on through traditional knowledge sharing methods. This may lead to loss of values based on the particular person involved. Systems for scientific documentation and sharing of these philosophies are less compared to the modern medical systems. The Cost Benefit Analysis The basic difference in between the natural and modern system of medicines in terms of its impact is the time period for the cure to take place. In general, modern medicines show quick signs of cure. This effect comes handy when dealing with critical medical conditions which need urgent interventions. The antibiotics which serves the antibodies of the body, brings down the symptoms of the medicine at a quicker pace. However, in the case of traditional medicines, the impact takes a longer time. Thus in traumatic conditions, these medicines are generally used. However, if this is analysed based on the philosophies of the medical systems being discussed, it can be found that the effect of traditional systems are longer than that of the modern ones. This is because of the simple reason that traditional medicines heal the illness as such and not just the symptoms of a biological imbalance. It has been argued by a number of scientists that modern medicines treat the systems than the illness. Taking into account the cost of treatment, it can be found that apart from the monetary cost involved, modern medicines involves a lot of physiological, psychological and social costs. The process of diagnosis itself will involve exhaustion of biological resources within the body. In other terms, it will involve unpredictable and predicable side effects. A disastrous fact associated with this is that these side effects may lead to further illness. Moreover, this will lead the patient to a peculiar psychological state involving social costs like deprival of peace of mind, livelihood, and change in life patters etc. On the other side, traditional medicines by taking a holistic approach, improves the psychological status of the patient in the long term. Conclusion While comparing traditional and modern systems of medicine, both have advantages and disadvantages. Considering the longer term of impact, traditional medicine is to be considered as a part of life style. The traditional system of medicine is getting popularity across the world as patients are increasingly being aware of the side effects of modern medicine. A study which was published in Journal of the American Medical Association revealed that patients in America had the same inclination towards traditional practitioners as they had for modern medicines. This proves that both the streams of medicines are being pursued by sick people. There are efforts worldwide to integrate these systems of medicine so that the advantages of both are combined to minimise the disadvantages of both. For example, the calibration and standardisation techniques used by modern medicine can be integrated into the traditional system. Similarly, the holistic approach of traditional practitioners can be used in modern medical systems. References Steig R L (2011), Modern vs Traditional Medicine, National Pain Foundation, Retrieved on 20 October, 2011, from Bang C C (2009), Traditional Medicines: Promising Alternatives to Animal Experimentations, Chinese Animal Protection Network, Retrieved on 20 October, 2011, from Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“None Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 1”, n.d.)
None Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1582191-none
(None Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1)
None Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1582191-none.
“None Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1582191-none.
  • Cited: 3 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Modern vs Traditional Medicine

How Culture Has Impacted the Development of Pharmaceutical Drugs

On the other side, herbal medicine might be more beneficial particularly in recovery and prevention since it helps to improve the immunity and offers nutritional advantages that pharmaceuticals lack.... From the Native American, Indian, Chinese, German and American perspective, herbal medicine is about healing the person rather than curing a disease.... Practitioners of herbal medicine use cleansing and purifying rituals to the body and set up the person for healing....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Energy Medicine as the Medicine of Future

Energy medicine, also known as energy healing is founded on the notion that it is possible for the healer to direct the rejuvenating energy into the patient through various processes like touching, applying pressure or even distant rejuvenation (where the healer is physically absent and located differently from his/her patient) (Daulby and Mathison, 1996, 89).... Energy medicine, also known as energy healing is founded on the notion that it is possible for the healer to direct the rejuvenating energy into the patient through various processes like touching, applying pressure or even distant rejuvenation (where the healer is physically absent and located differently from his/her patient) (Daulby and Mathison, 1996, 89)....
17 Pages (4250 words) Dissertation

Traditional medicine vs alternative medicine

This paper attempts to compare and contrast the traditional medicine (TM) with the Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM).... There are data that suggests that 80% population in Africa is depending on traditional medicine for health care.... For instance, there are several tourists from different countries visiting India basically for the treatment using Ayurveda which is a traditional medicine developed over the years in India.... This traditional medicine was accomplished for centuries and its idea is based on Taoist philosophy....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Pharmaceuticals and Herbs

African traditional medicine………………………………………….... Native Americans use of herbs in medicine………………….... On the other side, herbal medicine might be more beneficial particularly in recovery and prevention since it helps to improve the immunity and offers nutritional advantages that pharmaceuticals lack.... Practitioners of herbal medicine use cleansing and purifying rituals to the body and set up the person for healing....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Streams in Medicine: Methodologies And Techniques

In order to analyze the two different streams in medicine, it is important to understand the approaches of both modern medicine and traditional medicine.... As explained earlier traditional medicine is the branch of medicine which does not depend on manmade systems and chemicals to intervene with the body and tackle a medical condition.... Steig (2011) has opined that the basic difference between traditional medicine and modern medicine is in their approach towards diseases and health....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Use of Animal By-products for Human Medicine

Their utility as sources of varying medicines is traceable to early historical times, as showcased through various cultural utilities, with this still being practiced in the field of herbal medicine.... The paper will be organized into two main sections, which will further display the prevailing contexts influencing the need of anima-based products for human medicine.... Animal, as well as plant-based medicines, through increased utility in contemporary contexts, provide for a case study of how both western and traditional forms of medication can be incorporated into the overall human health and medical development....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

The Toxicity of Ayurvedic Medicine Use

This research paper "The Toxicity of Ayurvedic medicine Use" analyzes Ayurveda that deals with the intricate processing mercury and metals converting them to therapeutic forms from toxic materials.... In the USA the medicine is observed as complementary and alternative medicine for more than 20,000 adults a number that was posted in the previous year.... omplimentary and alternative medicine (CAM) includes a wide range of curative advances, therapies and philosophies....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Traditional Chinese Medicine for Prevention and Treatment

There is therefore a need of the implementation of the traditional Chinese medicines so as to remove the economic strain on the health sector as well as making the service available to all.... .... ... ... Most of the burden of diseases is due to chronic diseases and its prevalence is increasing day in day out....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us