StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Holocaust Documentaries Analysis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Holocaust Documentaries Analysis" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the documentaries about the Holocaust. It must be understood that the period in question was concentric around the period between the Nazi takeover of Germany and the end of World War II…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Holocaust Documentaries Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Holocaust Documentaries Analysis"

With respect to the documentary in question, as well as the chapter by Peter Suedfeld, it must be understood that the time period in question wasconcentric around the period between the Nazi takeover of Germany and the end of World War II. Such a time period was necessary as it helped to capture many of the nuances for why such hatred, animosity, and deep seated racial policies were able to come to fruition. However, it must also be understood that in order to understand why the holocaust took place, focusing solely upon the Nazi period of German or European history is not sufficient. As such, deep undercurrents of anti-Semitism and racial hatred for the Jewish population of Europe had existed since the Middle Ages. Much of this was caused by the fact that stakeholders within early European society believed that people of Jewish decent still bore a direct level of responsibility for the crucifixion and death of Christ. Such a level of innate and cultural distrust and even hatred ultimately coalesced with the economic and political pressures that Germany faced after the First World War and gave rise to the Nazi Party; a harbinger to the holocaust. 2. For the most part the film appeared to be rather unbiased. However, it must be stated that no attempt was made to understand the situation from the perspective of the German citizen or the German soldier. Naturally, the film-maker probably glossed over this due to the fact that seeking to understand the issue from such a perspective was deemed as merely trying to understand evil; something that they did not want to waste valuable time on. Yet, even though this may be true, it would have provided a further level of credibility to the film if the film-maker(s) had allowed for an alternative approach and a view of the situation through the eyes of those who were responsible for carrying it out. Even if such a view might have been unpleasant, it was necessary in order to understand the dynamics for why such inhumanity can persist and why a broad based public outcry for it to stop was never realized or witnessed. Moreover, even though the film is useful in understanding the plight of the individual caught up in the horrors of the holocaust, too much of an emotional appeal also detracts from the merit of objectivity that could otherwise be represented. Naturally, it is not fair to disregard the horrors that the individual faced during the ethnic cleansing of Jews within Europe; however, too much of a focus upon the individual loses sight of the mechanisms, causation, and realities for why this was being carried out and what forces encouraged it. 3. How does this film contribute to our knowledge of the Nazi Holocaust? Ultimately, the film contributes to an understanding of the Holocaust in the sense that it allows the viewer to come to a more informed understanding of the way in which the Holocaust not only Germany’s Jews but Jewish populations throughout the remainder of occupied Europe. This is an important understanding to gain due to the fact that a misconception with regards to the overall scope of the Holocaust is one of the most common misconceptions that exists. Whereas it is true that the Germans were responsible for murdering unknown tens of thousands of Jews within Germany itself, the bulk of the Holocaust victims were derived not within Germany’s borders; rather, these were derived from areas of heavy Jewish concentration within Eastern Europe – specifically Poland and Ukraine (Cowen 167). In helping the viewer to come to a further understanding of the scope of the Holocaust and the personal ramifications that it had upon the lives, experience, and future of the individuals that were fortunate enough to survive it, the viewer is led to a more informed understanding with respect to the many different ways in which this particular occurrence impacted upon the future of not only Europe but the rest of the world. 4. Ultimately, Suedfeld posits a litany of different reasons for why the Holocaust actually took place. The first of these theories he terms as “demonic theories”. Even though this encourages something of a religious understanding, what this ultimately means is that an individual human being, of a particularly twisted psyche, would most be responsible in engaging something like the Holocaust. Naturally, for such an understanding, the reader can come to the realization of the fact that Hitler would necessarily represent this “demonic” human being. However, this particular theory falls short due to the fact that it over emphasizes the role that adult Hitler himself had and minimizes the impact of the roles that tens of thousands of German soldiers and civilians had in perpetrating allowing the Holocaust to continue. A secondary theory that the author puts forward is what is referred to as the sociopolitical and economic chaos theory. It cannot be denied the Germany faced a period of intense social and political unrest and upheaval following the catastrophic defeat in World War I. As a direct result of this catastrophe, many theorists put forward the understanding that the core of society was shaken to such a degree that radical and rabid anti-Semitism was able to rise and ultimately gave birth to the Nazi party and its atrocities. Of all of the theories that were presented, it is this reader’s understanding that this particular theory is the most effective in explaining the underlying reasons and rationale for why the Holocaust took place when and where it did. A third theory that was presented is with regards to pragmatism. This theory basically claims that the pragmatism of the German people specified that it was culturally understood that Jews were necessarily wealthy people and had approved a great deal of wealth over the centuries within the German society. As such, taking this wealth by force and persecuting the Jews would allow for a pragmatic level of perceived benefit within the entire society. A fourth theory that is put forward is with regards to what is termed as a social psychological theory. This theory is perhaps the second most relevant in terms of the way in which this particular reader integrates with it. As such, the social psychological theory puts forward the impact that peer pressure and group dynamics can have upon the decisions, morality, and exhibition of ethics within the group as a whole (Dietsch 67). Further, the author puts forward a rather wild theory with respect to the fact that Germans were somehow free determined to exhibit racial hatred. This particular theory is known as the Goldschlagen thesis. Although it has almost resoundingly been disproven by litany of different scholars of the past several years, there is an element of truth to the way in which German culture, history, and specific interpretations of religion all coalesced in order to make the German people a more likely victim of racial hatred and ideology than any other group; at least at the given time. The final theory that is put forward is with regards to what is known as the will to power and/or the postmodern approach. Within this particular approach, the author denotes the fact that Germany was far and away the most developed society within all of Europe prior to and during the Nazi takeover. This encouraged a degree of belief and trust within numbers, science, and an overall level of distrust with regards to the importance of humanity, compassion, and caring. From all of these factors, theories, and considerations, it can clearly be determined that the Holocaust and the racial cruelty that he was exhibited within Germany during the years in question is not entirely dissimilar to the racial cruelty, ethnic cleansing, mass murder, and societal upheaval that have occurred in places such as Armenia, Cambodia, Rwanda, Bosnia, and a litany of different states around the globe. In short, the running list of theories that is been provided should not be understood as somehow uniquely German. Rather, these forces can have a powerful impact throughout the globe and to determine the way in which conflict is exhibited and different groups are persecuted for no reason other than their ethnic composition. Works Cited Cowan, Paula. "Reconceptualising The Holocaust And Holocaust Education In Countries That Escaped Nazi Occupation" Intercultural Education 24.1/2 (2013): 167-179. Academic Search Complete. Web. 1 Nov. 2013. Dietsch, Johan. "Textbooks And The Holocaust" European Education 44.3 (2012): 67-94. Academic Search Complete. Web. 1 Nov. 2013. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Holocaust Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1490147-holocaust
(Holocaust Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1490147-holocaust.
“Holocaust Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1490147-holocaust.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Holocaust Documentaries Analysis

Holocaust - Dr. Mengele

According to the discussion it it is clear that apart from millions of victims, the Nazi holocaust had its own heroes, martyrs and villains.... Mengele has intrigued the world ever since the cruelties of the holocaust came out in public.... But when perused from closer premises, the Nazi mindset can be understood as an outcome of ideological frenzy overpowering all humane feelings and responses, a dangerous human possibility indeed, that was revealed before our eyes through the Nazi holocaust, as never revealed before....
19 Pages (4750 words) Research Paper

Improving Media Literacy in Lower Education

The research primarily focuses on how first person documentaries can not only be utilized as media to convey messages, but also as tools for enhancing media literacy.... It is for this reason that, they deem modern media tools like first-person documentaries to be the most appropriate investigative methods.... It is for this reason that, they deem modern media tools like first-person documentaries to be the most appropriate investigative methods....
17 Pages (4250 words) Research Paper

The Use of Documentary Film as Historical Recollection

his report makes a conclusion that the use of film documentaries as a tool by which to further inform an audience, and to serve as a permanent historical record of events, is a valid and reliable tool for accomplishing those goals.... Marzynskis uses that coldness to help make his points, points with which he is concerned; that the holocaust memorial will be a cold and unwelcoming place that will cause people to avoid it, and that it took an unequaled coldness of heart – like the weather – for the German people to allow the murder of six million Jews....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Adversary School From US to Harvard

Students can relate to the film and adhere to it more for essay analysis.... The paper describes the constituents of basic skills for educators and their peers mostly that comprise of 3 R's strategy.... Reading, writing and thematic.... The strategy is regarded as the traditional approach for all levels of education....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

The Holocaust: Remembering and Becoming Human

Numerous documentaries and movies have been produced to remember the Holocaust for remembering helps ensure that it never happens again to any minority group and provides victims the opportunity to make sense of what happened, and to, hopefully, move on.... The essay "The holocaust: Remembering and Becoming Human" focuses on the stories of the holocaust are human stories that intersect issues of survival, apathy, escape resistance, rescue, and the search for meaning....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) defines Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) as suffering from an incident in which one has experienced serious threat of damage or death and then suffers from extreme fear and horror along with helplessness.... ... ... The paper describes the major causes for developing the Post-traumatic stress disorder....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

Conceptual Analysis as a Human Cognitive Activity

The paper "Conceptual analysis as a Human Cognitive Activity" states that mental models are made up of several characteristics.... The practice of conceptual analysis has undergone tremendous revolutions in recent years (John, 1984).... In an overview, conceptual analysis involves carrying out an assessment of the primary meanings of terms categorized as of philosophical interest.... roper use of conceptual analysis dictates that it is the primary breakdown of concept into their constituent parts....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Holocaust as a Tragic Trauma Drama

This paper ''The holocaust as a Tragic Trauma Drama '' tells that the holocaust is a tragic trauma drama that took place in human's history, which also became subject to extensive commemoration and remembrance (Alexander 2002, 52).... However, commemoration of the holocaust attained larger interest only during the last few decades and until the 1970s public awareness of sufferings of the Jews during the WWII were not as widespread as it is nowadays (Littler, 1972-; Naidoo, 1965)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us