StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Miranda Revisted: Dickerson v. United States - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article "Miranda Revisted: Dickerson v. United States" by Thomas Petrowski examines the issue of Dickerson v United States case and discusses its implication for the law enforcement. It starts with the quotation from Fifth Amendment of Constitution which says that the person cannot be a witness against himself…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Miranda Revisted: Dickerson v. United States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Miranda Revisted: Dickerson v. United States"

The author provides the factors under which the confession is considered to be voluntary. The section of passage 3501 is used to protect the rights of convicts, however, despite this passage, the law enforcement agencies followed the ruling in Miranda. On page 27 the author summarizes the details of the Dickerson case: Dickerson was aware of the rights granted to him by the Miranda ruling and has waived them in the written form. However, as the investigation went further, he has notified that has confessed before he received the Miranda warning.

The major point was not that the confession was voluntary, but whether it was in fact given before Miranda warning. As the result, the case was transferred to US Supreme Court. "The Court not only affirmed Miranda but also declared it a Constitutional rule" (Petrowski 28). The next section is headed "Practical implication: Civil liability" in which the author investigates the "potential civil liability of individual law enforcement officers and their departments resulting from intentional violations of the warning requirements mandated in Miranda" (Petrowski 28).

The major point of this section is that "prior to the Supreme Court's decision in Dickerson, the clear majority view among the federal circuits was that no cause of action for money damages existed under 1983 where police officers allegedly violated Miranda principles by either failing to give Miranda warnings or by continuing to question a defendant in custody after his request for an attorney" (Petrowski 28). The section "Practical Guidance" is an overview of what the law enforcement agencies and officers should do in order to prevent the violation of Miranda warning right.

For example, the practice of interrogation before the warning was given. The author notes that sometimes the law enforcement officers can "over-Mirandize" - "tendency to repeatedly or unnecessarily give Miranda warnings" (Petrowski 29). Petrowski notes that there is a need to train the law enforcement agencies and to create sound policies to minimize the risk of Miranda violation. The conclusion is basically the summary of the whole report with the major points highlighted. I think that the Dickerson decision has not changed the existing practices too much, for example, it has not created new requirements for law enforcement officers.

However, it is vital that the Supreme Court has reminded both suspects and law enforcement agencies that the person cannot be forced to confess against himself if he does not want to. Of course, it is constitutionally right to give the suspect a Miranda warning; however, it adds more work to law enforcement officers in trying to prove the guilt of the suspect. My opinion is that if the suspect is cooperative and does not try to hide his guilt, Miranda warning should not be obligatory. Dickerson's case has made Miranda warning a constitutional right of each suspect but seems that law enforcement officers are forced to overuse it.

Even though nothing is said about the need to repeat the warning several times, I believe that there will be more cases about this issue in the future. The author has made an important point that the "intentional violations of Miranda must cease" (Petrowski 30) and he is right. For example, if the suspect was forced to confess because the officer has told that he has no other choice, it is evident that the rights were violated.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Miranda Revisted: Dickerson v. United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words, n.d.)
Miranda Revisted: Dickerson v. United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. https://studentshare.org/law/1523922-the-article-miranda-revisted-dickerson-v-united-states-by-thomas-petrowski
(Miranda Revisted: Dickerson V. United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Miranda Revisted: Dickerson V. United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1523922-the-article-miranda-revisted-dickerson-v-united-states-by-thomas-petrowski.
“Miranda Revisted: Dickerson V. United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/law/1523922-the-article-miranda-revisted-dickerson-v-united-states-by-thomas-petrowski.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Miranda Revisted: Dickerson v. United States

Right to Silence Issue

This was indeed a departure from the Miranda judgment regarding enforcement of Fifth Amendment laws and is a decision by the united states Supreme Court in which the Court considered the position of a suspect who understands his or her right to remain silent under Miranda v.... rdquo; (What are your miranda Rights?... Thompkins, the defendant, Thompkins accused of first-degree murder failed to invoke his miranda rights to remain silent and to counsel because he failed to do so "unambiguously....
16 Pages (4000 words) Dissertation

Personal Masters Learning and Development Portfolio

Table of Contents Strategic Rationale, Masters Objectivity and Self Analysis 2 Strategic Analysis of Masters Abilities 4 Communications and Assessment One 8 Cornwall Residential and Working in Teams 11 Assessed Team Presentation 12 Developing Your Scholarship Abilities 13 Masters Learning Personal Reflections 14 References 16 Introduction The paper begings with a discussion of the strategic rationale and objectives of taking up my Masters degree....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

The Directives of the Miranda Act

The Miranda Act has been the most contentious and the most condemned case of the Supreme Court in the united states criminal justice (Fridell, 2006).... Arizona, the united states Supreme Court declared suspects within detention - or a logical custodial condition - have to be recommended of their right to stay silent, that no matter what they state, could be utilized against them and that they have a right to a legal representative.... Legal scholars and practitioners, recently, have committed vast amount of effort to reflecting over the impacts of the miranda Act on individuals and law enforcement personnel....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Miranda v. Arizona 384 U.S. 436 (1966)

united states, Vignera v.... The Miranda Law was created by a court of law based upon the united states Constitution and therefore cannot... miranda v.... Arizona In 1963, Ernesto miranda was arrested and charged with rape, kidnapping and robbery.... He confessed to all the crimes he was accused of within a grueling 2 hour interrogation process that was undertaken without any counsel present to advise miranda of his rights....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

U.S. Supreme Court review of Gideon v. Wainwright

No history of the right to counsel could be complete without a discussion of Gideon v.... Wainwright - one of the best-known and most significant right to counsel decisions rendered by the Supreme Court.... … The Warren Court's landmark 1963 opinion in Gideon revisited the issue confronted twenty years earlier in Betts v....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Miranda v. Arizona (1966) and Dickeson v. U.S. (2000)

and Suspect Rights Advisements in the united states.... Arizona case in 1966 and dickerson v.... Miranda Revisited: The Case of dickerson v.... A case study of the miranda v.... Quoting the miranda's conviction which was overturned, the court made it clear about what should happen if the suspect chooses to exercise or practice their rights.... The Martin Quinn scores indicate that the Supreme Court's decision on miranda Vs Arizona was a liberal judgment as it is marked with a negative....
2 Pages (500 words) Term Paper

Personal Masters Learning and Development Portfolio

In the paper "Personal Masters Learning and Development Portfolio" the author discusses his awareness of his objectives in the pursuit of a Masters degree.... It has likewise made him realise the knowledge, skills, and abilities which he has yet to master to be able to exceed the expectations....
22 Pages (5500 words) Admission/Application Essay

Palliative Care in Australia

The author of the paper "Palliative Care in Australia" states that palliative care in Australia has now reached a watershed.... More than ever before, there is greater recognition of the need for more integrated services across home and institutional environments.... hellip; Throughout the 1980s and 1990s federal governments, reformed health services across institutions, home services, and support services and this fostered the reduced development of programs that reduced the use of institutional care (Calder, 57)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us