StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

America's Constitution - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of this assignment "America's Constitution" touches upon the case of Michigan Court decision. It is mentioned that the major issue in County of Wayne v. Hathcock is about the constitutionality of a municipality to use the Economic Corporations Act to condemn a private property…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Americas Constitution
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "America's Constitution"

Analysis of Michigan Court Decision The major issue in County of Wayne v. Hathcock is about the constitutionality of a municipality to use the Economic Corporations Act to condemn a private property and transfer its ownership and use to a private corporation. This case was filed by defendants (Hancock et al) to seek redress when the defendant (County of Wayne) decided to evict residents living within a two-kilometer radius to pave way for the construction of a technology and bus park. This was to be used for constructing recreational facilities, hotel, corporate mall and conference center. All these were being done with the aim of creating up to 30,000 jobs and help in generating annual tax revenue of $350 million. By taking this action, the plaintiff queried if it was really constitutional. Although it was done under the guidance of the Taking Clauses of the Fifth Amendment, it was challenged for not in a compliance with the public purpose. However, according to the Michigan Comp Laws clause 213.23, a county government has an authority to condemn a private property and use it for public purposes. Meaning, whenever a municipality decides to condemn a private property, it should be used for the activities which are meant for the common good such as creation of employment opportunities to the citizens. So, like in this case, the municipality was constructing the park to help in generating numerous jobs to the people. This would be a good initiative that would help in reducing the high rate of unemployment within the municipality and helping the municipality to increase its revenues through taxation. As clearly spelt out in the article 10(2) of the Michigan Constitution, any constitutional condemnation should be justly done. Meaning, whenever the government seizes a private property, the owner must be fairly and justly compensated. A fair compensation simply refers to giving financial payments that correspond to the current and actual market value of the property as at the time of condemnation (Amar93). Therefore, while planning to build such a big park, the County of Wayne must be ready to compensate all the individual owners whose property has been condemned. After all, condemnation is a constitutional process that is permitted by the law if done for a public purpose. Indeed, County of Wayne v. Hathcock can be compared to Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit in which the city seized private property and transferred its ownership to a private corporation. In order to respond to the high rate of unemployment, the city opted to evict a large number of people from their respective homes to create room for the General Motors to build a plant. However, despite the motive, the action was challenged in the court of law so as to determine if it was constitutional for the city to condemn private property and give it away to a private corporation. Although the city’s actions are incompliance with the taking clause of the Fifth Amendment, it was necessary to determine if the city had not violated individual rights. Questions were raised if the city was constitutionally justified to seize private property and transfer its ownership to a private corporation. It was held that this was a constitutional act because it was done in compliance with the law. The establishment of the plant would help in the creation of employment to the people of municipality (Harper 37). The municipality had not erred since the new plant would be for a public purpose. Provided that fair compensation was given, the project was to go on as planned. This ruling was similar to that of County of Wayne v. Hathcock which had also been done in compliance with the condemnation laws. A similar scenario is evidenced in Kelo v. City of New London in which the city had been accused of violating the eminent domain laws. This followed its action to take private property and transfer it to a private organization for use. Upon a thorough scrutiny of the la, the court ruled that the city had not violated the law. Even if it transferred the ownership of a private land to a private developer, it was in a compliance with the taking clause of the Fifth Amendment. The court ruled that the action was a genuine one and permissible by the law. By allowing the private corporation to own the land, a lot of benefits would be gotten such as job creation and economic growth (Harper 21). Based on this discussion, it is quite clear that these cases fall under the taking clause of the Fifth Amendment of the US Constitution. According to this clause, the government is permitted by the law to seize a private property. However, whenever this is done, such property should be taken by the government and exclusively availed for public use. In other words, the condemned property should be used for a project that is aimed at helping the general public such as job creation, revenue generation and economic growth. This is exactly what happened in the County of Wayne v. Hathcock case. The court ruled that the seizure of the private property was aimed at creating jobs to tens of millions of Americans. In conclusion, County of Wayne v. Hathcock is a typical case that shows the application and constitutionality of the taking clause of the Fifth Amendment of the constitution. Although the municipality was accused of ‘trespassing’ to private property, its action was justified by the law because they would be put into public use. If not initiated, there would be more unemployment which the municipality should be dealing with at whatever costs (Amar 72) However, as seen in Kelo v. City of New London and Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit, the seized property should be fairly compensated. Having said all these, I would like to express my satisfaction with the ruling. It is constitutional for the individual liberties such as property ownership rights to be infringed for the sake of common good. This is what would be achieved if the projects were completed as they would create lots of jobs and help in growing the municipality’s economy. Works Cited Amar, Akhil. America's Constitution. New York: Random House, 2005. Print. Harper, Timothy. The Complete Idiot's Guide to the U.S. Constitution. Penguin Group, 2007. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“America's Constitution Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 3”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1685250-undecided
(America'S Constitution Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 3)
https://studentshare.org/law/1685250-undecided.
“America'S Constitution Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 3”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1685250-undecided.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF America's Constitution

Police Interrogation and Due Process

constitution 5th amendment enumerates five main individual freedoms namely; the right to be free from what can be termed to be multiples punishments and prosecutions for a single criminal offense, the right for a defendant to be indicted by a definable impartial grand jury before engaging to be tried in any federal criminal offense, the right for one to receive just compensation when govern comes in and takes private property for public use, right to have all individuals to be protected by DUE … PROCESS OF LAW and finally, the right to be free from government bound SELF INCRIMINATION....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Raising Voices Against Bigotries

Adbusters suggested September, 17 as the date for the initiation of the protest as it corresponds with the America's Constitution Day (Fleming, 2011).... Occupy Wall Street Introduction History reveals that sooner or later, people stood up against prejudice.... With the increasing awareness and past experiences, courage is being displayed by people to raise their voice against bigotries....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Civil Liberties

Civil liberties are enshrined in the country's constitution either by doing first amendments, legislation or by common law.... The police have to deliver correct judgments without contravening the constitution.... In the end, the students clearly understand that their rights have been respected as stated in the constitution while they too have to act in a way that will show their respect for other citizens.... The majority (white) and the minority (blacks) all have equal rights in the constitution....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

How did the Constitution impact the development of American freedom

Name: Instructor: Task: Date: The constitution's impact on American freedom The constitutional progress commenced after the 1776 attainment of sovereignty.... Since achieving a consensus among the thirteen states was a great challenge, the necessity for a new document led to the drafting of the constitution.... Drafted in 1787 and ratified in 1788, the constitution became operational in 1789.... The constitution would create a powerful central government as required by proponents of its drafting....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

American Constitution

Time and again the question has been asked: Is the United States constitution a finely crafted document; or is it a document that was put together without extensive forethought?... First,… Second, that the constitution is perhaps the most enduring nation-state document by which a country has been governed.... The Articles of Confederation were the skeletal framework within which the newly On the Nature of the United s constitution Introduction Time and again the question has been asked: Is the United s constitution a finely crafted document; or is it a document that was put together without extensive forethought?...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Political Reflections on the Original American Constitution

This paper "Political Reflections on the Original American constitution" discusses the American constitution from the perspective of pragmatic politics.... The author assesses the text of the original constitution of the United States of America in relation to the political situation of America.... hellip; Reading the original American constitution, it is easy to acquire the impression that our forefathers have been elitist and unjust....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

The Twenty Seven Amendments to the Constitution of America

Amendment 3 The constitution states that soldiers should be privately contained to thwart them from being a peril to the public.... The constitution should treat such a person as suspect and should be protected from personal incriminating substantiations.... Amendment 1 The amendment bars the congress from instituting any policies which directly affects the freedom of people to religion, barring the liberty of the press, challenging the already existing rules of a public member petitioning the government for a redress of grievances, and limiting a person's freedom of speech....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

American Constitution Law 3 J

Under the United States constitution, Johnson cannot be tried for the… e crime twice under the Fifth Amendment, which ascertains that an individual shall not be tried twice for the same crime in the same jurisdiction (Stephens & Scheb, 2008). This rule falls under the Double Jeopardy Clause that prohibits the law from prosecuting the individual Concept of Double Jeopardy Concept of Double Jeopardy Dear ……….... Under the United States constitution, Johnson cannot be tried for the same crime twice under the Fifth Amendment, which ascertains that an individual shall not be tried twice for the same crime in the same jurisdiction (Stephens & Scheb, 2008)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us