StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Changes that Would Take Place if A Country Changed From a Unitary to a Federal System - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Changes that Would Take Place if A Country Changed From a Unitary to a Federal System" discusses changes in a unitary system of government to a federal system that would bring about the creation of law-making bodies at the different levels of government…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Changes that Would Take Place if A Country Changed From a Unitary to a Federal System
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Changes that Would Take Place if A Country Changed From a Unitary to a Federal System"

THE AL APPROACH: CHANGES THAT WOULD TAKE PLACE IF A COUNTRY CHANGED FROM A UNITARY TO A FEDERAL SYSTEM (2007) INTRODUCTION Comparative public administration brings about the understanding of the institutional structures of government in different governmental administration. According to Hague & Harrop (2004), internationally comparative approach is needed. Given problems of conceptualization, the availability of reliable and comparable data, and the (sometimes-subtle) differences between political-administrative systems, a focused comparison has the best chances of being completed satisfactorily. Institutional power structure of a system of government is based on how the constitutional allocation of power to office holder is patterned. In addition, how relationship and power sharing affect the different public servants in their different positional capacity. System of government has to do with pattern of how power allocation is being shared within the different arms and levels of government. The unitary system of government maintain the centralization of power within the central government with a subsidiary power position reserved for regional and local government. The central government in a unitary state has the power to usurp and take control of the jurisdictional functional areas of these subordinate government levels without prior notice of any difficult amendment procedure. The case is not so in a federal system of government where power among the different levels of government exist as coordinates, rather than a superior- subordinates relationship. Here, the role and jurisdictional power of each levels of government within the federal state is explicitly spelt out by the constitution of the state. Thus, the central or federal government has no power to take over the constitutional functions of the state or local governments. In such institutional power setting, the constitution would spell all tasks that are exclusive to the federal government only. Here, the exclusive list contains these functions reserved for the federal government, while the concurrent list states those functions which the federal government and other levels of government can carry out concurrently. The residual list states functions reserved for the states governments and local authorities. Thus, the institutional power structure of a state is determined by the adopted system of government. It is pertinent to state here that there is nothing, as a clear-cut federalist state and a pure unitary state, as in a unitary state there exist a level of decentralization, as well as a federal state where there is a level of centralization of power. In this view, Bakvis (1980:4) argues, "The distinction between federal and non-federal systems is not clear-cut. It is very difficult to find a purely federal state that meets all the criteria concerning the independent and co-ordinate status of governments as originally specified by K.C. Wheare (1946). At the same time, it would be unusual to find a system that can be called a purely unitary state. Most polities are decentralized in some form, even if it is only at the administrative level". CHANGES THAT WOULD TAKE PLACE IF A COUNTRY CHANGED FROM A UNITARY TO A FEDERAL SYSTEM As already stated in the previous paragraph, a unitary state is one that is characterized by centralized power distribution revolving around the central government. For a country to transfer its governmental institutional setup to adapt to a federal system from a unitary system there would be decentralization of power from the central government to the other levels of government. The devolution of power here would mean that other tiers of government would not be subordinate to central government, but they would exist as coordinates, with autonomous power to operate in their constitutional given jurisdictional area. Here, there is the need for coexistence and harmony in the relationship that would take place among these tiers of government. According to Burgess (2000), "According to this perspective, the concept of covenantal federalism embodies a set of normative principles which binds partners together in a moral contract or agreement of trust. The act of coming together remains a 'political bargain' but it is more than just this; it is also based upon mutual recognition, tolerance, respect, obligation, and responsibility". In the same vain, Mc Kay (2001:2) argues that institutional devices such as proportional representation are used as a means of avoiding conflict and the creation of harmonious existence in a federating state. Thus, the major change that would need to take place when a country is changing from a unitary system of government to a federal system is the restructuring of power base among the different tiers of government. This should be carried out based on tolerance for other components that make up the political system. The constitution of the country need to spell out vividly the jurisdictional operational is of each level of government. For instance, a unitary state like the United Kingdom and Ghana, if in anyway they decide to change to a federal state, they would need to decentralize their power structure and give other tiers of government the power to operate autonomously, as is witnessed in a federal state like the United States of America, Canada, India, and Nigeria. Though US are a federal state, its constitution practiced a highly centralized federal structure. The constitution of a state does not reflect the actual power sharing within a state. "Formal constitutional arrangements are not just accurate guide in the distribution of power between central and state authorities" (ibid). According to Wichendorfer (2001), federalism is a binding force that bind a nation together especially in an ethnic pluralized society. The political institutionalism has variables of political institutions and political actors that have the capability of making rational decisions. Thus, as a state engages in a federalist system of government, it is taking a turn to ensure that the various ethnic groupings are united together and the consolidation of a solidarity among the components parts that make up the state. "It is then difficult to enforce change within a federated state" (ibid). This means in a unitary state where there is a loose institutional framework, this will be replaced with a more solid institutional framework where there is rigorous amendment procedures to established institutions. Another changes that would occur in the change from a unitary system of government to a federal government is that the Intergovernmental relations (IGR) would move from an inclusive pattern (where the central government has control over the operations of regional and local government functions) to a separated typology where each level of government operates autonomously, with the constitution clearly stating their relationship. According to Deil S. Wright 3 typology of IGR, which include separated, inclusive, and overlapping models, these models take place within a unitary and federal government relationship. Thus, the changes in system of unitary system of government to federal system would make the relationship between the different levels of government to be clearly spelt out in the constitution. It is seen that in federal states like Nigeria, USA, Canada, the intergovernmental relationship is clearly stated in the constitution and the central government cannot usurp into the functional areas of other levels of government without due and proper consultations. This may be tolerated in a unitary state like UK and Ghana. Furthermore, it is expected that fiscal relationships among tiers of government be clearly expressed by the constitution. Here, the different levels of government are expected to have statutory allocation from the federation account. Largely the levels of government would have the autonomy to engage in internally generated revenue (IGR), where they would use this to support the statutory allocation from the federation account. The change in system of government from a unitary to a federal system would bring about different sets of bureaucrats at the federal, state, and local government levels. These would operate at different capacities. The federal civil servants are to be under the control of the federal government, and they would be remunerated by the federal government. This applies to other level of civil servants controlled by the state and local government. The change in unitary system of government to federal system would bring about the creation of law making bodies at the different levels of government. In country like Nigeria, outside the federal national senate and house of assembly, there are state houses of assemblies in the different 31 states of the federation. Also in US, outside the Senate and Congress at the national level, each state of the federation has its own law making body. This is not so in a unitary state as United Kingdom and Ghana, as there are only national legislative body. REFERENCES Bakvis, Herman (1981), Federalism and the Organization of Political Life: Canada in Comparative Perspective. Kingston, Ontario: Institute of Intergovernmental Relations, Queen's University Burgess, Michael (2000), Federalism and European Union: The Building of Europe, 1950-2000. London: Routledge Burgess M. and A. Gagner (1993), Comparative Federalism and Federations, Harvester Wheatsheaf Hague, R. and M. Harrop (2004), Comparative Government and Politics, Palgrave Macmillan. McKay, David. (2001), Designing Europe: comparative lessons from federal experience, Oxford University Press Smith, G. (1995), Federalism: the Multi ethnic Challenge, Longman Swendon, W. (2006) Federalism and Regionalism in Western Europe, Palgrave Macmillan Wichendorfer-Schmidt, U. (2001), Federalism and Political Performance, Routledge Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Institutional Approach: Changes That Would Take Place If A Country Essay”, n.d.)
The Institutional Approach: Changes That Would Take Place If A Country Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503282-the-institutional-approach-changes-that-would-take-place-if-a-country-changed-from-a-unitary-to-a-federal-system
(The Institutional Approach: Changes That Would Take Place If A Country Essay)
The Institutional Approach: Changes That Would Take Place If A Country Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503282-the-institutional-approach-changes-that-would-take-place-if-a-country-changed-from-a-unitary-to-a-federal-system.
“The Institutional Approach: Changes That Would Take Place If A Country Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503282-the-institutional-approach-changes-that-would-take-place-if-a-country-changed-from-a-unitary-to-a-federal-system.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Changes that Would Take Place if A Country Changed From a Unitary to a Federal System

Change And Change Management At Sony

The first change that occurred at the company was the drop in the value of the company share from a high of $150 to a very low value of $25.... Over the product lines, the decision was to make it possible for easier decision making processes to take place.... The second change was that one of breaking from the norm (cultural change).... This was a change from the normal norm in which only Japanese top management had been in control....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Recent Political Changes in the Middle East

The general elections in Lebanon which took place in 2009 hogged the limelight, the minimum age to vote was 21 that time, the age was to be changed from 21 to 18 but this required a constitutional bill to be passed which did not happen and things remained as they were, completely unchanged.... The paper 'Recent Political Changes in the Middle East' focuses on the significant events in Egypt, Tunisia, Libya, and Lebanon, the current and future relationship of Lebanon with its neighbors, emphasizing on Doha agreement which was introduced to put an end to the violence in the country....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework

The Strengths and Weaknesses of Traditional Constitution of Britain

A codified constitution is usually based on one document and is more likely to be inflexible while a federal constitution divides power into two parts of the government.... Britain is an example of a country that lacks a written constitution though some of its parts may be in written form.... A constitution can be codified or not codified, federal or unitary, and flexible or rigid.... It is these rules that show a picture of the country's values and nature....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Post Confederation Canada

Quasi federalism occurs when a state appears as if is divided into jurisdictions however is in fact a unitary state without any divided authority.... Instead, people considered quasi federalism as a system... In this case, one political dominated the provincial level whereas opposition affirmed control at the federal level.... A political scientist, Russell, argues that, in the case of contemporary politics Canada has experienced the same pattern of federal Conservative control even after the Mulroney Conservatives4....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

The Australian Federal System

he Australian federal system has generally worked satisfactorily even though it had undergone substantial changes in the years following its establishment.... There is a general consensus that the Australian federal system does not work as well as it should, keeping in view the commercial operations, management, and administrative environment.... The essential characteristics of a federal constitution are the supremacy of a written constitution....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Economic History

The cycles and changes that characterize each period are the driving force in how the world economies work together to create a different set of development in civilization.... The main changes that have occurred in the development of world economies have changed with the political rise and fall of power.... The area went through both Europe and Africa and reached ports that were from India, which provided more opportunities for trade.... he main rise and fall in power also led to changes within the world economy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Significant Changes in Police Role

It is therefore critical to understand that the challenges and opportunities available to Police are unique in nature and need to be viewed from the perspective of the changes which have taken place since 9/11.... 9/11 was one of the events which changed many things and virtually shifted the existing paradigm for the security and policing methods.... The original duty or the mission of Police, as outlined by Sir Robert Peel, is to prevent crime and disorder, however, the overall sensitivity and the responsibilities of Policies have radically changed in the wake of the current situation....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Health Care System in New Zealand

from a fundamentally completely public system introduced in the 20th century, recent reforms have led to the adoption of health and market insurance components mainly in the past three decades, generating a mixture of the public-private system for healthcare provision (Davis & Ashton 23).... The paper "Health Care system in New Zealand " is a great example of a case study on health sciences and medicine.... The paper "Health Care system in New Zealand " is a great example of a case study on health sciences and medicine....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us