StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Friendship in A Passage to India - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Friendship in A Passage to India" focuses on the critical analysis of the particular characteristics which allowed Fielding to befriend Dr. Aziz, and the very real limits of this friendship as constrained by issues of law and nationalism…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
Friendship in A Passage to India
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Friendship in A Passage to India"

As an initial matter, it is quite true that Fielding and Dr. Aziz established a genuine friendship. This owes a great deal to Fielding’s fiercely independent nature. Unlike other British officials who adopted a condescending attitude toward the native people, Fielding treated the Indians with a sense of decency and respect. He wasn’t an idealist, but he did tend to approach issues and people from an objective and open-minded point of view. He didn’t allow his perceptions of India to be affected negatively by bias or stereotypes. These qualities attracted Dr. Aziz and distinguished Fielding from the other British officials. Indeed, when Dr. Aziz was subsequently accused of assault by Adela, Fielding broke with the British and lent his support to the Indians. In short, the qualities that allowed Fielding’s friendship with Dr. Aziz to flourish were his independence of mind, his conviction in the notion of an objective justice for all, and his strength of character in declaring and acting on his beliefs. Fielding was a principled man and Dr Aziz respected him in this way.

That there were very real limits to this friendship, however, is beyond doubt.  There are moments, in the beginning of the novel when Dr. Aziz is very accommodating and accepting of the British. He is generous to his British friends, particularly Fielding and Mrs. Moore. The assault charges filed by Adela, however, are a turning point in the novel; indeed, this is where the limits of the friendship between Fielding and Dr. Aziz are most particularly defined and drawn. These men are not equals under the law. The Indians are not entitled to a presumption of innocence; quite the contrary, they are presumed guilty. More, they are not considered honest and their testimony is frowned upon and disbelieved under British law. There is a double standard at work, an in-egalitarian double standard that serves as a barrier to the friendship between the British and the Indians.

Issues of nationalism only serve to exacerbate the tensions. If the unequal application of the law functions to separate people, then the competing senses of nationalism tend to inflame the passions of the people trying to co-exist. How can Fielding ever defend an oppressive imperialism given his stated beliefs in justice? Indeed, he cannot and his disgust and frustration ultimately persuade him to leave India. In sum, the friendship between Fielding and Dr. Aziz is limited in very real ways. The law treats them unequally, there are competing struggles for influence and power, and nationalism sharpens the disputes. It sharpens the disputes because people are compelled to take sides. Friendships are casualties of these types of conflicting loyalties.

The final issue is whether in a context such as Fielding and Dr. Aziz existed, egalitarian friendships are truly able to persist. This is an extraordinarily difficult question. One might refer to the American Civil War as an analogy.  In this case, fathers, sons, and brothers went to war on opposite sides. Families were divided, and destroyed, and friendships were damaged beyond repair. There were similar issues of unequal treatment under the law and a fierce sort of nationalism that erupted. In the North, the nationalism manifested itself in terms of the need to preserve the Union. In the South, nationalism manifested itself in terms of actual declarations of secession and calls for independence. This analogy is illuminating because it happened within a country with similar ethnic groups, legal principles, and religious backgrounds. In Fielding and Dr. Aziz’s case, the differences were far more significant. The point is that the forces at work, the emotions, and the injustices felt, were much stronger in the case of the British oppression of India than those experienced during the American Civil War. The differences, such as religion and culture, were far greater. That said, I don’t believe that friendships can endure the oppression of imperialism. The strains are too great, and people do have to choose sides. At best, friendships that might survive are badly damaged.

In the final analysis, Fielding and Dr. Aziz had much in common. They were both educated men and they were both willing to offer their friendship to people of other nationalities.  The unequal treatment of Indians under British law, and the resulting nationalism, however, set up barriers to the development of this friendship. Their friendship, perhaps, was doomed from the very beginning.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Passage to India Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525394-a-passage-to-india
(A Passage to India Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525394-a-passage-to-india.
“A Passage to India Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525394-a-passage-to-india.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Friendship in A Passage to India

Illusions and disillusionment in A Passage to India

Forster in his a passage to india creates a world which is full of illusions.... Forster in his a passage to india creates a world which is full of illusions.... Crews relates that in Forster's novel “ Romantic love, God's love , and friendship are exposed as futile.... Aziz' belief in friendship shatters” ( qtd in Koponen 39).... friendship Aziz's concept of friendship amounts to a mythic belief in the holiness and strength of this bond and its power in bringing people close together....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Analysis and Interpretation to Develop a Narrowly Focused Theme in A Passage to India

Name Surname Supervisor Subject Date On a Theme in ‘a passage to india' a passage to india by E.... That is why perhaps Fielding's friendship with Aziz is more enchanting than any other Anglo Indians; however, he is quick to add that how long Fielding can maintain such relationship in a Colonial india is worth watching.... In the beginning, Forster poses a question through Hamidullah and Mahmoud Ali when they discuss "Whether or not it is possible to be friends with an Englishman" (passage 5)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

A Passage to India Analysis

The following paper "a passage to india" provides a discussion and interpretation in order to develop a narrowly focused theme in a novel ‘a passage to india' by E.... ‘a passage to india' is one of the greatest works produced by E.... Moore and Adela Quested, who travel to india.... For a short period of time, the group develops a great level of understanding and together they all begin to explore various areas of india....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Novel a Passage to India

From the paper "The Novel a passage to india" it is clear that Mrs.... Moore comes to india as a good Christian, but her experience in India draws her to the spiritual world rather than the traditional religious one and she leaves India with her faith shaken.... t makes her vulnerable to the sort of external influences that are likely to be encountered in india, particularly the india of a century ago, driven by ritual, faith, and superstition....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Sexuality in Forsters Passage to India

Forster's novel a passage to india.... Forster's most famous novel a passage to india (first published in 1924) has been critically discussed in the light of colonialism, freethinking, modernism, traditions, sexuality and the connection between the personal and political....
14 Pages (3500 words) Book Report/Review

Rebekah Nathan's My Freshman Year

In the spring of 2002, an anthropologist professor, under the alias of Rebekah Nathan, conducted a study in order to represent the typical American university and its freshman student culture.... As a professor at the unnamed university in which she conducted her fieldwork, Rebekah Nathan asks an important question at the end of her book, My Freshman Year....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

A Passage to India by Foster

The paper "a passage to india by Foster" highlights that generally speaking, Ronny is a character who devalues Indians and their culture.... For all the characters india is a 'muddle'.... Thus it jerks their friendship deeply.... He was brought up with an open-minded outlook, but gradually it gives its way to a suspicious attitude to the Indians....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Relationship between the Colonizer and the Colonized

in a passage to india, there were inevitable sections that tackled imperialism and colonization.... This paper "Relationship between the Colonizer and the Colonized" cites a passage to india by E.... a passage to india portrayed a picture of the Indian society under British rule.... a passage to india, which is considered one of the paramount novels of the twentieth century, was among Forster's last novels.... n fact, a passage to india has been praised for its format invention and a good tragedy....
12 Pages (3000 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us