StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Argument Against the Existence of God - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
J.L Mackie's, "Evil and Omnipotence" is an argument against the existence of an omnipotent and wholly good God on the basis of the problem of evil. According to theological doctrine, God is omnibenevolent but this belief is rendered inconsistent by the presence of evil in the world and the theologian can subscribe to it only by divorcing himself from reason…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
The Argument Against the Existence of God
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Argument Against the Existence of God"

Download file to see previous pages

The theologian embraces three propositions - God is omnipotent, God is good and evil exists. Mackie's brilliant argument for the problem of evil has shown that the first two propositions cannot be true while the third exists. He has made use of two additional premises to drive the point home. He calls these "quasi-logical rules connecting the terms 'good', 'evil', and 'omnipotent'" (Mackie 78). These additional propositions state that good is in a state of opposition with evil and seeks to eliminate it and that omnipotence is without limits.

Therefore Mackie's argument and the problem of evil has decimated the very core of theistic belief by claiming that "the several parts of the essential theological doctrine are inconsistent with one another, so that the theologian can maintain his position as a whole only by a much more extreme rejection of reason" (Mackie 77). Thus his argument calls for a complete reconstruction of the theological doctrine as we know it. At the onset Mackie outlines certain adequate solutions to the problem of evil that is also consistent with the essential theistic propositions or which rejects one or more of the propositions.

He makes it clear that only those who believe that God is omnipotent and wholly good are confounded by this problem. . Mackie then turns his attention to four solutions that he calls fallacious because they overtly adhere to the integral theological propositions while inadvertently or covertly rejecting one or more of them while attempting to tackle the problem of evil. The first of these fallacious solutions is that it is not possible for good to exist without evil. Mackie asserts that this solution does explain away the presence of evil but a whole series of problems crop up consequently.

For instance it questions God's omnipotence because it implies that God cannot create one without the other and is invariably bound by the rules of logic. Further this solution undermines God's goodness as it appears that God is not opposed to evil if it is deemed necessary. Besides, the existing evil is far in excess of the amount needed to serve as a mere counterpart to good. Some people claim that evil is necessary as a means to good. This view according to Mackie contradicts the theist's view of God's omnipotence as it suggests that God's power is subject to the law of cause and effect.

Therefore this argument as seen by Mackie does not hold much water as it severely detracts from God's omnipotence. The third solution to the problem of evil is that the world with its attendant evil is a better place than one without. By way of explanation Mackie classifies good and evil into levels. He calls pain and other forms of physical discomfiture first order evils whereas pleasure constitutes first order good. First order evil is necessary to bring out second order goods like benevolence, courage, fortitude and the like which far outweighs first order evils.

But Mackie states that this argument falls apart as it does not take into

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Argument Against the Existence of God Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1530545-the-argument-against-the-existence-of-god
(The Argument Against the Existence of God Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1530545-the-argument-against-the-existence-of-god.
“The Argument Against the Existence of God Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1530545-the-argument-against-the-existence-of-god.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Argument Against the Existence of God

Theism: Examples and Definition

Many authors have had an argument in support of theism and the existence of god as a supernatural being, one of these arguments for theism is discussed in this paper.... This implies that with one the pure who are allowed to enter into the after-death world, thus the existence of god.... This review "Theism: Examples and Definition" discusses an argument in support of theism and existences of god as a supernatural being, one of these arguments for theism are discussed in this paper....
3 Pages (750 words) Literature review

Assessing Traditional Arguments about God's Existence

According to him, the existence of god can be derived from the belief that a being, which is more powerful than any other can be, conceived (Pojman 54).... In supporting the argument, the proponents argue that disputing the existence of god is awkward, like the act of imagining that a four-sided triangle, which cannot be drawn (Malcolm 41-50).... These differences serve to show that the different Gods conceived by the different groups can be flawed; therefore, the existence of a more superior being cannot be disputed....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Argument on Mackie's Analysis on the Existence of God

This paper ''Argument on Mackie's Analysis on the existence of god'' tells that Since the start of western thought, philosophers and other scholars have battled with the issue of the existence of god.... The argument presented in this paper will defend a position that reconciles the presence of God with the presence of wickedness, thus highlighting the existence of god.... nbsp;       The argument for the existence of god             Mackie's argument is quite contradictory since by appreciating the existence of evil, he unknowingly also acknowledges the existence of god despite such evil....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Response to McCloskey's Article

The focus of the paper "Response to McCloskey's Article" is on critical of the conventional arguments for God's existence, the issue of the existence of god, major arguments, several points of view about God's existence, lack of substantive proof, the notion of Gods existence.... In his article, he puts emphasis on the point that evident proofs of nature cannot adequately elucidate the existence of god.... Moreover, looking keenly at the arguments he puts across it lacks substance, one of those is the existence of evil, which he says is proof God does not exist....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Four Arguments for the Existence of God

The four arguments for the existence of god are ontological, which is when God exists if we can argue and conceive this, if we base our feelings of his existence off of intuition; cosmological, which is the belief that for the universe to exist as it does, then there must have… en a God that had created it; teleological, which is when people believe that God exist because of an order and the details of a creation, such as human lives; and the moral argument, which states that there could be no morality without God....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Explain and evaluate Bebe's teleological argument for the existence of God

A design argument is He was one of the proponents of intelligent design supporting the existence of god, Behe initially supported the scientific theory, however after studying Evolution by Michael Denton changed his mind and started to question the evolution theory.... His logic was similar with other proponents such as the William Paley of 1802 who gave the proof of the existence of the divine creator.... god is considered as a supernatural being whose existence is full of mysteries and have been argued by many philosophers, scientist and the theologians, some are against Gods existence while others supports his existence, their ideas are based on different facts trying to give a… The wide varieties of such arguments categorized as the metaphysical, subjective, and logical....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Arguments about God's existence

To most scholars of theology, the explanation about the existence of god raises pertinent issues within any religion.... The explanation about the existence of god is a subject that has been posited by several theoretical explanations.... Some of the arguments and explanations that have been used by scholars to describe the existence of god include the cosmological argument, the teleological argument, and the ontological explanations.... This paper discuses the teleological perspective that tries to explain the existence of god....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Evaluation of the Evil-god Hypothesis

The problem can hence be sharpened by observing that God will most probably not allow the existence of any gratuitous suffering.... Having the belief of god's existence, as they maintain, does not resemble having the belief that fairies or Santa are in existence.... The second problem, which is the evidential problem, is founded on the assumption that the second argument is incompatible with the first argument logically, but on the assumption that the second argument avails good evidence against the first argument....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us