StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Presence Overseas - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Hardly had the fires died down in the suburbs of Paris, as the November rioting by immigrant youths petered out, than the flames of another conflict fed by France's colonial past began to sweep through France's political landscape.
The law of February 23, 2005, as it is known, was intended to recognize the contribution of the 'harkis', the 200,000 or so Algerians who fought alongside France's colonial troops in their country's war of independence, from 1954-62, before being abandoned to a dreadful fate when the French withdrew - "about 130,000 were executed as traitors." (Henley, 2005)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Presence Overseas
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Presence Overseas"

Download file to see previous pages

This law, otherwise known as the 'February 23, 2005' law, was passed quietly in February of 2005, but came to prominence in the autumn when there was an overwhelming vote by conservative deputies against a bid to revoke the phrase. This touched off on a debate about whether France, whose empire ended in bloody wars in Indochina and Algeria, had learnt from its colonial experience. The trouble started in February when lawmakers quietly slipped a clause into a bill requiring schools to "recognize in particular the positive character of the French overseas presence, notably in North Africa.

" Some of the key players in this situation would be: President Jacques Chirac of Paris, Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin, Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy, Gilles Manceron, and Olivier Petre-Grenouilleau - a respected historian who was accused of making statements in an interview which implied that the slave trade was not a crime against humanity. (In fact, he said that it didn't constitute genocide). Gilles Manceron noted that for some historians, the treatment of the harkis exemplifies how France has basically failed to deal with aspects of its past, saying "The state put them in military camps or in isolated camps in forests, cut off from the rest of the French population.

This isolation is comparable to the treatment of indigenous people in the colonies." (Gehmlich, 2006). Hamlaoui Mekachera, junior minister for veterans' affairs who is also of Algerian origin and in fact actually fought for the French army during the Algerian war, praised the law, saying it was "a historic moment for people of all origins who have been repatriated." He went on to say, "The current debate must not allow us to forget the real range of measures (the law) contains." (Geimlich, 2006).

Who Wants a Repeal of the law and who Does not, and why More than 1000 historians, writers and intellectuals have signed a petition demanding the repeal of this law. "In retaining only the positive aspects of colonialism this law imposes an official lie on massacres that at times went as far as genocide on the slave trade, and on the racism that France has inherited," says the petition, which has also been signed by one of France's best-loved humorists, Guy Bedos, and a leading film director, Patrice Chereau.

The principal objection to the law is

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Essay”, n.d.)
The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532202-the-controversy-surrounding-the-law-on-the-positive-role-of-the-french-presence-overseas
(The Controversy Surrounding the Law on the Positive Role of the French Essay)
The Controversy Surrounding the Law on the Positive Role of the French Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532202-the-controversy-surrounding-the-law-on-the-positive-role-of-the-french-presence-overseas.
“The Controversy Surrounding the Law on the Positive Role of the French Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532202-the-controversy-surrounding-the-law-on-the-positive-role-of-the-french-presence-overseas.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Controversy Surrounding the law on the Positive Role of the French Presence Overseas

The silent language in Overseas Business

Contradictorily the french, Germans and the English have their own way of utilizing material possessions.... The Silent Language in overseas Business Table of Contents Thesis Statement 3 Discussion 3 Works Cited 7 Thesis Statement Based on this particular notion, the following discussion would present an elaborative explanation of the role played by silent language in overseas business with reference to the explanations given in the article titled “The Silent Language of overseas Business” by Edward T....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The British Overseas Trade

The paper 'The British overseas Trade' presents overseas trade, slavery, war, and taxation that were linked together during the eighteenth century.... The interconnectedness of overseas trade, slavery, war, and taxation shall be addressed by this paper.... It is important to note, however, that British colonialism had an influential role in the linkage among the four factors....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Controversies Surrounding Constructive Trusts

This paper "Controversies Surrounding Constructive Trusts" sheds some light on constructive trusts that can be grouped in the category of implied trusts, as they are established by the effect of a court ruling or the law, pertaining to any transfer of assets.... Accordingly, the purpose of constructive trusts should revolve around its binding effect on the issues of law in developing the major issues like honoring commitments, disgorging gains and repairing losses....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The Male Role in French Cinema

The films also put accentuation on the instinct of the female, and the traditional role of the male is then found at the mercy of this female force.... This essay will focus on the role of the male in the film; it will assess which forms the male role has taken in film and for which message it was intended to portray.... the french male role is often the suave, less masculine in terms of violence, yet more beautiful and poetic.... The paper "The Male Role in french Cinema" highlights that the modern man does not take the typical role any more, and this is increasingly so in the film industry, especially in France....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Western Civilization: French Revolution to the Present

The proposed changes met a lot of hostility from the french Nobles.... He successfully persuaded the french, under Luis to help them against the British.... Luis came into power after the death of his father, Louis, Dauphin of France, in 1774.... He came into power with quite a number of reformation agendas, some which were opposed by the… He even wanted to enforce the enlightenment ideas in his kingdom....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

France Past Present and Future

Louis XIV and Richelieu from 1635-1748 embarked on a mission to further expand the territories of the french Kingdom towards the Rhine and the north.... Earlier the two had remained as distinct regions but that marriage brought about the annexation of the two into the french Kingdom in the year 1532.... his is because after the french had lost the french Flanders in 1526, the Austrian royal houses situated near f the french Capital had started to pose some danger....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Solutions to Controversies Surrounding Healthcare in the United States

It is important for the United States to carefully formulate and proceed to implement policies that will help the country reduce the over 17% of gross domestic… At present there are a number of solutions that can be implemented so as to resolve the current controversy surround the provision of healthcare within the United States....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Distinction Between Religion and Politics in France

Sarkozy shocked the french press with his apparent acquiescence to what he thought the Pontiff might want to hear regarding the Church's role in French politics.... hellip; “There has probably never been a French president who defended his country's Catholic heritage so vigorously,” wrote the french Catholic daily La Croix as quoted by Reuters (2007).... the french concept of laïcité while generally viewed as the separation of church and state goes much deeper into the french consciousness, history and law....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us