StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Judgment at Nuremberg - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
1. Judgment at Nuremberg is a powerful persuasive film by producer-director, Stanley Kramer, with Spencer Tracy playing the main protagonist of chief American judge, Dan Haywood. When four Nazi German Judges are put on trial for abetting holocaust during the Second World War, Haywood was at the helm to deliver the verdict…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Judgment at Nuremberg
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Judgment at Nuremberg"

Judgment at Nuremberg is a powerful persuasive film by producer-director, Stanley Kramer, with Spencer Tracy playing the main protagonist of chief American judge, Dan Haywood. When four Nazi German Judges are put on trial for abetting holocaust during the Second World War, Haywood was at the helm to deliver the verdict. Although, the actions of the German judges were a clear case of violation of human rights, Haywood played by Spencer Tracy faces slight ethical and moral dilemmas due to the background of one of the judges and also due to the changed political climate.

Among the judges, Ernst Janning (portrayed by Burt Lancaster), was slightly different from others because he was an accomplished legal scholar, who drafted the strong Weimar constitution, and even expressed his opposition to Hitler. Due to this positive background, Tracy’s character has some dilemmas regarding Janning’s role in Holocaust. However, removing those mental dilemmas, and with only a minor conflict between what he feels “is lawful" and "is ethical", he convicts all the judges including Janning.

Against Janning, he had strong evidences overriding any dilemmas. That is, despite his favorable credentials, in the Feldenstein case, Janning convicted Feldenstein although he is perceived as an innocent and importantly ordered imprisonment of many innocent Jews concentration camps and thereby facilitated their deaths in. 2. It is clear that although Janning had a creditable background, he has committed or facilitated crimes against the humanity, and thus has to be punished. This is line with the ethical principle of distributive justice as this principle mainly focuses on what is good and ethical to the whole society, instead of catering to individual interests.

The argument put in favor of Janning was that, should he be accountable for the deaths in the concentration camp, although he just signed an order for imprisonment. However, in line with principle of distributive justice, that action of Janning proved to be detrimental to sizable number of people or society, and that negative effect on society has to be taken into account. 3. In the context of then prevailing political and social climate, as well as historical events, the resolution in the movie seems to be apt and ethically correct.

That is, at the time of the trial, political repercussions of Second World War got subsided and Cold War has started. So, there was a view, that the German judges should not be punished strongly to avoid alienation of the German people, and to make the German government side with the United States. Quite contrary to that perception, the Germans themselves wanted to punish the Nazi criminals to wash off the taint of Holocaust and thereby salvage some pride. So, instead of taking a softer path, the resolution of sentencing the judges to life imprisonment was ethically apt. 4. Although, the Nuremberg Judgment had clear political and social impacts, it made impacts on the Healthcare arena as well.

The Nuremberg Trials took place from 1945 to 1947, and it was in 1947, the World Medical Association (WMA) was established. When the WMA was set up, its founders decided to incorporate ethics for physicians taking into consideration the inhumane and unethical practices carried out by the German physicians at that time. “Conscious of the violations of medical ethics before and during World War Two, the founders of the WMA immediately took steps to ensure that physicians would at least be aware of their ethical obligations.

” (Elnimeiri, 2008). Many obligations were included like, voluntary consent of the human subject is absolutely essential during treatment and medical experiments, those experiments should yield fruitful results for the good of society, importantly the experiment should be so conducted as to avoid all unnecessary physical and mental suffering and injury, experiments should be conducted only by scientifically qualified persons taking into ethical considerations, etc. (Elnimeiri, 2008). 5. The personal conclusions that can be made from the movie is that whatever be the external political, social and historical situations and pressures, ethical aspects has to be given prominence.

In the film, there were pressures to go soft on the German judges and also consider Janning’s credentials, but Haywood played by Tracy placed strong emphasis on ethics and laws, thereby taking apt decision. He even declares that a judge responsibility is to stand for and uphold justice, overriding any personal and external pressures. In addition, the decision of Haywood not to focus on Janning’s ‘other side’, and decide mainly based on the repercussions of his decisions, were commendable and an ethically correct behavior.

Reference: Elnimeiri, M. K. M. (2008). Nuremberg Code: A landmark document on medical research ethics. Sudanese Journal of Public Health, 3 (2): 94-96. Retrieved from: http://www.sjph.net.sd/files/vol3i2p94-96.pdf.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Judgment at Nuremberg Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/nursing/1456170-no-specific-topic
(Judgment at Nuremberg Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/nursing/1456170-no-specific-topic.
“Judgment at Nuremberg Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1456170-no-specific-topic.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Judgment at Nuremberg

The Nuremberg Trials

Appropriateness of the Indictments The function of the IMT at nuremberg was to formally question the ‘main' German war criminals.... Name of of Professor The nuremberg Trials Introduction It is now safe to assume, after more than sixty years of retrospection, that the International Military Tribunal (IMT) in the nuremberg Trials was a historical episode of global magnitude.... And the term ‘nuremberg' has been associated with the greatest principles and hopes of the world, and with the foundation of all later humanitarian endeavours....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

International Criminal Justice

We were committing war crimes in World War II, before the nuremberg trials were held and the principle of war crimes was stated. The statement in the question was given by the eminent political scientist John Burton and yet the statement presents the very opposite of what is happening in the world of international humanitarian law today....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Judgement at Nuremberg

In the paper “Judgement at nuremberg” the author analyses the movie, which expansively presents the post-World War trials held at nuremberg.... (Judgement at nuremberg)The movie revolves around four judges who enact the Nazi Law and inflict a lot of pain on humanity.... In 1948, a series of trials were held in nuremberg.... In 1948, a series of trials were held in nuremberg, Germany, by an international tribunal, headed by American legal and military officials, with the intent of bringing to justice those guilty of crimes against humanity....
1 Pages (250 words) Movie Review

Nuremberg Trial

As we are discussing the legal aspect, it is important to highlight that the case against Nazi judges at nuremberg was based upon moral and ethical misconduct.... The nuremberg Trial is trial of four Nazi judges before American court which comprised of three judges.... Introduction The nuremberg Trial is trial of four Nazi judges before American court which comprised of three judges.... With reference to the judgment of nuremberg Trial, the judgment was implemented by the American forces as per their legal obligation....
2 Pages (500 words) Movie Review

International politics, Movie Analysis

The defendants could not Judgment at Nuremberg This is a movie that was developed from real scenes that took place in Nuremberg in German in the year 1948 (Bradley 1).... Judgment at Nuremberg.... 0 at the US nuremberg Military tribunals (Bradley 1)....
2 Pages (500 words) Movie Review

Legal History of the Nuremberg Laws

While World War II has become known historically for the genocide of the Jews under the Nazi regime, very few people know of the history of the atrocity which can be traced back to the nuremberg Laws that legalized the murder of Jews in Germany and even further back, to the… This paper will look back into the psyche that drove Hitler to demand the creation of the nuremberg laws.... What is more amazing about the story of the nuremberg Laws and the rise of Hitler to power is that he was not German himself....
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

Legal Consequences Crime of Aggression : State v Individual Criminal Responsibility

There is no denying the fact that most international crimes are committed under the banner of system criminality where there is a mixture of individual and collective responsibility therefore cornering only particular individuals for accountability would just be a limited part… in 1949 the United Nation's ILC developed a “Draft Declaration on Rights and Duties” that mentioned some duties for the states but their accountability In recent years the argument under consideration is whether international criminal law has its jurisdictions on large scale war crime?...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The International Criminal Court and the Legal Principles Developed by the Ad Hoc Tribunal

In other words, the establishment of the ad hoc tribunals of the ICTY and the ICTR are perceived as the “impetus” for the establishment of the ICC which is in turn set up for enforcing the nuremberg principles of individual accountability regardless of office for violating international law.... Following the Second World War, the establishment of the International Military Tribunals as Tokyo and nuremberg gave expression to accepted definitions of international crimes such as war crimes, crimes against humanity and crimes against the peace....
20 Pages (5000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us