StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined? Your name Due Date Why mankind behaves the way that they do, what motivates their actions, and guides their choices and lives are questions tackled by academics, historians, religious scholars, and philosophers…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined"

Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined? Due Why mankind behaves the way that they do, what motivates their actions, and guides their choices and lives are questions tackled by academics, historians, religious scholars, and philosophers. There are a number of theories have been developed, using differing approaches and concepts, to determine one of the most intrinsic and essential arguments. Does man have free will? Does true freedom exist? Determinists would tell you no. There is no such thing as freedom and free will; it is an illusion of our perception.

Existentialist, on the other hand, would tell you that all that there is for mankind is what he makes of himself; there is no ideal because there is no “God” figure to oversee such judgments. There are strong supporters and opponents on both sides of the issue. However, after reviewing the arguments it strikes me most sensible that neither is really right. Existentialism, again, primarily, relies on the atheistic perspective of existence. Without a God figure reality becomes solely a product of nature and humanity is a child of its own devices (Sarte 1-2).

This perspective is disagreeable because it offers that since no “ideal standard” of good or evil truly exist, fears of afterlife punishments are negated, and people are entirely free and entitled to achieve their own happiness. This creates, what would amount to, chaos, which would only lead to outright anarchy. Everyone would be, literally, “out for themselves,” regardless of consequences or consideration of others. Ideals of good and bad, right or wrong would become ethically relative and dependent on whom you are speaking.

This might sound refreshing to the individual, but for a united society it is hardly productive or communal. Determinism is ripe with issues that many people would find entirely disagreeable for a number of reasons. Determinism eliminates entirely the existence of free will and freedom of individual choice (D’Holbach 1). This means that human beings are living amidst predetermined and mathematically calculable reactions, responses, and behaviors. They have no option; almost like being programmed with a limited number of responses.

Every action, good or bad, is not the responsibility of the person; it is outside their control (James 1-2). If no one is responsible for their own actions then how can any form of societal order ever hope to be kept? The instances in life that people perceive as choice or free will are illusions. Similar to people floating down a flowing river. They can cling to rocks and temporarily slow their movements, but, eventually, they will, sooner or later, continue in the direction the river takes them (D’Holbach 4).

Not unlike the concept of destiny. Regardless of your acts, the outcome will inevitably be the same. This thinking breeds laziness. Why bother to achieve, striving for our hopes, working hard for a goal, or planning ahead for the future if it is going to end up in the exact same place either way? It is these kinds of questions that make Determinism such a disagreeable philosophy. That said, it is likely that human behavior is guided by a mixture of things, biological imperatives, unconscious instincts, and the choices that they make.

For example, if a poor man robbed a market for products and money Determinists would say that he is not responsible. The negative experiences and his status in society forced him to this inevitable action; statistically that is calculable. His want and need in his life for food and income drove him to this act. . Existentialists might see his actions as a total personal choice, but he still cannot be held accountable because he is taking the initiative to improve his life, chances, and income regardless of consequences to anyone else.

However, what does it mean when a wealthy man does it. A wealthy man has no need to rob the store, he knows that it is a serious crime, and if he is caught he will be severely punished, he knows that his actions are morally and ethically wrong, and yet he does it anyway. This is proof that free will and personal choice do exist; it was solely placed on his desire not his need. Both ideologies do breed a certain amount of selfishness, which does not seem healthy in communal societies. One teaches freedom without restraint or regard and the other offers a world where you are little more than a biological robot acting out an unending program that you cannot change or effect in any significant way.

They make existence seems more empty and pointless. It is true that human beings are biological animals and a product of nature, which means that we are often encouraged and motivated by instincts and biological imperatives that act on our decisions unconsciously. Scientifically speaking, there are proven medical conditions that can effect behavior and influence abhorrent actions. However, examples of human choice exist all of the time. Human beings wished they could fly. They did not need to fl; it was not an issue of necessity.

They, obviously, could not will themselves wings, but instead devised hang-gliders, parachutes, helicopters, and airplanes in order to make this non-essential desire a reality. This represents more than the Determinists necessity driven, optionally limited, potential actions. However, it did require the unified planning, inventing, and continuous research and development, by 1000s of contributors, working together, with a single shared idea. This could not really exist or last for long in an existential world.

In the end, we must all live in the way and style that is right for us, however, given the circumstance neither Existentialism nor Determinism are desirable. Work Cited Sarte, Jean Paul. "Existentialism is A Humanism." Philosophy Magazine. n.d. 1-12. Print. D’Holbach, Baron. "Motives and the Determination of the Will." System of Nature. 1. (1853): 1-4. Print. James, William. “ The Dilemma Of Determinism ." Will To Believe. (1896): 1-6. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486570-are-we-free-or-are-our-actions-determined
(Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486570-are-we-free-or-are-our-actions-determined.
“Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486570-are-we-free-or-are-our-actions-determined.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Are We Free, or Are Our Actions Determined

Libertarian vs Determinism

In psychology, this is referred to as compatibilism, also called soft determinism, that describes how we still behave as free and ethically liable agents where what we do is determined by what we desire.... The former describes the future and how it has already been determined despite free will.... It is moral and normal for people to claim responsibility for their actions.... This includes blame and credit for good and terrible actions....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Are we free or determined

The below essay discusses the question, whether you believe human beings are free or determined.... We are free or we are determined in our decisions and behavior, this question arises in the mind of every philosopher.... If they are free, to what extent are they free If they are determined, what difficulty does this raise I believe that they are determined because, determinism is when the level to which human beings have influences over their future is itself dependent on present and past....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Free Will and Moral Responsibility

nbsp;Those who adhere to hard determinism assert that everything in our world and our actions are predetermined.... Libertarianism supposes that all our actions, decisions, and their results depend on us, they are the result of rational agency, but not of chance or luck.... Of course, heredity and environment play great a role in our actions, but I think that free will can depend on personal moral responsibility.... Blatchford asserts that our actions can be predictable....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Determinism Versus Libertarianism

Finally, there is biological determinism which gives the idea that our actions and behavior are fixed by our genetic predisposition.... Our desires are determined by environment, genes and decisions.... A human being cannot have freedom over his actions if it is already determined by God.... This could mean that human beings have no free choice because each event is caused by an agent and its effect would also be determined by that cause....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

A Feature of the Human Soul: the Material Existence and Realities

n fact, Kane has an impulsive tendency to argue against “compatibilism” on the ground that man will never be able to learn whether his 'will' is determined by some other power or not.... He argues that though indeterminism and free will are incompatible, human beings 'self-forming or libertarian actions are essentially the result of free will.... Therefore, they are morally responsible for their actions.... Indeed, he believes in the agent's mundane power to be responsible for his action, as he says, “If we are to be ultimately responsible for being what we are, there must be acts in our life histories in which parenting and histories…....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

What's your Dangerous Idea

The result of his first 2 previous actions determined that he would fail the test and thus, fail the class as well.... Factors combine in order to make people follow a certain path with a pre-determined result for them at the end of it.... It… Determinism dictates that the series of actions of a person will produce either a positive or negative effect upon his situation depending upon the A sample such a situation is a college who, during exam week, chose to party every night instead of study....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Problem of Free Will: Compatibilism

The first reason why I find Compatibilism to be the most plausible position is that libertarianism position is inconsistent with our daily experiences in life.... This is because in our experiences in life, we find that there are many factors and circumstances that determine us in our behaviour.... On cultural determinism, you find that the culture in which one grows in influences his/her behaviour in a fundamental way; the culture in which one grows in shapes our worldview in a significant way....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Analyzing the Problem of Freewill

We should not, at any given time, stand in a position to be easily predicted in our actions.... Our system as human beings is probabilistic rather than deterministic and therefore our actions should be unpredictable unlike the machines.... However, should our action be a direct consequence of an event that is random, responsibility cannot be felt.... The problem of free will emanate when one tries to merge the component of freedom with the apparent determinism in this world that has causes and effects....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us