StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Compare David Hume's ideas - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Comparison David Hume and Descartes Ideas David Hume’s excerpt “Of the origin of our ideas” David Hume was a famous Scottish philosopher widely known for his philosophical experimentation and uncertainty…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
Compare David Humes ideas
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Compare David Hume's ideas"

Comparison David Hume and Descartes Ideas David Hume’s excerpt “Of the origin of our ideas” David Hume was a famous Scottish philosopher widely known for his philosophical experimentation and uncertainty. His main area of interest in philosophy was on “The Origin of Our Ideas and Skepticism about Causal Reasoning.” His emphasis was on the difference between impression and thoughts or ideas, which are the two basic categories of the human mind perception (Hume 120). He argues that impressions emanate via human senses, feelings and reactions, and other mental features, they are the active perceptions we have because of hearing, seeing, feeling, loving, hating perceptions craving and ambitions.

When we hear, see, feel love, hate, desire or will. Ideas refer to the less active perceptions and reactions we have at the thought and imagination of these sensations, the faint pictures painted in our minds by these thoughts and reasoning. He also added that the difference between ideas and impressions is in the degree of force applied by each of them on the mind (Hume, 1). Construction of ideas occurs from the impressions that we have and in three distinct ways: ideas from simple impressions in three ways: the affinity, coherence, and connection.

Hume goes ahead and categorizes human rationality as either facts or just simple ideas. In the first category, he analyses facts hatched from experience. Despite the fact that thoughts originating from association of ideas may be inexistent, their truth is rationally flawless. A good illustration is in the case of a square; it will always have four corners irrespective of whether it exists in reality or not. It is possible for us to imagine the unseen things e.g., a monster but all our self-created perceptions emanate from sense and experience.

In his second category of human rationale, Hume makes an analysis based on inference to experience and not based on philosophical denouement; he assumes experience and an occasional observation as the basis of human reasoning (7). He denotes that factual matters are unpredictable since there is a possibility of the reverse happening. An example he gives is the assumption of the possibility of the rising of the sun. He criticizes the idea of “matter of fact” on making such conclusive assumptions if there is a possibility of the opposite occurrence.

He questions this idea as an innovative and a type of logic only possible in a theoretical perspective. Hume’s argument is that assumptions of cause and effect between two correlations are not obviously true. . He further affirms that our assumptions about the future cannot be justified since there is no such law that the future will always be like the past. He emphasizes that our assumptions are based on habits and not on logic. He says that if experience teaches us that two events take place at once, then we assume a relationship between them.

However, he appreciates the importance of the assumed connections and defines them as simple repeated observations between two events. He then concludes that, in the absence of cause and effect, our actions are unpredictable. He further proves that cause and effect are based on subjective reasoning and thus causal. He denies the concept of knowledge because all beliefs emanate from ideas, which originate from reality; no conclusion can be made beyond experience (Pojman et al.). Descartes’ 6th Meditation Rene Descartes was a French philosopher, mathematician, and writer who spent most of his life in the Dutch Republic.

The sixth meditation consists of one of the philosophical ideas in which Descartes highlights all beliefs in things he says have no absolute truth in them and tries to find out any facts that can be established about them. The meditations were written as if he was in meditation for the six days during which he wrote them all and in each meditation, he refers to the previous as yesterday (Skirry 116). This meditation concerns the existence of material things and the actual distinction between the mind and the body.

Descartes postulates the possibility of existence of material besides the self and God. First, he affirms that such objects can possibly exist simply because God created them. He denotes that even though they are the subjects of pure mathematics, he knows that there is a possibility of their existence because he understands them separately. Since God can definitely create anything, he can grasp and that he could not judge that anything could be impossible for God (Descartes, Meditation VI: On the Existence of Material Objects from Body).

With the knowledge of the possibility of existence of such object, he then highlights the pervasiveness of imaginations as a proof. To do this, he makes a difference between imaginations and understanding, he envisages imagination as a school of thought that immediately presents to it without logic or inception. This, therefore, exists like a mental picture. On the other hand, he said that understanding does not have to be pictured; this he explains using the example of a mental image of a triangle.

He says that he finds it hard to understand that it is a three line bounded figure and sees the lines through the perceived present eyes in the mind, this he called having a mental image. Thinking of hectagon, he says he understood it to be a thousand sided figure as much as he has an understanding that a triangle is a three-sided figure, but he could not imagine the figures as if they could be present. He, therefore, concluded by making an observation that there is some effort needed by the mind for imagination as opposed to the conception of ideas or understanding.

This particular struggle of the mind distinctly distinguishes imagination and pure logic. He further denoted the difference between the mind and the body, with the idea that the body is often separable while the mind is completely inseparable. He says that in truth, when he considers himself thinking, he is able to distinguish in himself no parts but rather feels himself as whole. He believes that he cannot imagine anything in thought, which, therefore, he does not know to be divisible. This, therefore, is an illustration that the mind or soul of man is entirely different from the body.

He concludes that the mind does not suddenly receive impression from the rest of the body but only from the brain or rather from just a very tiny part of it where the common sense is said to be found which in turn gives the same perception to the mind. Difference Hume seeks to explain our understanding of the world around us rather than establishing a justification of our beliefs or anything else. Here, he does not address the existence of possible relationships between occurrences but rather that we cannot establish what the relationships are.

This means that these relationships exist, but it is only that they are not defined. Definitely, Hume argues for a mitigated skepticism. We have no good reason to believe much of what we believe about the world, but human nature helps us function in all the ways that reason cannot. On the other hand, Descartes, on the other hand, shows that there is no such thing as a relationship between the mind and the body and that the body is often separable while the mind is completely inseparable. Descartes' arguments for the existence of the body as essentially extended that then follows this strategies in the Meditations is to show that it is possible to demonstrate logically the existence of a relationship between the soul and the mind.

His ideas to view clearly and distinctly the primary attribute of the body as an extension. His arguments from the imagination and the senses clearly illustrate the logic schools of thought seem to be linked to something outside of the mind. While his argument from the imagination only leaves the existence of the body as a reasonably good guess, his argument from the senses will ultimately leave him satisfied. This, therefore, presents Descartes’ argument as the most appropriate. Work cited David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature.

New York: Dover, 2003 edition Pojman, Louis and Lewis Vaughn. Philosophy: the Quest for Truth. New York: Oxford, 2009. Skirry Justin. Descartes: A guide for the perplexed.philosophy.Countinuam publishers. 2008. David Hume. An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. Vol. 37, Part 3.Collier & Son Company, .2009.print.  

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare David Hume's ideas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1495187-compare-david-hume-s-ideas
(Compare David Hume'S Ideas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1495187-compare-david-hume-s-ideas.
“Compare David Hume'S Ideas Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1495187-compare-david-hume-s-ideas.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare David Hume's ideas

David Hume and Schumacher

hume's essays revolve around all spheres of life and it would be impossible to precisely summarize his views in a single work.... This paper ''david Hume and Schumacher'' tells that Today's world experiences unprecedented attention being paid to the understanding of man's ways of life and his behaviour.... One of the greatest philosophers ever seen in history was david Hume (1711-1776).... david Hume is regarded as one of the greatest philosophers to have ever lived....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

David Hume and Immanuel Kant on our ideas of right and wrong

The ideas of Hume had their impact on Metaphysics, Epistemology, and Psychology.... Relations of ideas cannot speak exactly for the existence of human beings, the universe or God.... This empirical understanding of the ideas of right and wrong is needed to have the clear picture of things.... In the work An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding Hume discusses the origin and association of ideas.... He distinguishes between impressions and ideas which will give us his notion of idea in general....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Critique of the Design Argument by David Hume

In david hume's treatise "Critique of the Design Argument", presented in his book Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, David Hume introduced a discourse between two characters, Cleanthes and Philo.... hellip; This argument from hume's treatise is said to have paved the way for the foundation of the Theory of Evolution first proposed by Charles Darwin.... This review "Critique of the Design Argument by david Hume" discusses substantial evidence of independent thought and judgment, with arguments that are clearly presented and well structured....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

The Philosophical Naturalism Of David Hume

The paper "The Philosophical Naturalism Of david Hume" discusses david Hume as one of the most thoroughgoing exponents of philosophical naturalism, who sought to develop the consequences of Locke's cautious empiricism by applying the scientific methods of observation to a study of human nature....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Tell me why Hume believes that Thesis (2) is true

In what is commonly referred to as david hume's Thesis 2, the theorist claims that “causal relations are not knowable a priori (apart from experience), but only by inference from past experiences.... ?? In other words, everything we know about the relationships between cause… To prove this point, Hume analyzes the processes of thought and understanding, tracing how each idea is formed by knowledge of previous experience. He begins his argument david hume's Reasons to Believe In what is commonly referred to as david hume's Thesis 2, the theoristclaims that “causal relations are not knowable a priori (apart from experience), but only by inference from past experiences....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

On Defending Humes First Principle

In david hume's Enquiry concerning Human Understanding (1748), he sets out his empirical reconstruction of the foundations of philosophy.... Herein, Hume formulates his theory of meaning based on his explication on two main categories of perception, namely, ideas and… In other words, where there is no impression the idea is meaningless (Lavine 156).... Since it does not come from our sense perception; it must come from the mind, based on Hume's explication on the psychological laws of association of ideas....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Analysis on Humans and Animals

The issue is controversial, thus it is essential to consider the ideas of famous thinkers.... The "Analysis on Humans and Animals" research paper is focused on a difficult moral and ethical issue: whether the killing of an animal for human gastronomy is justified or not.... hellip; Therefore there's no way and justification for cruel attitude towards animals....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Humes Copy Principle

Fro this work it is clear that Hume presented a number of arguments in his copy principle that indeed simple ideas are direct representations of the simple impressions that exist in the world.... It is from this that the mind is supplied with simple ideas once the environmental detection or sensation has taken place.... The mind then gets into a process of synthesizing simple ideas through conversion and combination so they may produce compound ones....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us