StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Socrates vs Confucius - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay describes a method in philosophy – the “Cartesian doubting” or “doubting method”, called so because Rene Descartes used this method widely in his philosophical studding. The idea is to doubt everything in order to find the true statement within a variety of statements…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful
Socrates vs Confucius
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Socrates vs Confucius"

Socrates vs. Confucius There’s a method in philosophy – the “Cartesian doubting” or “doubting method”, called so because Rene Descartes used this method widely in his philosophical studding. The idea is to doubt everything in order to find the true statement within a variety of statements, and separate the truth from false. Method helps to base philosophical thoughts only on true, doubtless statements. Then further statements, based on doubtless ones, are also true. Using a doubting method is like constant checking own beliefs in order to belief only in true things. Though this assignment will have nothing to do with Descartes, this position will help to analyze the other two prominent Philosophers – Socrates and Confucius. The prominent Greek philosopher Socrates and the great teacher of the Chinese nation Confucius tried to solve the same issue fostered by the life itself – they endeavored to find a means to get over turmoil, distemper and anarchy in the society, they sought to make it firm balanced unity, to convert chaos to order. But what is order in general? Put in the language of that epoch this question is stated as follows: what are we to take as a “paragon” of order and consistency? How should perfect social fabric look like? The difference between the eastern and western cultures lies in the answer they offer for these questions. The difference in the attitude towards the means of solving the issues disturbing society came out of the peculiarities if historical preconditions and the period they lived in. Both Socrates and Confucius at the time of significant social changes accompanied by frequent wars, as well as society demoralization and political perturbations (Bishop). Socrates witnessed florescence of Greece as Pericles was in reign, as well as did he see its overwhelming defeat in the Peloponnesian wars and severe rule of the Thirty Tyrants. Confucius lived at the time when the traditional slave-owning system was on the verge of decline while various political powers were fighting for power. All these factors lead to crises, and the philosophers tried to find a way to understand them and their origins and tackle them mending the social structure. Basically, this was the main common aim of Socrates and Confucius. The principal difference between them lay in the way they chose to treat the issue. The view on human nature and morality is considered to be theoretical basis of their teachings. Socrates shifted focus from speculations about the afterlife, the gods and the nature to meditation on how to live in this world. He saw the solution of a problem in reason. Reason is what can open the essence of a “paragon” for order; what we wish to create should be first developed in our mind. Socrates’ famous admonition “Know thyself” implies the importance of knowledge in human affairs. Knowledge of good is wisdom, and a one should devote oneself to perception of one’s own moral nature (Socrates consider a human to be moral by nature), this was an integral part of a human’s life (Jichen, Paxson). Generally, Socrates proposes to acquire some new knowledge and then – virtue as virtue is knowledge (of the good). Meanwhile, Confucius has a different point of view on the prior task of the philosophical teaching. According to his position, there already is a “paragon” of order which is unnecessary to invent. It’s antiquity, the rules the ancestors used to follow, their customs and rituals; when they are observed, there comes the reign of order and harmony, but when they are forgotten and neglected, there comes chaos and distemper. So, in this respect we see the contrast between Socrates relying on wisdom and reason and Confucius resting upon rituals. According to Confucius, the governor is sheng (perfectly wise), and his task is not to seek a new knowledge, but to restore lost customs. Confucius believes that the order depends on revitalizing the old ritual as forgetting them has led to chaos. He sees the main objective in recovery of the previous order. Disorder is cause by losing the way and Dao. But the perfectly wise, sheng himself embodies order, harmony, antiquity, he is nearly an incarnation of Dao. Though there is no clear definition for virtue in the teaching of Confucius, he offers his understanding of morality. "Govern the people with severity, - he states, - keep order among them by chastisements, and they will flee from you and lose the sense of shame. Govern them by moral force, keep order among them by ritual and they will keep their sense of shame and come to you of their own accord.”(Confucius) This quote means that law is not as powerful in ruling the society and maintaining harmony as morality. Greece proclaims the value of reason and the wise individual and focuses on the new knowledge opened with help of reason. At the same time Chinese view states the value of ritual and traditions orientating on the antiquity. The general philosophical aims coincide, but the ways for their pursuing discord. The difference between eastern and western philosophy lies in the difference of world perception. The Greek ideology, according to Plato’s conception, proclaims imperfection and inconsistency of the material world and excellence of the world of ideas. Greeks perceive the sublunar realm as chaos. That is why they think that it is only possible to achieve harmony through attaining knowledge and wisdom; if philosophers rule the world, order will reign. But Chinese ideology personified by Confucius does not offer escaping this imperfect world, actually there is no other world for it, it perceives the world as it is; Confucius recognizes his value in this world and aspires to achieve harmony and bring it to the world. Thus, having considered two types of world overlook – eastern and western – we can make a conclusion that they are based on two different social environments. In Greece we observe polis and democracy; in China – the stated headed by the governor reigning on behalf of Heaven. Eventually, these peculiarities influence the formation of two different cultures with varying perceptions of the world and reality. In particular, democratization of political sphere and absolution from ritual deliver a free individual building life on the basis of knowledge. Works cited Bishop, Philip E. Literature for the Adventures in the Human Spirit, 1994. Print. Confucius. Analects, Web. Jichen, Shu; Paxson Thomas. A Comparison Between the Ethics of Socrates and Confucius, Web. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Socrates vs Confucius Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Socrates vs Confucius Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1662875-socrates-vs-confucius
(Socrates Vs Confucius Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Socrates Vs Confucius Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1662875-socrates-vs-confucius.
“Socrates Vs Confucius Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1662875-socrates-vs-confucius.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Socrates vs Confucius

Research Confucius and Socrates

(Assignment) confucius and Socrates confucius, the highly determined Chinese scholar was born in 551 BCE in the state of LU.... hellip; confucius desired to restore the lost justice and harmony of Chinese society through his remarkable teachings throughout his lifetime.... (Assignment) confucius and Socrates confucius, the highly determined Chinese scholar was born in 551 BCE in the of LU.... confucius desired to restore the lost justice and harmony of Chinese society through his remarkable teachings throughout his lifetime....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Comparison of Plato and Confucius and Their Contemporary Relevance

Comparison of Plato and confucius and their Contemporary Relevance Your name Name of Professor Section Number Date on which submitted Word Count: 1717 Comparison of Plato and confucius and their Contemporary Relevance Plato and confucius are two of the world's most important philosophers.... The paper shall look at the Apology, Crito and Gorgias by Plato and the Analects of confucius for a discussion of the views of the two philosophers....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Confucius as the Founder of a Profound Philosophy

Subject 05 December 2012 confucius: The Founder of a Profound Philosophy China is a country that has been nourished under a very interesting history since the prehistoric times?... confucius?... confucius?... confucius was forced into different kinds of labor like working as a keeper of the granary?... Although confucius is the father of this school of thought?... confucius' journey of life came to an end in 479 BCE and he was mourned by followers all over China....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Philosophy Paper Option

This has led china's philosophy to uphold philosophical conclusions that are drawn from divine notations as ascribed to confucius by traditional writers (Chan, 1969).... This paper ''Philosophy Paper Option'' tells that The development of Chinese philosophy versus western philosophy backs from pre-Confucianism to neo rationalist as well as neo idealist movements....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Analects of Confucius

confucius is a Latinized form of Kong Fuzi, which literally means Kong the Master, or Master Kong. confucius was more concerned with the moral character of the… confucius wanted to apply his teachings to practical, everyday life, that is why he served in office so that he can advise the rulers of the clan as to the proper way of However, he seemed to have not achieved that because of the corruption that governed the lives of the rulers at the time....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Philosophy Ethics

On the other hand, confucius's The Analects – a post-mortem compilation of his thoughts and written works (Walsh, 2006, p.... Suffice it to say: If Plato is the Socrates of the West; then confucius is the “Socrates of China” (Walsh, 2006, p.... confucius's definition of the meaning of life can be understood from his belief of the influences of fate and... Among the early seminal… To Santas (2006), Plato's The Republic – his book containing his and socrates's philosophical thoughts – entitled him the 1)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Ancient Chinese Civilization

he main concern of confucius was to attain social order and political stability.... The key to a peaceful existence, according to the analysis of confucius, was a return to the virtues of humanity and benevolence in social relations by reciprocity.... This is what confucius meant when he said, “a young man's duty is to be filial to his parents at home, and respectful to his elders abroad, to be circumspect and truthful ....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Education in Australia and China

… The paper "Education in Australia and China" is a great example of a report on education.... Over time, there has been a significant increase in the number of foreign students pursuing their studies in Australia.... In most cases, these foreign students come from non-English speaking countries such as China among many other countries....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us