StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author examines the commercial surrogacy dilemma and states that is unethical and unacceptable. Also, the author examines the human enhancement dilemma and  presents the argument and opinions for and against biotechnology which is often used in enhancing human nature …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas"

ESSAY ASSIGNMENT 2 [Insert al Affiliation] Surrogate mothers Commercial surrogacy is unethical and unacceptable as it compromises the surrogate mother’s autonomy, treats children as commodities and relegates women to a position of children industries. Anderson (1990) uses the concept of alienation to argue that during pregnancy, a mother develops love with the unborn baby hence reprising the baby psychologically affects the baby yet the remuneration provided is not enough to cater for emotional and psychological damage caused.

Anderson (1990) uses the concept of alienation to denounce commercial surrogacy. He argues that the bond that often develops between the unborn child and the mother is too strong to break through forcing the surrogate mother to repress the parental love she has for the child. Moreover, the mother becomes alienated from her labor as well as the child thus violating the mother’s right to consideration. Through the concept of alienation, Anderson (1990) further indicates that commercial surrogacy reduces pregnancy to a form of drudgery performed for money motives, which is against the societal norms.

What’s more, Anderson (1990) responds to the objection that the women sign a contract and agreed to be surrogate mothers by articulating that the contract does not guarantee the surrogate mother peace of mind as it merely treats moral transformation as any other economic exchange. Disparagingly, the surrogate agency strives to strike the best deal while leaving the surrogate mother in a position that she can hardly protect and/or serve her interests. Moreover, the woman might have signed the contract out of desperation and vulnerability, a factor which exposes her to exploitation by surrogate agency hence mothers should be allowed to decide what to do with the pregnancy, and surrogate contracts should not be enforceable (Anderson, 1990).

Human enhancementBiotechnology is often used in enhancing human nature. However, the entire concept is often contentious with proponents and critics articulating various reasons for and against the use of biotechnology in enhancing the nature of human beings. Buchanan (2009) responds to the objection of using biotechnology to enhance the nature of human beings by accentuating that people possess some characteristics that are not always ideal whereas Parens (2005) provides a context-specific of female Viagra to indicate why biotechnological enhancements are not always viable.

Human beings, from a philosophical standpoint, consist of dispositions that shape their behaviors. Among these dispositions or features, some are desirable whereas others are detrimental or rather unattractive. While many scholars condemn enhancement on the basis that it always destroy or alter human nature, Buchanan (2009) responds by articulating that there is no evocative reason or evidence that eliminating some bad qualities in human beings endanger the good qualities. While there is no a clear cut between the good and bad characteristics, Buchanan (2009) asserts that human beings perceive some characteristics as ideal and purely human due to their egocentric nature.

Apparently, a principled objection to enhancement is an opportunistic demurral on grounds of egotism rather than morals whereas a context-specific objection to enhancement considers the prevailing situation and offers moral reasons for the demurral. Parens (2005) provides the “female Viagra” as an example of a context-specific objection. He objects the use of “female Viagra” as it does not generate intimacy to bridge the gap between arousal and desire and that its use will only make the woman live a happy life while missing an essential part of life; the ability to be intimate (Parens, 2005).

Sadly, Parens (2005) disregards the fact that the Viagra would improve the reproductive health of women.ReferencesAnderson, E. (1990). Is Women’s Labor a Commodity? Philosophy and Public Affairs 19:1: 71-92.Buchanan, A. (2009). Human Nature and Enhancement. Journal of Bioethics. Malden USA: Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Parens, E. (2005). Authenticity and Ambivalence: Toward Understanding the Enhancement Debate. Hastings Center Report. doi:10.1353/hcr.2005.0067

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas Assignment - 1”, n.d.)
Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas Assignment - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1698608-essay-assignment-2
(Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas Assignment - 1)
Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas Assignment - 1. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1698608-essay-assignment-2.
“Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas Assignment - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1698608-essay-assignment-2.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas

Ethics and Surrogate Motherhood

Luckily, such a travesty of an intellectual and ethical catechism is, in fact, next to impossible in the contemporary technology-driven society where the emergence of the latest scientific discoveries and novel possibilities more then ever impinges upon the collective human consciousness to see and analyze the emerging issues in a multifaceted context.... The essay "Ethics and surrogate Motherhood" focuses on the urgent ethical issue, surrogate motherhood....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Surrogate Mothers: Helping Infetile Couples vs. Ethical Abuses

Other areas of human endeavor are also t to conflicting views arising from technology such as the use of genetically-modified organisms (GMO), mapping of the human genome (allowing people to select certain genes for their progenies in the future), priority in getting vital human organs for transplant (Steve Jobs of Apple, Inc.... A question of surrogate motherhood does not involve a few individuals only but rather the whole society (Rae, 9)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Admission/Application Essay

Audience Analysis Cover Sheet + Persuasive Letter on Surrogacy Arrangements

The matter does not seem to be as pressing like dilemmas such as drugs, scandals or even climate change.... It is not an issue which many had the time to even consider their position on.... But surrogacy is a topic… It is worth the people's time to step back and think about what this really means in our lives and in our society....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Negative Factors Involving Surrogate Parenting

Neither the surrogate mothers nor the donor parents accepted the child as their own.... Traditional surrogacy involved the artificial insemination of the surrogate… Gestational surrogacy has come in recent times and involves the implantation of the surrogate mother with the already fertilized ovum.... In the gestational surrogacy, the surrogate mother has no genetic connection with the There has been ongoing debate on the legality of surrogacy, whether it should be allowed, or not (Hatzis, 2009)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Surrogates Philosophy

Surrogacy as a subject of mental disability and healthcare system is a complex, but proactive, systematic process that has generated a significance philosophical point of argument among various critics and amateurs of justice and ethical human rights.... In COGNITIVELY DISABLED SURROGATES PHILOSOPHY Introduction Surrogacy as a of mental disability and healthcare system is a complex, but proactive, systematic process that has generated a significance philosophical point of argument among various critics and amateurs of justice and ethical human rights....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Human Enhancement

In the paper “human enhancement” the author discusses the idea whether the welfare of the unborn child is considered.... human enhancement al Affiliations Although surrogate parents and their normally sign an agreement of bearing the children, Anderson strongly opposes this idea by considering whether the welfare of the unborn child is considered.... A principled objection to enhancement gives the total interrelationship between human nature and judging good and bad character....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Designer Babies, Eugenics and the Concept of 3 Parent Child

In-vitro fertilization and PGD are significant advances in human civilization and can lead to further achievements.... here are many other discoveries and inventions which fostered human progress to the point it is now today; earlier advances included mastery of fire, the invention of gunpowder, the use of the compass (for marine navigation), use of ink for printing, domestication of the horse for its varied uses in both transportation and as the war machine in fighting (cavalry), production of paper and the subsequent use of paper currency (instead of the bulky and heavy metal coins) to foster trade, pottery and porcelain, sericulture (raising silkworms for making silk) and many others....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Why Commercial Surrogate Motherhood Unethically Commodities Women and Children

Given the fact that contact pregnancy is a free will undertaking of the surrogate mothers but in the process, the undertaking alienates the mothers' autonomy hence deteriorating her dignity through the decision made of selling the parental obligations.... Commercial surrogacy undermines the dignity of the surrogate mothers by reducing the worthiness of the reproductive capacity.... From the definitive point of view, human dignity can be understood as the individual's sense of self-worth and self-respect, psychological and physical integrity as well as empowerment....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us