StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Should the US Pull Their Troops out of Iraq - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Several important figures of the world of politics and the military forces on the United States of America, such as the CIA chief John Deutch, say they should. From those that argue that the war was never necessary in the first place to those that the issue has caused controversy for years.
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Should the US Pull Their Troops out of Iraq
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Should the US Pull Their Troops out of Iraq"

US FOREIGN POLICY Should the US pull their troops out of Iraq.................2-4 Should the US continue to support Israel....................5-7 References...................................................8 Should the US pull their troops out of Iraq Several important figures of the world of politics and the military forces on the United States of America, such as the CIA chief (1995-1996) John Deutch, say they should (AFX News Limited). From those that argue that the war was never necessary in the first place to those that say it is time to pull the troops out, the issue has caused controversy for years. Historical reasons Many argue that we, the Western World, were "tricked" by our politicians to get into the war when they convinced us that Saddam was accumulating weapons of mass destruction and that a clear link existed between Iraq and Al Qaeda, the group responsible for the 9/11 massacre in the Twin Towers (New York, USA). However, during Gulf War I most of Saddam's weapons were destroyed and, with the country under a very strict embargo since then, it is virtually impossible he could have accumulated such an arsenal. Political reasons Experts often argue that the US should not be trying to re-build a nation according to its own values. Additionally, it is believed that the presence of US troops in the area is fuelling the civil war that is taking place there. During the years following the Golf War I, the US bombed Iraq daily killing thousands of Iraqis and it is thus not surprising that the Americans are viewed as occupiers. Many Iraqis firmly believe that America has come to conquer and not to aid them. Economic reasons In terms of the economic cost, it was L. Lindsey, President Bush's economic adviser, who several years ago suggested that the cost of the war would reach $200 billion. Since then, this has been proved to be a serious underestimation: the US Congress has already spent in the order of $357 billion for military operations, reconstruction works, enhanced security at US bases and foreign aid programs in Iraq and the neighbouring Afghanistan (Bilmes and Stiglitz). Conclusion Therefore, if the reasons to start the war were: 1) liberation of Iraq of the regime of terror imposed by Saddam; 2) the establishment of a democracy; 3) self-defence and elimination of any weapons of mass destruction; and 4) protection of the Middle East; and these issues have now been resolved (liberation of Iraq has been achieved and Saddam has been tried and executed for the crimes he committed; a democracy or at least a new government selected after democratic elections has started to exercise power; weapons of mass destruction were never found; there is no risk that a country in ruins will try to attack or invade the neighbouring countries-even when Saddam was alive this was quite a remote possibility) What is the presence of the US troops in the area achieving The answer is simple: nothing. From an international point of view, the presence of US troops is only aggravating the problem, increasing the possibilities of a bloody civil war. From a domestic point of view the deployment of troops in Iraq weakens the US military power; it detracts attention from other issues, such as international terrorism and the situation with North Korea and Iran; and the economic and human cost has risen significantly. While an early withdrawal of the troops has been announced by the British government, President Bush has confirmed an additional 21,500 additional troops will be sent in (Harding and Hardern). Is he seriously damaging the image of the US and its international credibility Many believe he is Should the US continue to support Israel There are many reasons for the existing strong relationship between Israel and the US. First, the US was the first country to recognize the state of Israel. Secondly, the US has maintained a very profitable arm trade with Israel for a number of years. Thirdly, Israel is a very useful non-NATO ally that has a very strategic location in the "explosive" Middle East. The support of the state of Israel by the US population is obvious from recent polls that confirm that it is regarded as one of their closest allies. So much so that, although a majority of the population agree that the US is more likely to be targeted for a terrorist attack as a result of the support of Israel, a large percentage believes that this support should continue. However, dissident groups have appeared within the North American society that argue that Israel has breached UN decisions, is illegally occupying Palestinian territories and is the perpetrator of human rights abuses. So, should the US withdraw its support The answer is yes. First, experts have suggested that the US-Israel bond might result in worsening relations with other Arab states. Additionally, comments such as those made by Dick Cheney do not help the situation. He suggested that a retreat (from Iraq) would be seen as an encouragement of the enemies of the Jewish state and would increase the risk of initiating a regional conflict. Secondly, in the conflict with Palestine it is the UN (and not the US, who should remove themselves and remain neutral), that should mediate between the 2 countries and regulate their relations. Thirdly, while withdrawal of support would be highly unpopular within the American society, international relations would be greatly improved. As it stands, the US runs the risk of seeing itself in the middle of an ethnic/religious war predicted to happen in the next 10 to 20 years. References -AFX News Limited. "US should pull out of Iraq now says former CIA chief John Deutch". Forbes.com. Date last accessed: March 18, 2007. -Bilmes, L. and Stiglitz, J.E. "The economic costs of the Iraq war: an appraisal three years after the beginning of the conflict". Date last accessed: March 17, 2007. -Harding, T. and Harnden, T. "3,000 British troops to pull out of Iraq by May". Telegraph.co.uk. Date last updated: March 18, 2007. Date last accessed: March 18, 2007. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should the US Pull Their Troops out of Iraq Essay”, n.d.)
Should the US Pull Their Troops out of Iraq Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1506175-should-the-us-pull-their-troops-out-of-iraq
(Should the US Pull Their Troops Out of Iraq Essay)
Should the US Pull Their Troops Out of Iraq Essay. https://studentshare.org/politics/1506175-should-the-us-pull-their-troops-out-of-iraq.
“Should the US Pull Their Troops Out of Iraq Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1506175-should-the-us-pull-their-troops-out-of-iraq.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should the US Pull Their Troops out of Iraq

The United States and Iraq

This paper ''The United States and Iraq'' tells that It is ten years since the inversion of iraq and still there is no debate on the aspects of war except the relevant law in a nation dedicated to the rule of law.... Bush Administration intensified its allegation of iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction after the September 11, 2001 terror attacks.... The United States invasion of iraq was not justified because there is no evidence that IRAQ has Weapons of Mass Destruction, complicity in the 9/11 attacks, and oral –Qaeda connection....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Intentions and Goals of the U.S. and Iraq War

Iraq War, led by the United States against the regime of Saddam Hussein, the authoritarian leader of iraq in 2003.... The invasion and occupation of iraq has made terrorist threat worse than before.... forces from iraq.... troops from iraq as follows: Introduction: The recent surveys that I have come across show that there are serious rifts among Democrat leadership about the success of war in iraq.... A recent survey finds two in three Democrats believe the war is already lost and a serious criticism about the adventure of America's war against terrorism in iraq is evident from the public side as well....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Should US Military Stay in Iraq

According to the text, most Americans now agree with what the rest of the world has known all along, that the invasion of iraq was not in the best interest of western-Arab relations.... However, because of the occupation of iraq, the international terrorist organization, Al Qaeda has grown in number.... The author of this essay "War in iraq" touches upon the war in iraq.... hellip; The alleged link between the terrorist group Al Qaeda and iraq was referenced before the war and became the primary excuse of the Bush administration following the lack of weapons evidence....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Risks Involved if the U.S. Withdrew From Iraq

Withdrew From Iraq" concerns the US occupation of iraq.... It is mentioned that most Americans now agree with what the rest of the world has known all along, that the invasion of iraq was not in the best interest of western-Arab relations.... However, because of the occupation of iraq, the international terrorist organization, Al Qaeda has grown in number, increased attacks worldwide and has infiltrated the borders of iraq....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Results of the US Involvement in Iraq

Having control over such oil reserves would have made Iraq… At this time of the century, the cold war was still on and an attempt of iraq to make itself an influential state of the world was not taken lightly by the world super powers.... Also, the presence of America in Middle East helped contain the major militant gangs of the world; Taliban and Al-Qaida; a great step towards uplifting the lives of the different citizens of iraq and Middle East.... Such acts could have directly affected the major economies of the Nevertheless, the us invasion on Iraq has been considered as one of the most momentous and controversial foreign policy decisions that have ever been made by the American government....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

The Gulf War and Sadam Hussain: 1991

It was in this year that the coup leader, Abdul Karem Kassem tried to reduce the disparities between the rich and the poor class of iraq and form relations with Communist countries.... hellip; The year 1958 was when the military in iraq was successful in removing the country's monarchy.... iraq was now the world's leaders in the production of oil.... It was also noted then that Saddam feared the effects of Iran on iraq and also feared that iraq would also move into fundamentalism and would destroy the country....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Refugee and Migration Movements Throughout the History

An author of this research "Refugee and Migration Movements Throughout the History" will conduct an in-depth analysis of the historical events involving refugees and migration movements that occurred at different points of history in various regions.... hellip; The origin of Hutu and Tutsi dichotomy started during the pre-colonial Rwanda....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

The US Efforts to Install Democracy in Iraq

he irony of the entire scenario is most poignantly expressed through the fact that, though bitter enemies of one another, both Iran and US wanted democratization of iraq.... The paper "the us Efforts to Install Democracy in Iraq" discusses that by describing Iran's initial reaction to 9/11 catastrophe and how it gradually modified it, the video expertly underscores the complexity of US Iranian relations while bringing in Hezbollah and Israel in the discussion....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us