StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Civilization and its Discontents: a discussion with Freud - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This is a discussion between a student, Tom, and Freud on Freud’s book Civilization and its Discontents. At individual level most of us traditionally internalize our sense of aggression against ourselves by using our superego to hold the ego in check…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Civilization and its Discontents: a discussion with Freud
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Civilization and its Discontents: a discussion with Freud"

Civilization and its Discontents: a discussion with Freud This is a discussion between a Tom, and Freud on Freud’s book Civilization and its Discontents. Tom: Sir, What did prompt you to write your book Civilization and its Discontents? Freud: The World War 1 events and reign of terror which was unleashed in it by actors of the war mostly influenced my deliberations in this book. This book is in a way extension of my earlier works like Beyond the Pleasure Principle and The Future of an Illusion, so on and so forth.

I had made use of concepts like Super-ego, Ego, Id, Totem and Taboo, Eros and death instinct, which appeared in my earlier works, to explain the domain of civilizations (wikipedia). Tom: Sir, some people say that your pessimism about the human being and human nature is at its peak in this book. Why is it so? Freud: Yes, this notion to a large extent is true. My pessimism about human beings and their nature is not unfounded; the atrocities committed in World War 1, World War 2, Nazis’ massacre in Holocaust, atomic bombs attacks on Japanese cities, Stalin reign of terror to strengthen the Revolution, Saddam’s killings of his masses, 9/11 act of terrorists, Americans atrocities in Iraq and Afghanistan and Musharaf‘s war on terrorism all attest to my deliberations in this book about human nature.

Tom: Sir, you believe that destructive forces are present in all individuals, and thus man by nature, is an essentially anti-social and anti-cultural being as you wrote in your book, "(aggression is) an original self-subsisting instinctual disposition in man . . . the greatest impediment to civilization”. Would you please explain this postulate having in view the present state of American culture and society? Freud: This passage refers to basic human nature; man born with such instincts and drives which compel him/her to be aggressive.

This natural tendency in human beings is not only manifested in individuals and groups but also expressed at society and state level; let me say in the present clash of civilization scenario it is a glaring reality that different civilizations of the world are at daggers drawn against each other. At individual level most of us traditionally internalize our sense of aggression against ourselves by using our superego to hold the ego in check. While we all struggle with many forms of aggression, including anger at ourselves and amongst ourselves, few of us are ever likely to become violent.

Mild bickering and other tempests in tea pots are the usual expressions of our anger. However, we all learn hatred even if we never externalize it outwardly. The most violent individuals do not seem to have a superego that works to keep their ego in check, but their superego strength gets expressed externally onto other individuals, groups, institutions, or even countries. Moving to the most horrific types of aggression once this superego has gone external, it will encompass acts of murder on a variety of fronts such as manslaughter, third, second and first degree murder; Serial killing; mass murder, suicide bombing, so on and so forth.

In your country, America, Timothy McVeigh blowing up a Federal building in Oklahoma City was an act of aggression against government for he was afraid that the government of the United States would take over the lives of all; in his paranoia and delusions of grandeur, he tried to strike back at the government that he saw as so dangerous (Charlotte A. F). What crime gangs commit acts of murders and looting and plundering are yet another manifestation of human aggressive nature; Alqaeda attacks of 9/11 were another example of groups’ aggressive disposition.

At state level, aggressiveness finds its display in the shape of attacks by powerful states on weaker ones as American forces made attacks on Iraq and Afghanistan in the recent past. Human aggressive instincts depiction can also be found in horror movies, novels, children computer games being produced at large scale in America now-a-days. Tom: Sir, you state in your book that technological progress has failed to make humans happier. I strongly disagree to this opinion as I believe that today’s technological progress has made our lives more efficient and interesting, and thus more happy.

What do you say in this regard? Freud: If the phenomena like production of weapons of mass destruction, atomic and biological weapons and depleting of precious natural resources and ever-increasing spoiling of Ozone layer and consequent global warming, so on and so forth, are the fruits of technological progress which are making human lives more happier than making miserable then you are right. Tom: Thank you sir, I had a valuable discussion on your treatise Civilization and its Discontents. Freud: thanks you too Sources Charlotte Ann Frick.

“The Mythos of Terrorism through the Prism of Sigmund Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents”. (date of creation not given). CUNY Graduate School.Jan30, 2008.. gradesaver.com .:Grade Saver”. Date of creation not given. GradeSaver LLC. Jan 30,2008.. en.wikipedia.org .“Civilization and Its Discontents”. last update Dec 27,2007. The free encyclopedia Wikimedia Foundation, Inc..Jan 30,2008. .

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Civilization and its Discontents: a discussion with Freud Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1544288-civilization-and-its-discontents-a-discussion-with-freud
(Civilization and Its Discontents: A Discussion With Freud Essay)
https://studentshare.org/psychology/1544288-civilization-and-its-discontents-a-discussion-with-freud.
“Civilization and Its Discontents: A Discussion With Freud Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1544288-civilization-and-its-discontents-a-discussion-with-freud.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Civilization and its Discontents: a discussion with Freud

Civilization and Its Discontents

In the paper “civilization and its discontents” the author gives Freud's introduction of civilization and its discontents' texts as the irremediable antagonism that exists between various demands of instinct and the restrictions surrounding civilization.... This shows that civilization and its discontents is a great contributor to the Western culture's literature.... hellip; Freud explains that his book does not just barely touch on civilization and instincts, but covers the whole concept and theory of human behaviors, explaining why people behave as they do, with reasons explaining why even the best-intended of people's actions give the impression of having hindered human beings in their life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

'civilization and its discontent, Sigmund Freud

However, in “civilization and its discontents” Freud emphasized the social role of superego in preserving social order by preventing and turning individual aggression against the society which result in increased discontent with civilization.... Freud was controversial and influential and in “civilization and its discontent”, Freud explicitly argues that humankind is violent and cites different terrible instances that suggest part of humankind is violent and he refers to it as “the inclination toward aggression”....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Love and Aggressiveness Are Very Closely Related in Freuds Conception

hellip; Freud discusses the origins of our sentiments of aggression (especially as involved in feelings of guilt) in chapter seven of civilization and its discontents, and finds them to be intimately involved with feelings of love; equally, sentiments of love often originate from feelings of aggression.... Love and aggressiveness are very closely related in freud's conception of a person's social interactions.... Finally, freud deploys his concepts of love and aggression to show that civilized societies are bound to fail: they place restrictions on our natural sentiments of love and aggressiveness which are in many cases insupportable - in particular, he criticises societies founded on the Christian principle of love, and those founded on communist ideas....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Freudianism and Freuds Personality Theory

This idea is supported in Freud's civilization and its discontents ( ) as he discusses the aggressive energy associated with the super-ego.... Sigmund freud was a medical… or who worked with mental patients in Vienna prior to 1959 and is considered one of the founding fathers of modern day psychology because of his development of the psychoanalytic theory.... Originally trained as a neurologist, freud's work with his patients, frustrated by a cre ability to hypnotize, necessarily took on a more imaginative turn that revolutionized the way people approached the treatment of the mind (Robbins, 1999)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Civilization and Its Discontents by Sigmund Freud

The father of psychoanalysis, Sigmund Freud, in his book civilization and its Discontent, maintains it is an indisputable fact that achieving happiness not possible.... This cycle of futile searches for happiness is addressed throughout Freud's civilization and its Discontent.... Freud proposes that the very underpinnings of civilization and systematic factions such as religions are found within the multifaceted development of a person.... In spite of this, freud says people use many ultimately ineffective strategies to compensate for this reality....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Two Types of Happiness Explored by Freud

Freud's happiness connects with the arguments presented through civilization and disconnect.... The paper "The Two Types of Happiness Explored by freud" analyzes the progressive nature of civilization.... freud believes that happiness is undermined by civilization; happiness entails the avoidance of suffering and the bursts of satisfaction that result from the satisfaction of human needs.... freud ascribes to several principles, including that archaeology offers an explanative model for the exploration of the self and the workings of the society....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents

The aim of the current book report is to discuss the relationship between love and aggressiveness as depicted in the work "civilization and its discontents" written by Sigmund Freud.... Freud discusses the origins of our sentiments of aggression (especially as involved in feelings of guilt) in chapter seven of civilization and its discontents, and finds them to be intimately involved with feelings of love; equally, sentiments of love often originate from feelings of aggression....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

How Would Rousseau, Nietzsche, and Freud Assess the Civilizing Process

discusses the publication of Sigmund Freud's "civilization and its discontents", Friedrich Nietzsche's "Twilight of the Idols", and Rousseau's "The Social Contract or the Principles of Political Right".... he propositions concerning the civilization process as Sigmund Freud presents in his publication of civilization and its Discourse intrigue the reader with its persuasive approach to the subject.... Assessing the concepts and contemplations of Freud on the subject from this publication, it is evident he seeks to elaborate on the very structures and stratifications that society considers as civilization and evaluate their impact on humanity....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us