StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Designer Babies and the Concept of Children as Property - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Designer Babies and the Concept of Children as Property” the author tries to answer the questions: Are children the property of their parents? What things are we forbidden to do with/to our children, which we are permitted to do to our property?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Designer Babies and the Concept of Children as Property
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Designer Babies and the Concept of Children as Property"

On Designer Babies and the Concept of Children as Property Are children the property of their parents What things are we forbidden to do with/to ourchildren, which we are permitted to do to our property The notion of children being the property of their parents provides grounds for parents who prostitute their children, compel them into forced labor, or deprive them of quality basic education. It is a notion that cannot be supported by the society that we live in today, whose principles follow the idea of democracy, individualism, and free will. Can children be the property of their parents In a warped-up society that does not espouse respect for individual life and liberty, indeed, children could be relegated as mere property. The notion of children as property, however, cannot thrive in a democratic society such as ours. The relationship between parents and children are very different between the relationship between owner and property. Whereas the owner of a property generally has real right over it, in that he can do anything he wishes to do with it, the same cannot be said in regards to children. We cannot legally dispose of them or any part of their body, either by selling them for adoption or by forcing him to undergo unnecessary surgery. Even when the parent himself is at the brink of death, the child cannot be compelled to donate his organ so as to ensure the success of any organ transplant that would save his father or mother. The child cannot be used as a means to benefit his family, his parents, or even society in general, if the act required of the child will be to his disadvantage. Even when the act required is to the child's advantage, if it is not essential and basic to his survival as a person, he cannot be forced into it. You cannot force a child to take a nap if he does not want to. You can beg him, as is often the case, but this would still entail voluntary assent on his part. Unlike property, a child has a mind and a will of his own, and is awarded specific rights as children and as individuals. Children enjoy a dual role, that of being their parents' child and that of being a separate individual. I think that it is the existence of this dual role that draws the line between what parents can and cannot do with their child. As your child, he can be scolded for not eating his green peas. As an individual, he cannot be forced to eat the green peas. All the rights of an individual are enjoyed by the child, and these are tempered only by your rights as a parent looking after the good of your ward. You are allowed certain privileges that are not enjoyed by people not his parents, but these privileges do not supersede the basic human rights that extend to all individuals. These "privileges", also, are awarded with the presumption that they will be used with the child's welfare in mind. If this presumption is violated, parental rights can be withdrawn by the state such as when children are withdrawn from the custody of their parents. With property, on the other hand, the owner can do whatever he wishes to do with his property for as long as his acts do not endanger the rights of other individuals. This basically means, that if you could place your house in such a location that setting fire to it would not involve the risk of harming other people and their property, then you are quite free to go ahead and burn your house. The relatively new development of "designer babies" places a unique strain on the principle of children as not being the property of their parents. Whereas we would be quick to object if a parent sets his daughter for an involuntary appointment with a plastic surgeon, we are a bit lost when the alterations are made while the child is not yet born. It's a difficult dilemma because it forces us to specify the point when a child already enjoys his rights as an individual person. Coming from a time when abortion of the fetus is generally legalized, then we could not help but say that the object that is being exposed to genetic engineering at that point does not as yet enjoy the rights of children. The genes being altered may be seen as the property of the parents. Generally speaking then, genetic alteration for the purpose of conceiving "designer babies" does not directly violate the principle that a child is not the property of his parent. Although it does not directly violate that principle, however, I do tend to believe that it risks encouraging the re-emergence of the notion of children being perceived as the property of their parents. The use of genetic alteration to create designer babies who are "healthy, disease-free, bright, attractive and alert," as so aptly described by Law, strengthens the notion that children can be bought, or to be more precise, better children can be bought at a better price. This emerging connection between monetary capacity and the ability to get a better child thins the line which place children as distinct and different from one's property. In the same way that designer clothes, cars and houses are employed as status symbols, designer babies could become objectified into the next status symbol for the affluent. It sounds like a far-fetched notion, but I do not believe that this fear is completely baseless. While I do agree with Law that parents cannot be condemned when they go through significant efforts to increase the chances of their child's success, the concept of designer babies has nothing to do with parental effort at all. It's a healthy child for a healthy fee, without having to make them eat vegetables. That's what differentiates genetic altering and being an eager parent. With genetic alteration, you don't need to be a good parent at all, you just need to have the money to get a trouble-free healthy baby. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Designer Babies and the Concept of Children as Property Assignment, n.d.)
Designer Babies and the Concept of Children as Property Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1509668-on-designer-babies-and-the-concept-of-children-as-property
(Designer Babies and the Concept of Children As Property Assignment)
Designer Babies and the Concept of Children As Property Assignment. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1509668-on-designer-babies-and-the-concept-of-children-as-property.
“Designer Babies and the Concept of Children As Property Assignment”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1509668-on-designer-babies-and-the-concept-of-children-as-property.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Designer Babies and the Concept of Children as Property

In-Vitro Fertilization as a Technology

It may be contended that in relation to IVF and the wider concept of designer babies, much of English law is unwarranted and unnecessary.... In particular, this contention is based on the belief that there is no need for the law to intervene in a well-established 'Doctor - parents-to-be' relationship to prevent the latter benefiting from the use of whatever methods of assisted conception are possible to enable them to have children....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Pros of the Breastfeeding

nbsp; Breastfed children usually have a higher IQ than others that are fed on formula milk.... Breastfed children are also seen to have fewer ear infections and fewer allergy contractions.... Breastfed babies are relatively good learners when compared to those who are not.... It has been noted that breastfed babies have lower risks of acquiring multiple sclerosis.... They are more into buying formula cow or Soya milk for their babies....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Trade between UK and China with a Focus on Joint Ventures

It emphasises on quality, protection of children, and is environment-friendly.... Its products are also available for sale online, and it caters to the 0-24 months segment of babies, just like V-Baby and it similarly prioritises baby welfare by using chemical-free soft terry fabric for its nappies, perfect for better baby health....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

Gender-Roles with Five Year Old Children

The theories also assume that gender roles are usually prevalent beliefs within all age setting and children's groups particularly the concept of the dream of being responsible one day just like their parents, uncles or grand parents.... This paper “Gender-roles with five year old children” intends to get preliminary research on the way at which children below the age of five years behave while at the play ground.... hellip; The main aim of this study is to understand the relationship between children's toy selection and gender-roles and also acceptance as observed in the play grounds....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Communication Assignemnt

Common mistakes shared by children as they learn how to communicate for the first time provide clues as to how language development progresses and contribute to a discussion of the average stages of language development exhibited among young children.... Considering language and communication, it seems that all children are born with the ability to learn and learn quickly various methods of connecting with their caregivers and others.... This type of communication is necessarily based on physical actions and tone of cry when the… ild is very small, but as they grow older, children begin to demonstrate that they understand gestures and the words of others even before they have voiced their first word....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Assessment of Language and Communication

Common mistakes shared by children as they learn how to communicate for the first time provide clues as to how language development progresses and contribute to a discussion of the average stages of language development exhibited among young children.... This leads to an investigation of how children seem to have an innate switch designed.... nbsp;… Regardless of the steps taken to encourage language and communication development at a very young age, children do tend to develop along a consistent and predictable acquisition process, most of which occurs before the age of 4....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Fashion Design Technology

The paper "Fashion Design Technology" highlights that Garment and fashion designers are doing their best in order to remain relevant in the market by making clothes that appeal to their clients.... Taonac.... (2012 3) says that, “retail businesses are becoming less brand-centric and more consumer-centric....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Proposal

Physical Activity and Physical Education

Physical education plays a vital role in developing children's motor and body control skills.... The locomotor, non-locomotor, and body control skills turn today's children into tomorrow's healthy adults.... Techniques for assessing locomotor, non-locomotor, and body control skills Physical education plays a vital role in developing children's motor and body control skills.... The locomotor, non-locomotor, and body control skills turn today's children into tomorrow's healthy adults....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us