StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critical Paper of Let's (Not) Get Physicals - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Critique of Let’s (Not) Get Physicals In the article “Let’s Not Get Physicals,” Elisabeth Rosenthal discusses the irrelevance of most medical physicals in America today. She uses three main aspects to make her point. First, she explains the uselessness and possible harm of the tests…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Critical Paper of Lets (Not) Get Physicals
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critical Paper of Let's (Not) Get Physicals"

Download file to see previous pages

For example, she seems to shift blame for the situation to doctors and patients and leaves out key players such as the government and insurance companies. Rosenthal attempts to convince people on the need of not having physicals, especially when the checkups become recommended by doctors and then get approved by insurance companies. Rosenthal, at the beginning of her article, states that she completed medical training in late eighties. This may validate her ability to make distinguishing arguments for or against some medical checkup procedures.

As such, she argues that various health tests are irrelevant and sometimes harmful to the patient. Her article reflects on tests that yield false positives on the first instance, therefore, facilitating the need for further tests. An example of convincingly harmful procedures includes X-rays which expose patients to radiation and over time can lead to health complications. Other medical tests such as blood screenings are intrusive and unnecessary. For instance, the United States Preventive Services Task Force does not recommend antigen specific blood screening to identify prostate cancer.

Nonetheless, close to 80% of urologists still think it is necessary. Rosenthal cites studies by the Canadian government task force in 1979 that provide evidence on the irrelevance of the standard head-to-toe annual physical. The results from these studies show that the tests a) do not yield efficient diagnosis or results and b) may expose patients to harmful, intrusive procedures. However, the author does not clearly articulate whose fault it is that the tests are not accurate. Furthermore, Rosenthal’s thesis mentions potential harm to the patient, but she seems to fail in outlining the clear dangers of engaging in medical checkups.

In her article, Rosenthal speaks of how some procedures are pointless and need to be wiped out from the medical practice. In addition, she insists of some laboratory tests being useless as moreso end up giving false positives hence hindering diagnosis of the real diseases. Furthermore, she continues by mentioning the pointless nature of screening tests as some do not have any influence on the progression of a disease in illnesses that do not have effective treatment. She goes further to give an example of how CT scan can be harmful to a patient through the radiation that it emits, though medical personnel still use it.

She emphasizes that there are quite a number of procedures and tests used in diagnosis and screening of certain diseases, but in real sense, also contribute in causing harm to that given patient. Moreover, Americans spend well over 300 billion dollars on unnecessary tests or treatment each year. Rosenthal also quotes Dr. Ateev Mehrotra, assistant professor at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, who estimates that unneeded blood tests alone consume close to 325 million dollars a year.

The excessive amounts of money spent on medical checkups reflect on the agenda of most doctors and hospitals. Rosenthal reports that doctors and hospitals prefer that patients spend more during medical visits because this is a sure way of making a profit. Another contributor to the inflating cost of healthcare is insurance. This article claims that medical insurance ends up paying large portions of bills for patients with coverage. This economic stimulus is dangerous

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Paper of Let's (Not) Get Physicals Essay”, n.d.)
Critical Paper of Let's (Not) Get Physicals Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1453147-critical-paper-of-let-s-not-get-physicals
(Critical Paper of Let'S (Not) Get Physicals Essay)
Critical Paper of Let'S (Not) Get Physicals Essay. https://studentshare.org/english/1453147-critical-paper-of-let-s-not-get-physicals.
“Critical Paper of Let'S (Not) Get Physicals Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1453147-critical-paper-of-let-s-not-get-physicals.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Paper of Let's (Not) Get Physicals

Immigration and Social Problems

[Your full name] [Instructor's full name] June 06, 2011 Immigration and Social problems Before going to study the benefits that immigrants bring to the United States of America, let us get a better understanding of the reasons, which make people migrate to other countries.... Moreover, the mindset of some immigrants is such that they like to get involved in criminal activities, such as, rape and adultery.... Thesis Statement The thesis statement for the paper is that: People should understand that not all immigrants are bad; rather they play a very considerable role in strengthening the economy of the United States....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Electronic Healthcare System Issues - Risks and Opportunities Involved in Sharing Clinical Data

This paper is a report on electronic healthcare system that analyzes and assesses the challenges that are part of the electronic system.... The paper is assisting managers in the healthcare dealing with information and data management operations.... Electronic Healthcare Information [Introduction] [Instructor Name] Electronic Healthcare System Issues Introduction There are information technology systems to assist healthcare organizations in the challenging environment of healthcare provision where a large numbers of patients have to be treated at the same time....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Sports Education and Society

The term paper "Sports Education and Society" points out that Sport(s) is more important than ever socially, economically and culturally.... This paper, besides being a critical evaluation of the role and impact of sport within our society, also highlights the facts of why it is so important to incorporate it within the National Curriculum.... This research paper has information from both primary as well as secondary sources that include sports journals, books, authentic online sites, and important press releases....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Critic of Pollock's Art

This work called "Critic of Pollock's Art" describes the artist's paintings, his style of art.... The author outlines the role of Lee Krasner in enhancing Pollock's life as an artist.... From this work, it is clear about all peculiarities of his biography, creative development, the modern critic of his paintings....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper

Management of Information Systems

In this paper “Management of Information Systems” first of all, a brief introduction is given as to what a Management Information System is.... hellip; The author states that e-health provides services which let the doctors have an access to their patients' data by maintaining their records and information about their diseases in databases and other e-Health tools, rather than using paper documents.... EHRs are very quick as there is no need for any paper-work for documenting and sharing of the information and images....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

College Level Education Improves the Quality of Our Lives

The paper "College Level Education Improves the Quality of Our Lives" discusses that when a student finds himself burdened with assignments, reports, case studies, homework, exams, tests and others, he learns that life is not a piece of cake and hardships are going to be at every step.... In fact, this paper is an attempt to prove that the point that higher-level education or college or university education is that magic factor.... he rest of this paper would be a series of arguments aimed at explaining why “College level education improves the quality of our lives by providing higher wages, better jobs, successful careers and advanced worldview”....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Electronic Health Records Software Analysis

In fact, Medi Touch from the get-go was designed with Apple's operating system and market influence in mind.... The paper "Electronic Health Records Software Analysis" focuses on examining the Electronic Health Records (EHR) software, Medi Touch, and depicting its qualities, functions, and usability.... HRs are an improvement from paper-based records of patient information in terms of flexibility and leverage, as illustrated by Figures 1....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Change4Life: Health Promotion Campaign Analysis

Mainly the Change4life campaign encourages individuals to adopt six healthy habits such as 5 A Day, watch the salt, cut back fat, sugar swaps, choose less booze, and get going every day.... Finally, the 'get going every day' plan explains to people why it is essential to lead an active lifestyle and how it is possible for adults and children to accomplish it cheaply and easily.... The author of this paper critically evaluates the Change4Life health promotion campaign designed and implemented by the Department of Health....
11 Pages (2750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us