StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Homo Floresiensis in Human Evolution - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Homo Floresiensis in Human Evolution" gives an insight into issues related to Homo floresiensis. An introduction has been given as to what it is and where it was discovered. Its evolution and the discovery of LB1 have been taken into account…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Homo Floresiensis in Human Evolution
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Homo Floresiensis in Human Evolution"

?Homo Floresiensis (LB1) in Human Evolution and Related Controversies One of the most spectacular discoveries in paleoanthropology is theunearthing of the species, Homo floresienses, which is believed to be the most severe form of human ever discovered. This paper gives an insight into issues related to Homo floresiensis. First of all, an introduction has been given as to what it is and where it was discovered. Its evolution and the discovery of LB1 have been taken into account. After that, the controversies that have been rising since the unearthing of LB1 specimen have been discussed in detail. The paper is summarized in a concluding paragraph and Harvard referencing style has been used properly. 2. Introduction to the Hobbit Before going into the details of the subject matter, let’s first get to understand what Homo floresiensis actually is. Homo floresiensis, literally meaning Man of Flores, was discovered by Michael Moore’s team at the Liang Bua cave1 on the island of Flores in Indonesia2 on September 2003. Nicknamed as the Hobbit, it is believed to be a species known for its small sized body and brain whose fossils, according to archeologists, have been found somewhere 38,000 to 18,000 years ago3. More specifically speaking, the size is said to be “only about 1 meter in height and fully bipedal, with a very small brain size of 417cc”4. Homo floresiensis may be called contemporaries of Homo sapiens. Scientists suggest that since it is usual that large mammals may exist on islands in their dwarf form, hence Homo floresiensis may also be a dwarf form of Homo erectus. Mayell5 states that the skulls of the tiny humans were the size of grapefruits and they lived on pygmy elephants, Komodo dragons, and big rats found on the island. 3. Homo Floresiensis (LB1) in Human Evolution 3.1. LB1 LB1 is the one complete-most Homo floresiensis fossil that consists of a complete skull and skeleton found by the discoverer team consisting of Australian and Indonesian paleoanthropologists and archaeologists who went to Flores to find out when and how the Homo sapiens migrated from Asia into Australia crossing the sea barriers. Since they were not prepared to find specimen of a new species, they were surprised to find fossils and remains of non Homo sapiens as old as 38,000 years. The found specimen, LB1, contains leg bones, hands, feet, pelvis, and other remains which are both primitive and derived. LB1 is said to be the fossil of an adult who might be the age of 30. An analysis of its pelvis revealed that it was the skeleton of a female. It would have been a bit larger on size if it was a male although all fossil found so far are of the same size as LB1. Since, the individual was of young age, the bones of the skeleton had not fossilized as yet and are reported to be in the consistency of mashed potatoes or wet blotting paper. The brain size is as small as 380cc that is a chimpanzee’s brain’s size. With the fossils of LB1, some stone tools were also found which a homini with such a small sized brain cannot make. Thus the tools are believed to be created by Homo sapiens. Anthropologists, for example, Peter Brown, Michael Morwood and their colleagues argue about LB1 that “it was contemporaneous with modern humans (Homo sapiens) on Flores”6. 3.2. Evolution Homo floresiensis are said to have evolved from Homo erectus and the result is a tremendous decrease in the body and brain size. Because of the reduced brain size, archeologists also suggest that the “floresiensis might actually have evolved from something smaller, such as the Dmanisi hominids found in Georgia, some of which have brain sizes between 600 and 700 cc, smaller than the 800-900cc typical of early erectus”7. Also, when stone tools were found on another location in Flores in 1998, it was said that these tools may be the creation of Homo erectus because these were the pre-sapiens hominids existing in Indonesia who are thought to have crossed the sea-passage that separates Flores from Java. Some archeologists believe that these were not Homo erectus but Dmanisi hominids or an early evolutionary form of Homo floresiensis. Scientists believe that the discovery and study of Homo floresiensis will not at all the evolutionary history of Homo sapiens as the later is surely not descending from the former. However, we cannot deny the fact that since LB1 type species that has been found on the island of Flores resembles human form and can be said as one of the most severe instances of Homo sapiens, hence Homo sapiens are apt to go through some sort of evolution to have taken the form of the tiny hominids. 4. The Controversies The discovery of the Homo florsiensis brought with it man controversies. Whether it should be considered as a new species has been the most controversial issue in this regard. This controversy was initially put forward by an Indonesian knowledgeable anthropologist, Professor Teuku Jacob of Gadjah Mada University of Indonesia, who claimed that the analysis of LB1 skull shows that LB1 was a modern Homo sapien suffering from microcephaly8 which is “a disease that causes small brain sizes”9. Thus, Jacob argued that LB1 could not be considered as a new species, but can be regarded as a “member of the "Australomelanesid race" of modern humans, and only 1,300 to 1,800 years old”10. Jacob insisted that the find belonged to the omnivorous species of Homo sapiens and was an individual of age lower than 30. According to Jacob, the small skull of LB1 might belong to a mentally abnormal individual or a microcephalic Pygmy. The anatomist, Maciej Henneberg, has also supported this statement. However, Brown et al.11 have contradicted the statement and have suggested that although there is a possibility that a human being may come up as a dwarf because of diseases like microcephaly causing reduction in body and brain sizes, still it is not acceptable that the tiny hominids of Flores were microcephalic humans. According to them, when a human being has microcephaly, then there are very few chances that he will reach adulthood while LB1 was the skeleton of an adult. LB1 has archaic traits that are not found with microcephalic humans but are replicated in early hominids. There are many other specimens from Flores who have the same features as archaic traits in the skeletons, and it is not acceptable that such a wide number of microcephalic humans many have evolved in an island. Hence, according to Brown et al., Homo Floresiensis are not just a form of Homo sapiens, but a different species. In 2005, a study was conducted under the supervision of Dean Falk12 who created a CT scan of LB1’s skull and produced a computer generated model. It also showed that the Homo florsiensis were a new species as the skull analysis gave no proof that it belonged to a malformed skull or a microcephalic brain. This study was also contradicted by another research conducted by Weber, Czarnetzki and Pusch13 who affirmed that it was not a new species but microcephalic Homo sapiens. Many researchers have also conducted their researches upon solving this controversy, and most of them have to the conclusion that the researchers, who call LB1 a microcephalic Homo sapiens, have not actually compared the LB1 skull with that of a real microcephalic skull because LB1 brain size was much smaller than that of a microcephalic brain. For LB1 brain size, the size of the whole skeleton should also have been much smaller if it was just a microcephalic being. In 200614 and 200715, Dean Falk, despite all contradictions upon his study, still insisted that the bone and skeletal structure of LB1 were of a diseased modern human. Hershkovitz et al.16 raised another controversy arguing that LB1’s morphological features show that it was a human being with Laron syndrome, a research that Falk et al.17 have rejected in their study concluding that “the type Specimen (LB1) of Homo ?oresiensis did not have Laron Syndrome.” 5. Conclusion The unearthing of Homo floresiensis has brought with it many questions regarding whether it should be considered as a new species that might have evolved on the island of Flores, or should be regarded as an ancestor of Homo sapiens or they might be diseased Homo sapiens. Many researchers have conducted studies on the specimen of LB1, analyzing the bone and skull structure and brain size, producing computer generated images of the brain and comparing it with microcephalic instances from humans. Some consider it an evolved form of Homo erectus; some regard it as descendants of Dmanisi hominids; and, some argue that they are an extreme form of modern day human beings that might have migrated to the island of Flores crossing the sea passage. Despite all the efforts to uncover the truth, the controversies and contradictions still remain and the question regarding the evolution of the Hobbit is still to be answered. (Note for the Admin: the word count is equal to 6 pages excluding the footnotes.) References Brown, P, Sutikna, T, Morwood, M, Soejono, RP, Jatmiko, SEW et al. 2004, ‘A new small-bodied hominin from the late Pleistocene of Flores, Indonesia’. Nature, vol. 431, pp. 1055-1061. Falk, D, Hildebolt, C, Smith, K, Morwood, MJ, Sutikna, T, Brown, P, Jatmiko, WSE, Brunsden, B & Prior, F 2005, ‘The brain of LB1, Homo floresiensis’, Science, vol. 308, no. 5719, p. 242. Falk, D, Hildebolt, C, Smith, K, Morwood, MJ, Sutikna, T, Jatmiko, WSE, Brunsden, B & Prior, F 2006, ‘Response to comment on "The Brain of LB1, Homo floresiensis"’, Science, vol. 312, p. 999c. doi:10.1126/science.1124972. Falk, D, Hildebolt, C, Smith, K, Morwood, MJ, Sutikna, T, et al. 2007, ‘Brain shape in human microcephalics and Homo floresiensis’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 104, no. 7, p. 2513. Falk, D, Hildebolt, C, Smith, K, Jungers, W, Larson, S, Morwood, M, et al. 2009, ‘The type specimen (LB1) of Homo ?oresiensis did not have Laron Syndrome’, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, pp. 1-12. Foley, J 2005, Homo Floresiensis: The Hobbit, viewed 14 January 2011, Hershkovitz, I, Kornreich, L, Laron, Z 2007, ‘Comparative skeletal features between Homo floresiensis and patients with primary growth hormone insensitivity (Laron Syndrome)’, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., vol. 134, no. 2, pp. 198–208. Jacob, T, Indriati, E, Soejono, RP, Hsu, K, Frayer, DW, Eckhardt, RB, Kuperavage, AJ, Thorne, A & Henneberg, M 2006, ‘Pygmoid Australomelanesian Homo sapiens skeletal remains from Liang Bua, Flores: Population affinities and pathological abnormalities’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, vol. 103, pp. 13421–13426. Mayell, H 2004, ‘Hobbit-like human ancestor found in Asia’, National Geographic, viewed 14 January 2011, Schalley, AC & Khlentzos, D 2007, ‘Mental States: Evolution, Function, Nature’, illustrated edition, John Benjamins Publishing Company, USA. Weber, J, Czarnetzki, A & Pusch, CM 2005, ‘Comment on "The Brain of LB1, Homo floresiensis"’, Science, vol. 310, no. 5746, p. 236. doi: 10.1126/science.1114789. WorldLingo Translations LLC 2011, Homo Floresiensis, viewed 14 January 2011, Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Human origins, human problems Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1405429-human-origins-human-problems
(Human Origins, Human Problems Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1405429-human-origins-human-problems.
“Human Origins, Human Problems Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1405429-human-origins-human-problems.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Homo Floresiensis in Human Evolution

Impact of Recently Discovered Hominins on the Understanding of Human Phylogeny

Name: University: Course: Tutor: Date: Impact of recently discovered hominins on the understanding of human phylogeny and biology The discovery of Australopithecus sediba and homo floresiensis offer us clues to an important transition in our evolution.... New hominids hit the scene, species that were subsequently christened homo, which is Latin for man.... With the coming of these hominids, came the flattening of the snout and the shortening of the hook-like fingers of the australopiths, an evolutionary process that is assumed to have given birth to modern man (homo sapiens)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Evolution of the genus homo

The recent discovery of a hominid species in Indonesia, which has been given the nomenclature homo floresiensis, whose existence is under active debate has confounded many anthropologists with one opinion suggesting that the species may have evolved from an early migration of the Homo erectus which was dwarfed due to peculiar ecological factors in the region (Finlayson, 2005).... 28 May 2015 evolution of the Genus Homo Life has evolved on Planet Earth over millions of years in a wonderful process of selection and favor for particular genera and species and the Genus Homo is no exception....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

An Analysis of the Significance of Guns as a Technology

Five distinct groups of early humans were identified such as the Neanderthals, Cro-Magnon (early homo sapiens), Homo erectus, the Denisovans and last, homo floresiensis (alternatively called as the hobbits, found only in Indonesia).... human societies progress and change over long periods of time through either of the two change processes: evolutionary and revolutionary change.... Discussion Many changes occurred as human societies and civilization progressed, which had in a way contributed greatly to our improvement....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Connection Between Problems And Parallels

The species homo Erectus was almost human because it was an advanced hominid that walked upright on two legs.... It was once thought that Neanderthals with their larger body size and heavier skulls were an earlier form of humanoid but scholars now accept that they are part of the same species as homo sapiens and probably interbred with the more slender form of human that we resemble today.... This species disappeared 230,000 years ago and was replaced by homo sapiens....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Human Evolution Process Peculiarities

This paper "human evolution Process' Peculiarities " focuses on the fact that initial classification and taxonomy of the hominids proved inconsistent as more specimens were discovered across the world.... Understanding the adaptive traits of the Homo erectus species and other close hominids assists learners to support or disband independent discoveries surrounding the unravelling of human evolution from primates.... Erectus has been studied to reveal that an important transition occurred to change the entire evolution journey at around the time the hominid existed....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Human Ancestry: Homo Erectus, Neanderthal Man and Homo Heidelbergensis

erectus would eventually give rise to a host of other early humans such as Homo heidelbergensis, and homo floresiensis though scientists still do not agree on whether the species is a direct human ancestor to Homo sapiens.... The author of the paper gives detailed information about human ancestry.... erectus first evolved from an earlier human ancestor known as Homo habilis, in East Africa.... The author describes homo Erectus which was discovered in Indonesia, Neanderthal Man discovered near Heidelberg and homo Heidelbergensis that inhabited Europe and parts of western Asia....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Advantages of Bipedalism

nbsp;… This assignment also discusses homo sapiens idaltu that was found at Herta in Ethiopia and has been dated at 160,000 years ago.... Its cranial capacity is bigger than that of homo sapiens but otherwise is very close to modern humans.... Although it is often said that these three form a lineage, homo sapiens is so close to modern humans, it could possibly be a side branch on the primate tree....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Dikikka Child and Homo Floresiensis

The fossil caused a rethinking of human evolution due to several of its features.... The debate over accuracy is attributable to how they have reshaped theories on human evolution.... This assignment "The Dikikka Child and homo floresiensis" presents the Dikikka Child, or Lucy's baby, as the name given to a 3.... nbsp;           homo floresiensis is a unique species discovered in Flores, Indonesia....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us