StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

European Sovereign Debt Crisis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "European Sovereign Debt Crisis" highlights that European Union has a Growth and Stability Pact, in which the main goal is to protect against fiscal deficits and excessive government debt, the crisis proved that this measure is not sufficient…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
European Sovereign Debt Crisis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "European Sovereign Debt Crisis"

Table of Contents Introduction 2 2. Determinants of the crisis 2 3. Impact on bond market and implications for other markets 3 4. Lessons from other defaulted countries 8 5. Policies and Measures 8 6. Perspectives 10 7. Conclusion 11 Reference List 12 1. Introduction Recent years have proved to be challenging for Europe’s economy, which was affected by two major crises: a banking crisis and a sovereign debt crisis. It is important to analyze this topic in order to draw lessons from the past events, and to consider measures appropriate to be taken. This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 provides an overview of the causes which determined the recent crisis, Section 3 discusses implications for other markets, Section 4 overlooks lessons from other defaulted countries, Section 5 underlines policies and measures taken to counteract the crisis, and the paper ends with Sections 6 and 7 which provide perspectives and conclusion. 2. Determinants of the crisis The systemic causes of the sovereign debt crisis are the imbalances in the European Monetary Union, and the global political economics. Related to the first cause, three important aspects must be mentioned. One of them is lack of flexibility for the labor market, which is necessary when considering a monetary union (Heinz, & Ward-Warmedinge, 2006). Secondly, the necessity of international fiscal transfers for asymmetric imbalances was not accomplished. Another reason was the lack of flexibility of the capital and product markets, which did not respond to competitive market forces (Grahl, 2011). In what concerns the second cause of the sovereign debt crisis i.e. global political economics, it is well argued that Germany’s politics have affected the EMU and increased the severity of this crisis. More specifically, Germany’s act as an export country with mercantilist origins created significant losses for the other countries in the EMU, and can be responsible for the current crisis (Conquest, R., & Bruges Group, 2011). 3. Impact on bond market and implications for other markets From the start of the sovereign debt crisis, the long-term government bond yields of some countries from the euro zone (Greece, Italy, Spain, Portugal, and Ireland) have intensively increased compared to the German Bunds. In the next figure is provided an overview of the downward trend of the price of the Italian 10 years’ government bonds (the relationship between yield and price is inverse proportional). Figure no. 1 Evolution of the price of Italian 10 years’ government bonds Source: Bloomberg. An explanation for the spreads in bond yields are: an aggregate risk factor, the country credit risk and the chain effect from the situation in Greece (Santis, 2012). If the last factor is straightforward, the first two factors need to be explained. The first factor i.e. aggregate risk is an indicator of changes in monetary policy, as well as global situation and investors risk aversion (Wall, Minocha & Rees, 2010). On the other hand, the country risk factor is an indicator of the country’s ability to repay its sovereign debt, and it is as well connected to raising funds and liquidity (Howells & Bain, 2007) In what concerns the impact on other markets, spillovers from the bond market affected financial intermediaries (for instance: bank lending) and stock and commodities markets, and also determined shifts in investor market sentiment and changes in investors’ risk aversion (Massa, Keane, and Kennan, 2012). In the following figures, can be seen the effects of the crisis on the Euro Stoxx 50 Index and FTSE 100 Index. Figure no. 2 Evolution of Euro Stoxx 50 Index Source: Bloomberg. Figure no. 3 Evolution of FTSE 100 Index Source: Bloomberg. Other effects are related to the announcements of credit rating agencies, which have many considerations before downgrading or upgrading a country’s rating. Credit ratings agencies are considered to have an important economic role for the financial market (Bogaertz, Cremers & Goetzmann, 2012) due to their goal of assigning opinions about the creditworthiness of debt instruments and issuers. A study made on a market based economy – U.K., by Barron et al. (1997), identified significant abnormal stock returns as a cause of bond rating downgrades and positive credit watch announcements. For the case of euro zone, the announcement of future downgrading of the Greek sovereign bond on February 24th, 2010 determined a decrease of 2% in most of the European stock markets. Also, as it was mentioned previously, the commodities market was also affected, and this lead to a decline in the derivatives market which have as underlying assets the respective commodities. The following figure depicts the decrease in commodity futures prices. Figure no. 4 Evolution of Futures Commodities Prices Source: Bloomberg. There are implications of this crisis also for the exchange rates. As will be seen next when considering the history of other defaulted countries, a currency crisis is interrelated to the banking and sovereign debt crisis. The next figures show the evolution of the euro currency with respect to American dollar, and sterling pound as the sovereign debt crisis has deepened. Figure no. 5 Evolution of EUR/USD Source: Bloomberg. Figure no. 6 Evolution of EUR/GBP Source: Bloomberg. 4. Lessons from other defaulted countries The crisis which hit Argentina several years ago, can offer some lessons for what is happening nowadays in the euro zone. One important issue in this matter is related to the fiscal deficit. Measures such as decreases in nominal expenditures and/or increases in taxes are not appropriate in the case of recessions. Secondly, considering that the public sector is large, it is inappropriate to use deflation to correct the overvaluation of the currency (Cavallo, 2011). Furthermore, devaluation in a dollarised economy (euro-ised in the case of Greece) can be problematic as it can lead to significant balance-sheet problems that need some form of government intervention (Geithner, 2003). Another defaulted country which experienced a similar crisis to that of the euro zone is Russia. Russian experienced a crisis in 1998 due to the default of sovereign debt, but also due to its banking system. The default of Russia lead to a systemic failure of other markets, and determined an increase in the credit spreads of sovereign debts (Mortikov and Volonkin, 1999). A major lesson which can be learned from Russian experience is that government intervention through fiscal system is not appropriate in times of crisis. 5. Policies and Measures The European Union policies have as main objective the maintenance of price stability, but this crisis proved that this condition is not a sufficient one. The systemic risk and financial instability determined the present crisis and put pressure on medium-term price stability, which needed to be counteracted by central banks decisions. At the start of the financial crisis, the banking system decreased the interbank lending due to counterparty and liquidity risks. So, the short-term interest rates in the interbank market were disconnected from the ECB’s main policy rate, and became impossible for the ECB to have an influence to the general economic activity through this instrument – interest rates (Candelon & Palm, 2010). Trying to solve this issue and also because of the collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008, ECB focused on the liquidity in the interbank market through expansion of the list of eligible collateral for refinancing operations. Moreover, refinancing operations for longer maturities, including six month and one year maturities were introduced in order to help the banks to manage the problems with the liquidity. One of the non-standard measures applied by ECB in 2009 in order to counteract the crisis was the Covered Bond Purchase Programme (CBPP1), which underlined a purchase of €60 billion worth of covered bonds between July 2009 and July 2010. The main objectives of this programme were: a decrease in short - term rates, a ease in financing requirements for credit institutions, a stimulation for these to lend more, and an improvement of liquidity (Ismailescu & Kazemi, 2010). Another measure taken by ECB was the Securities Markets Programme (SMP), launched in May 2010, which had the objective to protect the monetary policy transmission mechanism. This programme was supposed to correct issues related to key government and private bond market segments. 6. Perspectives From the sovereign debt crisis which affected the euro zone, can be drawn important lessons. One of them is related to the monetary policy of the central bank, which should have the same main objective i.e. price stability. It is the duty of central banks to ensure financial stability and liquidity to the market. A second lesson is concerning the need for the euro area governments to make structural reforms and sustain healthy fiscal policies, within the euro area governance framework. In this matter, maybe fiscal policies should follow the same strict framework, as well as monetary policies. Although some measures were taken in this matter, there is still room for improvement. Moreover, the financial sector should suffer reforms in matter of supervision and regulation. In time of crisis, credit institutions have been rescued and benefited from the help of central banks, but they should asses better the risks to which they are exposed in order to avoid similar situations in the future. In what concerns regulations, Basel III is an important regulation in matters of considering a higher minimum capital ratio and a more sane risk management from the financial institutions (Madura, 2010). Although, the European Union has a Growth and Stability Pact, which main goal is to protect against fiscal deficits and excessive government debt, the crisis proved that this measure is not sufficient. Future considerations should be made regarding this pact, as well as promoting a sane fiscal policy by adequate governance of these principles. Compliance of the principles stated in the pact, as well as penalties for the countries which do not succeed to comply with them is an area which needs to be revised in order to prevent other recessions. 7. Conclusion Throughout this paper, important aspects related to the sovereign debt crisis were discussed. It should be remembered the role of key institutions in providing an efficient adjustment mechanism to economic shocks because in a monetary union, the countries do not have the instrument to change the nominal exchange rate in order to counteract internal and external imbalances. It can be sustained that the measures taken to counteract the sovereign debt crisis had a role in providing financial intermediation in the euro area. These measures ensured the financing requirements of the banking system, and as well restore some of the confidence of the investors, participants in the financial markets. Furthermore, the considerations of ECB ensured the expansion of lending, and finally contributed to the main objective of maintaining the price stability. Reference List Barron, M.J., Clare, A.D. and Thomas, S.H., 1997. The Effect of Bond Rating Changes and New Ratings on UK Stock Returns. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 3(24), pp. 497-509. Bloomberg, 2012. Bloomberg. [online] Available at www.bloomberg.com [Accessed 18 October 2012]. Bogaertz, D., Cremers, K.J. and Goetzmann, W., 2012. Tiebreaker: Certification and Multiple Credit Ratings. The Journal of Finance, LXVII(1), pp. 113-152. Candelon, B. and Palm, F., 2010. Banking and Debt Crises in Europe: The Dangerous Liaisons?. The Economist, 158(1), pp. 81-99. Cavallo, D., 2011. Looking at Greece in the Argentinean mirror. [online] Available at VoxEU.org [Accessed 18 October 2012]. Conquest, R. and Bruges Group, 2011. German economic policy and the Euro 1999-2010. London: Bruges Group. Geithner, T., 2003. Lessons from the Crisis in Argentina. Occasional Papers IMF, 236. Grahl, J., 2011. Crisis in the Eurozone. Soundings, 47(47), pp. 143 – 158. Heinz, F.F. and Ward-Warmedinge, M., 2006. Cross-border Labour Mobility within an enlarged EU. Occasional Paper Series ODI, 52. Howells, P. and Bain, K., 2007. Financial Markets and Institutions. Harllow: Pearson Education Limited. Ismailescu, I. and Kazemi, H., 2010. The Reaction of Emerging Market Credit Default Swap Spreads to Sovereign Credit Rating Changes. Journal of Banking & Finance, 34, pp. 2861-2873. Madura, J., 2010. Financial Institutions and Markets. 9th ed. Connecticut: South-Western Cengage Learning. Massa, I., Keane, J., and Kennan, J., 2012. The euro zone crisis and developing countries. Working Papers ECB, 345. Mortikov, V. and Volonkin, V., 1999. The debt crisis in Russia. Russian & East European Finance & Trade, 35(2), pp. 31-42. Santis, R., 2012. The euro area sovereign debt crisis: Safe heaven, credit rating agencies, and the spread of the fever from Greece, Ireland and Portugal. Working Paper Series ECB, 1419. Wall, S., Minocha, S. and Rees, B., 2010. International Business. 3rd ed. Harlow: Prentice Hall. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(European Sovereign Debt Crisis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words, n.d.)
European Sovereign Debt Crisis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1784371-european-sovereign-debt-crisis
(European Sovereign Debt Crisis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
European Sovereign Debt Crisis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1784371-european-sovereign-debt-crisis.
“European Sovereign Debt Crisis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1784371-european-sovereign-debt-crisis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF European Sovereign Debt Crisis

Current Issue Project

Consequences of Germany Abandoning Euro and Alternative Strategies A political fear regarding EU sovereign debt crisis and leaving of member countries such as Germany from Eurozone will send a global economic shock wave of disrupting the financial markets throughout the world (Eichengreen, 2007, pp.... Another way out of the sovereign debt crisis would be to aim at a growth rate of at least 5% so that it could tackle its debt burden with productivity and long term growth....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Macroeconomics

In the last two years, developed countries have witnessed serious financial instability, and are at present trying to tackle the problem of a widening sovereign-debt and unemployment crisis.... The consequence of the crisis would involve emerging countries leading the way by playing a role in a global economy struggling with protracted rehabilitation related to the over-stretched balance sheets in developed countries (Lachman 66).... Is austerity an appropriate answer to deal with excessive public debt?...
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

The potential impact of the current debt crisis in Europe on the U.S. finanancial market

There are eminent impacts of this debt crisis on U.... Furthermore, in case Spain, Italy or Greece default occurs due to the crisis, a political The debt crisis in Europe has wide fetched impacts globally.... There are eminent impacts of this debt crisis on U.... The debt crisis will halt the recovery of the economy, thereby increasing the unemployment rate.... n the financial market, debt crisis has led to great speculative trading....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The European debt crisis of 2009

The crisis started to emerge when, during 2009, a group of 10 central banks of the bloc asked for a bailout package owing to their inability to pay off debt due to liquidity crunch and a greater danger of sovereign debt crisis started to emerge.... Ireland was another major economy which was hit hard by the sovereign debt crisis due to the fact that Irish government actually guaranteed the loans of six large banks having portfolios in the property sector.... The author of the essay entitled "The European debt crisis of 2009" focuses on the financial crisis....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Financial Risks Corvette Company Is Facing

$2,150,000 that HSBC is willing to pay a US based super car may be a good deal and at the same a bad deal.... The decision lies with the sales manager and the Chief Executive Officer.... It is a matter of risk taking. 5.... The manager had his own reasons for giving in to the offer.... hellip; According to the CEO, the offer may cost the company....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

European Monetary Situation about the Greek Sovereign Debt Crisis

The government would be compelled European Monetary Situation in Relation to the Greek sovereign debt crisis al Affiliation European Monetary Situation inRelation to the Greek Sovereign Debt CrisisHad Greece opted to fully pay their restructured debt and reduce on government expenditure, then its economy would have greatly suffered.... ?The European debt crisis: The Greek Case.... The European Central Bank would be left holding an enormous Greek debt with limited options....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

A Threat to UKs Parliamentary System

In 2008, the Independence Party (UK) gained its initial Parliamentary seat, illustrating the increasing cynicism with the EU in Britain, accompanied by a feeling worsened by the 2008 financial crisis and latest austerity dealings in Greece.... Parliamentary sovereignty is a cornerstone of the UK constitution making the Parliament the sovereign legal body in the UK that makes or removes any law (Kellerman 2011, pg.... This essay discusses why Britain should opt out of the union. These EUROPEAN UNION MEMBERSHIP; A THREAT TO UK'S PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEM By + of European Union Membership; A Threat to UK's Parliamentary SystemParliamentary sovereignty is a cornerstone of the UK constitution making the Parliament the sovereign legal body in the UK that makes or removes any law (Kellerman 2011, pg....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Analysis of Articles by Roben Farzad, Rachel King, and Dexter Roberts

While the United States economic recession contributed to these measures, more recently the European Sovereign Debt Crisis has hurt China as Europe is the main destination for Chinese manufacturing exports.... The chairman of BlackRock, Laurence Fink, referred to these ETFs as toxic and compares them to the financial crisis that collapsed the United States economy....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us