StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Concepts of Quality Theories - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The word “quality” is synonymous with a good product or service to the buyers and the consumers of these things yet the word itself can mean different things to different people. In the business corporate world, quality can mean the absence of defects or it can mean an…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Concepts of Quality Theories
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Concepts of Quality Theories"

The paper “Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosby’s Concepts of Quality Theories" is a fascinating example of a term paper on health sciences & medicine. The word “quality” is synonymous with a good product or service to the buyers and the consumers of these things yet the word itself can mean different things to different people. In the business corporate world, quality can mean the absence of defects or it can mean an acceptable level of defective products (meaning, within certain tolerable limits or allowances).

Quality can be quite subjective too, as some people consider what is good as already a quality output product yet other people may consider the same thing as defective, to an extent of non-conformance to its original specifications. Quality can be used as a strategic tool for any business organization to gain a lasting competitive advantage; but on the other hand, quality can also be very elusive and ethereal in the sense it sometimes defies easy definition or clear-cut categorization. Management of quality has been extended to many industries including the health care industry.

  Discussion Quality in the health care industry is of paramount importance because of lives that are at stake. A simple mistake or error can result in a legal suit, costly litigation, revocation of license, and even serious harm or injury to a patient, and in extreme cases, the death of that patient. This precarious situation makes it imperative health care professionals who render service should be always aware of how quality can affect the lives of people under their care. However, it is also a sad fact that errors in health care delivery cannot be avoided due to a number of human factors such as fatigue, lack of expertise, incomplete knowledge, and inadequate training in their field.

It has been estimated about 100,000 lives are lost annually due to errors committed by practitioners such as in wrong dosages, wrong medication, wrong diagnosis, and wrong surgical procedures. Quality management has been introduced into the health care industry to prevent such errors. Management experts have come up with many theories about quality in terms of making improvements or even eliminating defects completely. The two foremost management of quality theories are the ones propounded by Dr. W. Edwards Deming and by Philip Crosby who had published a best-selling book on quality management entitled “Quality is Free” but both of them exerted profound influences on how management today tackles issues of quality control.

Deming is considered as the father and to have started the quality revolution especially in Japan although it is only recently the United States of America recognized his work (Deming, 2000, p. vii). Deming's whole body of work on quality can be encapsulated in what is called as the “System of Profound Knowledge” or SoPK which is the culmination of a lifetimes work on the issue of quality improvement and management. In essence, what his theory emphasizes is that all organizations (whether for profit or not, whether private or public) are actually a whole system that consists of a network of interdependent components that need to work smoothly together to achieve whatever the aim of that organization is.

In other words, it is a holistic approach to the issue of quality by making quality an issue with the whole system and just with one department at the expense of another department (The W. Edwards Deming Institute, 2014, para. 4). On the other hand, the quality control theory by Philip Crosby differs from the theory of Deming in that Mr. Crosby believed in the prevention of defects from ever happening in the first place by doing things right the first time around. He does not believe in solving quality problems by looking for situations of where, why, and how the defect happened but instead look for ways to prevent the defect from happening in the first place.

Stated differently, what Deming advocated is an incremental method for correcting defects while the theory of Crosby is quite revolutionary in the sense it advocates for a new way of thinking, a paradigm shift, that any defect is a failure. Deming's theory is more inclined toward quality improvement and that of Crosby is more towards quality management (total control of defects by prevention). In this regard, the theory of Crosby is more suitable to health care management because Crosby does not allow for defects to happen at all; any defect is evidence of a failure somewhere (The British Library Board, n.d., para. 3) by management.

It is difficult to compute an acceptable level of failures or defects in the delivery of health care because people are involved and patients could possibly die thereof. The need for quality control is greater in health care than in any other comparable industry. His “zero defect” (Crosby, 1980, p. 116) is the best suited because medical errors are often preventable. Hospitals and other health care institutions have empowered their employees only to a limited extent because of variability in the delivery of health care and the threats of litigation by which the hospital or institution is sued for negligence under tort laws.

One way to empower employees is to appoint a chief medical officer (CMO) knowledgeable about all operations of a hospital and trains all the employees on the extent of their delegated responsibilities. In this way, there is a clear demarcation of authority and responsibilities to avoid confusion and avoid the all-too-common finger-pointing or shifting the blame to someone else for any mistakes. Conclusion Management can empower employees by emphasizing the value of team efforts. In this instance, the theory of Deming is more appropriate as he stated that everybody should gain and not at the expense of anybody or any department.

Taking the systems approach of Deming can be translated to employee empowerment because everyone is involved and this will raise morale among the employees by working together to attain a common objective or shared aim. The fear that goes with empowerment is the fear by the management of losing control (Kinlaw, 1995, p. 28).

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Term Paper, n.d.)
Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1816006-deming-and-crosby-theories-for-quality-improvement-in-healthcare
(Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Term Paper)
Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1816006-deming-and-crosby-theories-for-quality-improvement-in-healthcare.
“Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Term Paper”. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1816006-deming-and-crosby-theories-for-quality-improvement-in-healthcare.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Quality Improvement in Healthcare - Differences in Deming and Crosbys Concepts of Quality Theories

Quality Improvement Measurement Tools

hellip; A number of quality measurement tools are available that healthcare managers can use to ensure improvement in healthcare processes.... These charts would help me isolate the 20 per cent causes that give rise to 80 per cent problems in healthcare processes.... Those tools help managers analyze the functioning of different healthcare processes, compare the results with previous outcomes, make required improvement in functions, and monitor the progress of functions....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Investigation Theories Of The Problems Of Healthcare Quality

The ground theory as stated will also be considered due to the need of quality and reliability of data.... The purpose statement of the research "Investigation theories Of The Problems Of Healthcare Quality" is to test the qualitative theories from the department of health services and public health because of the growing concern of health disparities in the U.... Investigation theories Of The Problems Of Healthcare QualityPurpose statement The purpose statement of this research will be to test the qualitative theories from the department of health services and public health because of the growing concern of health disparities in the U....
2 Pages (500 words) Coursework

Monitoring Data and Quality Improvement

ealth care organizations use quality improvement techniques to guide decision-making through various means: integrating quality improvement methods in their organization's policy and procedures; following a specifically designed handbook; through regular orientation, training, and development programs; and through being kept apprised of best practices, evidence-based nursing methods and new developments on the subject of quality improvement in health care.... nbsp;The challenges encountered by organizations in applying quality improvement techniques to guide decision making include: (1) costs in designing, implementing and monitoring of the outcomes of quality improvement technique that cater to the specific needs and requirements of the organization; (2) complying with regulatory requirements, particularly “federal regulations governing the ethical conduct of human subjects research” (Baily, 2008, p....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Quality in Healthcare

There are numerous distinctive tools, and the aptitude of quality experts lies in their capability to take an application from one field or industry and apply it, or adjust it, to particular circumstances in different fields.... This will help in the training of the staffs to understand the various procedures application in healthcare.... Ten challenges in improving quality in healthcare: lessons from the Health Foundation's programme evaluations and relevant literature....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Quality Improvement Issue

In this regard, prolonged waiting times in my organization means that care is not provided in a Clinic wait times Clinic wait times One of the major issue in my organization that need to be redesigned for quality improvement is clinic wait times.... BJM quality improvement Reports 2(2), 1-5.... Strategies to reduce patient waiting times in my organization needs to be redesigned in order to improve quality of care provided.... Crossing the quality chasm: A new health system for the 21st century....
1 Pages (250 words) Term Paper

Institute of Medicine framework for healthcare quality

In 2001, a commission of the Institute of Medicine (IOM) released a report on health care quality in the US (Institute for Healthcare Improvement, 2015).... According to National Research Council (2001), the report's framework of health care quality involved the evaluation of… These components included safety (the avoidance of patients injuries from the health care processes), effectiveness (the avoidance of overuse or underuse of facilities), patient-centeredness (the ability to provide care which is responsive to patients Health Care quality due: In 2001, a commission of the Institute of Medicine (IOM) released areport on health care quality in the US (Institute for Healthcare Improvement, 2015)....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

International Quality Management System

A product or service might be remarkable in the sense of quality because of its ability to exceed customer expectation and achieving satisfaction.... The achievement of quality is a process because quality helps in the creation of value for both customers and the business.... Juran developed the Juran's trilogy that had quality improvement, quality control and quality planning as the three main elements.... In… quality also helps in influencing customer satisfaction, which in turn influences brand loyalty, making it important for a business to Delivering quality products and services also help in building a reputation for business, which influences the achievement of competitive advantage (Goetsch & Davis, 2013)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

The Provision of Quality Health Services

rganizations that Influence Quality ImprovementsAmong the imperative bodies that influence quality improvement in the health sector are health associations for instance: The American Public Health Association which has been active in conducting training programs, standardization, and stipulation of policies that are geared towards improving quality.... The provision of quality health services is fundamental to the success of any society; the government, development agents, experts as well as the society play an important role in promoting quality health....
3 Pages (750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us