StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Health Promotion Campaign in China - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
John Owen’s monitoring form is selected in the paper "Health Promotion Campaign in China" to enable performance monitoring and provide feedback from the ongoing promotion program. The impact form was selected to measure the effectiveness or the extent of outcomes of the health promotion program…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Health Promotion Campaign in China"

Evaluation Forms and their Application 1. Introduction This assignment will discuss and analyse the health promotion campaign in China that started way back in 1986. In 2011, the Alliance for a Cavity-Free Future conducted a case study of “Love Teeth Day” or LTD which was launch to increase public awareness of oral health through different health promotion approaches. The selected evaluation forms are monitoring and impact. John Owen’s monitoring form is selected in order to enable performance monitoring and provide feedback from the ongoing health promotion programme. Similarly, the impact form was selected to measure the effectiveness or the extent of outcomes of the health promotion programme such as changes in attitudes and behaviour towards health (Owen, 2006). 2. Monitoring Evaluation (Form 1) Monitoring evaluation is generally about ensuring the programmes are being delivered in the agreed or planned manner. These include analysis of programme components, individual assessment, and overall programme implementation analysis. The purpose of this form is to help improve the programme by identifying flaws and shortcoming in the earliest possible time. For example, monitoring evaluation can check whether the programme is indeed reaching its intended beneficiaries or answer important questions such as; is the programme on track? What are the problems in delivery? How is the progress compared to previous month’s performance? and so on. According to the Alliance for a Cavity-Free Future or ACFF, the health promotion is reaching over 600 million people. These include providing actual oral health services, preventive and therapeutic services, health education materials, and promotion through mass media, and festivals. Every year, impact evaluation is being done by the national oral care committee to assess the programme’s effectiveness and overall oral health outcomes. However, the case study does not indicate any monitoring evaluation or assessment conducted since 1989 up to the present. Even during the programme expansion in 1995, there is no indication that the decision was encouraged by any programme monitoring result (ACFF, 2011). The monitoring form is therefore is very useful in this situation in the sense that such nationwide health programmes affecting millions of people involve significant resources that must use correctly. The components of the programme that may be measured by this evaluation form is the target population, compliance to specified implementation plan, effectiveness, the cost being incurred, and the balance between effectiveness and the cost of implementing the programme. For example, the 1995 expansion programme was intended to provide health education to additional 11 provinces (ACFF, 2011) but did it reach the target population. Similarly, the 1998 campaign was specifically to promote oral health care and awareness in rural communities (ACFF, 2011) but did it comply with the agreed implementation plan. Monitoring evaluation can help remove these uncertainties and provide clear picture of the progress and resources being use to implement the programme. It can identify the number of those being served on specific period and those that require further attention. Moreover, since the programme according to ACFF (2011) requires a lot of funding and assistance from professionals and community leaders, this evaluation form can monitor the turn of events such as the impact of increasing or decreasing participants, the possible sources of funds, and the number of health professionals required. 3. Impact Evaluation (Form 2) As mentioned early, the health promotion programme in China only experience impact evaluation once a year. The last impact evaluation revealed that from 14% in 1986 the use of fluoridated toothpaste increased by almost 42% in 1996 or over a 10 year period. Similarly, brushing also increased by 20% over the same period of time while mean dental caries decreased by 0.54 in 2005 (ACFF, 2011). Impact evaluation is therefore very useful in finding the outcome of a particular programme. However, this kind of impact evaluation is somewhat short of its supposed function particularly in determining resources used and compliance with the agreed plan. For example, although there has been an increased in brushing habit, is 20% good enough for 10 long years of implementation? Is the resources used during this period proportionate to this percentage? If the right impact evaluation is to be implemented, the report should contain solid evidence how the resources are allocated, a comparison between the target outcome and the present one, a list of unintended and intended outcome , the variation in the implementation and its impact on the current outcome, and so on. Impact evaluation can help identify flaws in programme components as well as best practices that must be maintained. For example, using an objective-based approach to impact evaluation may reveal issues involving stakeholders such as reasons for decreasing volunteers, funding, and so on. A need-based approach may yield some important information about specific needs of a group or community such the relevance of the programme to a particular population or services being delivered beyond a particular community needs. The claim that Love Teeth Day is an effective oral health promotion on a national scale (ACFF, 2011) is misleading since the impact evaluation is inadequate. Note that this programme never experience monitoring evaluation that can assist in the determination of the programmes real outcome or reasons why the programme only yield such small percentage despite funding, large-scale participation, and years of implementation. An impact evaluation if ever implemented in this programme in the following years should be based on realistic evaluation where the logic of the programme will be investigated, comparison will be made between the planned and current outcome, and identify which components are working and to what population it should be applied. More importantly, the impact evaluation should consider balancing the amount of resources used for a certain period against the programme outcome. 4. Analysis and Conclusion The primary issue that must be considered in this nationwide health promotion programme is the ability of a particular evaluator to cover and evaluate such large and ever expanding programme. For example, since this programme from its conception in 1980s to present day was never monitored, conducting a comprehensive impact evaluation will be an exercise in futility due to the scarcity of information to prove or justify the outcome. It lacks the evaluation process (monitoring) that can feed and signal issues that must be addressed by impact evaluation (United Nations, 2009). Moreover, previous impact evaluation results are not reliable. In fact, there is evidence to prove that the national oral care committee was not bothered by the low percentage of health outcomes. The mere fact that the programme is continuously being carried out despite obvious shortcomings is evidence of evaluators’ lack of adequate knowledge about the real purpose of impact evaluation. For example, given that the programme is indeed successful in changing the attitude and beliefs of the population, the time it takes and the resources used to influence these changes also matters. It is never enough to claim that changes had occurred or the percentage of those affected increased since they are more in evaluation than just measuring outcomes. According to Owen (2006), an impact evaluation should be realistic and its findings should come from a comprehensive inquiry such as knowing the context in which the programme is implemented, processes or mechanisms that enable delivery of services and achievement of a certain outcome. It should be methodological and objective in verifying and evaluating evidence, and measure the benefits against the cost (p.260-264). Another important issue is the complexity of the health promotion itself. Note that this health promotion aside from being nationwide and ambitious, it uses different forms of promotion such as health educational materials, TV and radio advertising, newspaper ad, special promotion in large-scale public events, and collaborative effort with schools, professionals, community leaders, government and non-government entities, and even shopping malls. The point is that with this complex health promotion an evaluator will never know which one of these promotional activities is working and actually affect the outcome of the programme. For example, it may be easy to measure the impact of promotions done in school with health educational materials since an evaluator can monitor and evaluate the impact in that particular school or class. In contrast, the only way an evaluator can measure the real impact of TV, radio, and newspaper advertising is to conduct a nationwide survey which is costly and time consuming. Note that the evaluator must separate those that are affected by TV from those who got the information from radio as well as determining the level of changes between them. Another associated issue are the funds coming from different sources. Identifying which fund goes to what services is a complex and difficult task considering that there are thousands of entities providing their support to the programme. To determine activities that should be allocated with the appropriate funds is another problem since each contributor has a particular interest. For example, a toothpaste company trying to promote its product through social responsibility programme may not be willing to allocate its funds to the construction of small health facility in one remote and thinly populated rural community. Moreover, if key performance indicators were not well defined and resources for collecting and recording information are limited, the task will be more difficult (Khandker et al 2010, p.13). 5. References ACFF, (2011), Health Promotion: Love Teeth Day, Alliance for a Cavity-Free Future, School of Stomatology, Fourth Military Medical University, Shaanxi, China Khandker S., Koowal G, & Samad H, (2010), Handbook on Impact Evaluation: Quantitative Methods and Practices, World Bank Publications, United States Owen J, (2006), Program Evaluation: Forms and Approaches, Allen & Unwin, United States United Nations, (2009), Planning Sustainable Cities: Global Report on Human Settlements, United Nation, Geneva Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Health Promotion Campaign in China Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Health Promotion Campaign in China Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/2059228-evaluation-forms-and-their-application
(Health Promotion Campaign in China Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Health Promotion Campaign in China Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/2059228-evaluation-forms-and-their-application.
“Health Promotion Campaign in China Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/2059228-evaluation-forms-and-their-application.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Health Promotion Campaign in China

Promotional Campaign Olympenergy the energy drink

The campaign for plan to leverage the maximum promotional benefits is presented below.... The health and energy drinks sector is the most promising, profitable and growing segment in the UK (Reuters, 2008).... London 2012 Olympics is expected to bring about phenomenal changes and overall development for London....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Proposal

Health Promotion in the US via Health Programs and Campaigns

The intention of the present essay "health promotion in the US via Health Programs and Campaigns" is to evaluate the effectiveness of a few particular models of health promotion.... There are other connected programs like Healthy Border 2010 with their priority task of distributing health promotion cards.... Because of the mass media's endless appetite for new subjects to report, and because of the increasing public interest in health and fitness topics, the media are not just a passive vehicle for health promotion," (Backer, 1992, p....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Health Services for Young Adults

The paper "health Services for Young Adults" analyses the prospects and potentials of implementing a health service program in the Brisbane campus of the Griffith University.... The paper aims at providing a feasible marketing proposal for the health services offered at the university campus.... The two-dimensional perceptual map considered in this regard showed the consumer perception of available health services according to the quality and prices offered....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Marketing Communications Plan for Wanglaoji Herbal Tea

Even though Wanglaoji Herbal Tea is gaining popularity among health drinkers, the current market is still low compared to normal tea makers.... As a result of increasing awareness among consumers regarding the health benefits and negative effects of excessive caffeine or tea, more established tea and coffee brands are entering into the herbal tea market, intensifying competition for Wanglaoji (Armstrong and Kotler, 2012)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

A Major Health Problem in British Society and Improving Medical Service

The gradual shift was witnessed in British society which was reflected by the increasing concern of the policy makers towards promoting the health of the citizens.... In this regard, numerous policies were set towards ensuring the community engagement and promoting good health of the people within the country.... The healthcare professionals, government and non-government bodies, and healthcare institutions have a huge role and responsibilities to implement health policy among British society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Advertising and PR Campaign Used by Emporio Armani

In the paper 'Advertising and PR campaign Used by Emporio Armani,' the company under consideration is Emporio Armani.... The company has allocated its resources among different elements of promotion.... Sales promotion is an activity that intends to increase direct sales of a product or service.... Unlike other methods of promotion, sales promotion is all about action.... Emporio Armani employs different kinds of sales promotion to boost its wine accessories of clothing....
15 Pages (3750 words) Case Study

Marketing Strategy and Marketing Campaign of Alps Blue

Thus, it can be said that the water bottle brands present in china are not only focusing on distribution but also offering a unique variety of packaged water for higher brand value.... The organization has decided to launch new bottled water in the market of china.... Looking at the above opportunities, the organization has decided to launch new bottled water in the market of china.... china has been chosen as the country for launching the mineral water bottle because of several reasons....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report

Public Relations Campaign Proposal

The main weakness of the company in Australia is poor brand recognition mostly because a Chinese company makes the products in china.... This research proposal "Public Relations campaign Proposal" discusses Oppo, a Chinese firm will try to develop a PR campaign targeting potential Australian consumers with the objectives of changing their negative attitude towards Chinese technology.... Most importantly, the number of handsets sold would be the main benchmark on which the performance of the campaign would be based....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Proposal
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us