StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The United Food and Commercial Workers Union v. SORTA Appeal Case - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The United Food and Commercial Workers Union v. SORTA  Appeal Case" discusses that Case number 97-4126, United Food & Commercials Workers Union (UFCWU), et al, Plaintiff-Appellees, vs. Southwest Ohio Regional Transit Authority (SORTA), Defendant, Appellant, was argued from June 15 1998…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
The United Food and Commercial Workers Union v. SORTA Appeal Case
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The United Food and Commercial Workers Union v. SORTA Appeal Case"

United Food & Commercial Workers Union Case number 97-4126, United Food & Commercials Workers Union (UFCWU), et al, Plaintiff-Apellees, vs. Southwest Ohio Regional Transit Authority (SORTA), Defendant, Appellant, was argued from June 15 1998 and decided on December 10 1998. The defendant, SORTA, which is a state agency, had appealed against a district court’s ruling that granted UFCWU preliminary injunctive relief whereby the defendant was required to accept a proposed bus advertisement. In the case’s prior history, pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 1983 and on grounds of First Amendment, UFCWU challenged SORTA’s decision to reject the planned wrap-around advertisement, which they (SORTA) termed as aesthetically unpleasant and too controversial. Among SORTA’s commercial ventures is the sale of advertising space on the buses and bus shelters it owns. However, UFCWU’s proposed wrap-up advertisement, which portrayed protesting union workers fleeing from the police and boarding a bus belonging to SORTA was rejected. In its ruling, the district court concluded that UFCWU was favored by the balance of equities and, therefore, granted the preliminary injunctive relief (Moore 1). Case number 07-2105, Rita Miller, Plaintiff, vs. Clinton County; Honorable Richard Saxton, Appellant, was argued from May 13 2008 and decided on October 1 2008. The civil rights action was brought against Richard Saxton, the Court of Common Pleas’ President Judge, by Clinton County’s former probation officer, Rita Miller. It was asserted by Rita Miller that Richard Saxton violated her right to free speech (First Amendment) and right to due process (Fourteenth Amendment) by firing her after she wrote him a complaint letter claiming hostility and intimidation from her supervisor. Miller appealed against Saxton’s decision to fire her, and a district court permitted the wrongful termination case to proceed. However, the case was dismissed by a federal appeals court, effectively reversing the ruling made by the district judge. Miller had alleged that her supervisor had acted unprofessionally by stating the probationers were a scum and did not merit the money spent on them by the probation office. In his move to dismiss the claims, Saxton wanted to be granted a summary judgment motion and alleged to be immune to suit. In the UFCWU v. SORTA appeal case, the court stated that a preliminary injunction aims to avert irreparable injury and uphold a court’s capacity to deliver significant decisions based on merit in reference to Canal Authority of State of Florida v. Callaway, 489 F.2d 567, 576 (5th Cir.1974). The district court ought to have considered the four factors of preliminary injunction which would determine whether it was likely for UFCWU to succeed basing on the merits; whether they would otherwise incur irreparable injury; whether the granting of preliminary injunction would serve public interest; and whether others would be put under harm by the granting of preliminary injunction (Moore 1). UFCWU tabled a number of grounds that showed its likelihood to succeed on merit of the claims that its First Amendment rights were violated by SORTA. This included their argument that the outside space on the buses owned by SORTA are designated public forums and SORTA failed the scrutiny of standards applicable to denial of protected speech based on content in a public forum. In contrast, in the Miller vs. Clinton County case, the federal appeals court determined that although Miller’s letter partially touched on matters considered to be public concern, it appeared in a context that established her speech was not protected. Effectively, her letter was based on personal grievances in her capacity as an employee under the supervision of Mrs. Foresman. It was, therefore, on this ground of unprotected speech that the appeals court ruled that she could not build a First Amendment reprisal claim. In the reversal of the district court’s ruling, the appeals court further concluded that the district judge erred by failing to dismiss Miller’s complaint of violated due process. This is because, the court ruled, the arrangement of collective bargaining that Miller had relied on did not make her more than a willing employee as concerns the law of Pennsylvania, therefore, no due process was violated. Pennsylvania’s law on collective bargaining limits matters between local governments and public employees to conditions and terms of employment, hours and wages as referenced by Stumpp vs. Stroudsburg Mun. Auth., 540 Pa. 391, 658 A.2d 333, 335 (1995) Further, Miller’s case was dismissed largely because of the personal context she painted by criticizing her seniors and giving Saxton an ultimatum that she cannot go back to her employment so long as Mrs. Foresman remains her supervisor. Referring to Connick vs. Myers, 461 U.S. 138, 140, 103 S.Ct. 1684, 75 L.Ed.2d 708 (1983), the personal context minimizes the force of any public concern that could favor her First Amendment claims, while it adds more weight to Saxton’s allegations that her speech was not protected. She could, therefore, not meet the four factors of injunction and there was no likelihood of her succeeding. In comparison, although both Miller and SORTA had the same grounds to present their appeals, they failed due to different technicalities. It can be seen that SORTA improperly argued that the granting of the preliminary injunction was wider than necessary to achieve the sought results. However, the court found that UFCWU had sufficiently established likelihood to succeed on its claim’s merit that its First Amendment rights were violated by SORTA’s hindrance of access to advertising space. It also established that UFCWU had shown it would suffer irreparable harm if the denial of access to the advertising space was continued by SORTA (Moore 1). This rules out SORTA’s argument of the injunction being wider than necessary. With reference to International Union, UAW vs. Yard-Man, Inc., 716 F.2d 1476, 1484 n. 11 (6th Cir.1983), the substance of argument challenged SORTA’s policy guidelines that were found to be vague and unconstitutionally broad in the way they allowed officials to decline proposed advertisements because of the expressed viewpoints. In contrast, Miller failed to illustrate that the statements she included in her letter touching on public concern could be viewed in any context other than personal and could, therefore, not uphold her claims to property interests in her employment. It can be concluded that both cases had elements of violation of right to due process and free speech, but the contrast in judgment correctly arises from the contexts in which they are argued. Works Cited Moore, J. United Food Commercial Workers Union Local 1099 v. Southwest Ohio Regional Transit Authority, . 2013. Web. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“United Food & Commercial Workers Union, Local 1099 v. Southwest Ohio Essay”, n.d.)
United Food & Commercial Workers Union, Local 1099 v. Southwest Ohio Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1623007-united-food-commercial-workers-union-local-1099-v-southwest-ohio-regional-transit-authority-163-f3d-341-rita-miller-v-clinton-county-544-f3d-542
(United Food & Commercial Workers Union, Local 1099 V. Southwest Ohio Essay)
United Food & Commercial Workers Union, Local 1099 V. Southwest Ohio Essay. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1623007-united-food-commercial-workers-union-local-1099-v-southwest-ohio-regional-transit-authority-163-f3d-341-rita-miller-v-clinton-county-544-f3d-542.
“United Food & Commercial Workers Union, Local 1099 V. Southwest Ohio Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1623007-united-food-commercial-workers-union-local-1099-v-southwest-ohio-regional-transit-authority-163-f3d-341-rita-miller-v-clinton-county-544-f3d-542.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The United Food and Commercial Workers Union v. SORTA Appeal Case

American and the EU Competition Law

In the US under mentioned sanctions may be imposed on violation of competition law a) confiscation of property b) suspension of right for a period of one year c) fine up to the extent of one million USD and above in case of corporation d) for others fine up to 0.... The court of appeal hears appeal received from trial court of respective jurisdiction to decide the case.... Bankruptcy case deals by the court of Bankruptcy court since the creditors are not in a position to pay more after liquidating their assets....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Impact of Environmental Laws on Property Management in the UK

This study will relate principally to environmental policies pertaining to property ownership in the United Kingdom, specifically the rules and regulations in regards to legal compliance with environmental laws relevant to both residential and commercial property owners.... The impact of environmental laws on property management in the UK Abstract An overview of European Union environmental policy is given with special emphasis on property rights within the united Kingdom....
70 Pages (17500 words) Dissertation

The Truth about Globalization

This paper ''The Truth about Globalization'' tells that To keep my economist union card, author is required every morning when he arises to place his hand on the leather-bound family heirloom copy of Adam Smith's the Wealth of Nations and swears a mighty oath of allegiance to globalization....
64 Pages (16000 words) Essay

The Prevalence of Creative Accounting in the Corporate World

.... ithout moving away from laws or accounting requirements, allowing to the managers to change the financial result or the financial statements.... ?? (Balaciu & Pop p.... 936).... There are four ways in which.... ... ... The first way is when there are alternative accounting policies, and managers can make a choice among these policies....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Challenges in the Third Sector

In the paper 'Challenges in the Third Sector' the author analyzes the term third sector, which has currently been substituted in Government practice by the name 'Civil Society' or more frequently the phrase 'Big Society', which was invented by political consultants.... ... ... ... The author of the paper states that the third sector became the leading sector in society, as the well-informed class prevails over the effects of the private sector....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Impact of the Cold War and New Scrambles for Africa

The author of the following assignment claims that The Catholic Church is credited with numerous developments from the Renaissance to present.... During the Renaissance period, European missionaries, as well as explorers, took the mission to spread Catholicism across the world.... ... ... ... The colonialists were awarded the rights to control the appointments of clerics in these newly discovered regions....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

International Business: Davos 2010 and Labor

Child labor is a case in point.... Besides the labor exploitation in poorer economies, there is also the rise of the gap between the wages of skilled and non-skilled workers.... With the increase in globalization and the role that technology plays, there is now a pervasive shift in demand for labor that has favored skilled workers at the expense of the unskilled sector and that, according to von Brau and Mengistu (2007), this may translate into increased poverty or at least increased inequality....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Arguments against and for Reframing Labor Rights as Human Rights

The author also describes a strategy he/she advocates around labor rights as human rights and examines the implications of New Zealand minority unionism model for workers and unions.... The author describes the arguments for and against reframing labor rights as human rights.... ....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us