StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Foreign Countries - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Foreign Countries.
Rendering and interrogation are practices used as a counterterrorism tool which has become integral to American Intelligence in their effort to gather information related to terrorism attacks…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.1% of users find it useful
U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Foreign Countries
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Foreign Countries"

U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Foreign Countries U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Foreign Countries Rendering and interrogation are practices used as a counterterrorism tool which has become integral to American Intelligence in their effort to gather information related to terrorism attacks. Nevertheless, there has been insignificant publicity concerning the nature of the frequency of the U.S practice of rendering and interrogations.

The press has made reports indicating cases where more than one hundred terrorism suspects have been captured by the United States since the occurrence of 9/11 in countries like Egypt, Morocco, Pakistan, Uzbekistan, etc. Some suspects have been held in the United States for interrogation, and others are sent to the countries cited by U.S. State Department for human-right violation, including torture. However, there are human rights activist prominent U.S. allies who are against the Rendering and Interrogation.

Therefore, the paper will focus on developing relevant arguments to discuss issues related to U.S practice of rendering and interrogating terrorist suspects in foreign countries. There are reports that have been filed by various detainees concerning abuse whereby they criticize the government for failing to ensure that terrorism suspects are not interrogated in the hands of tortures. Moreover, the legal authority of the U.S. agencies to carry out rendering and interrogation has remained unclear.

On the other hand, the U.S. is a signatory to the UN’s Geneva Convention against Torture, which prohibits cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment of prisoners. Washington has determined that despite the directives issued by former President Bush in February 2002, the Geneva Conventions are not applying concerning the treatment of the detainees. Moreover, Washington has determined that Geneva Conventions are not applying on war terrorism though there was a draft memo by Justice Department which authorized the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) to render terrorism suspects out of Iraq to foreign countries for interrogation.

Therefore, the Central Intelligence Agency was offered authority to act autonomously through classified presidential directives signed after 9/11. The controversy related to the practice of rendering and interrogating terrorist suspects led to a significant discomfort in Europe due to Bush administration approach aimed at countering terrorism. In fact, the experts have raised issues related to clandestine prison and secret flight stem from broader issues affecting transatlantic relation. Moreover, Europe has been relentless with unwillingness of Washington to offer the due process to terror suspects whereby they are expected to assure suspects that their human rights will not be violated in the process of abusive interrogation.

In addition, experts claim that the due process is alleged to apply torture thus creating a contradiction with European norms on human rights. The allegations torture in U.S. practice of rendering and interrogating has been putting significant pressure on the European government. This made the EU Justice and Home Affairs Commissioner Franco Frattini issue a warning which states that any member of EU found guilty due to involvement in CIA’s practices of interrogation would lose the voting rights.

Nevertheless, this threat has been dismissed since there are secrets involved in violation of European Convention of Human Rights. On the other hand, the European human right groups and other parties are seeking assurance for the government that officials will not be involved in secret the U.S. practice of rendering and interrogating. Therefore, the media and other foreign countries are seeking opportunities to criticize the government; in fact, there are prison reports opposing the American practice of rendering and interrogating.

In this case, the issues concerning the U.S. operations in Europe contributed to significant fears concerning the Bush administration. The opponents of the allegations against the United States have remained speculative whereby there are experts claiming that Europe has been supportive, but the population has been opposed by the American actions. In fact, these practices have been contributing significantly to the process of sharing intelligence since the attacks on 9/11. Therefore, despite the political discord concerning the unpopular war in Iraq, there are substantial political hindrances in the future operations of collaborative intelligence.

In addition, the nature and frequency of the U.S. practice of rendering and interrogating has insignificant publicity though there are some of the politicized cases, such as Lebanese national Khaled el-Masri, and a German citizen who made allegations of being pick up by Macedonian authorities and handed over to the U.S. officials in Afghanistan (Crane, 2005). In conclusion, U.S.A officials accepted the mistake of wrongfully detaining the German for five months, and this led to an investigation by prosecutors about the involvement of a former German interior minister Otto Schily.

Moreover, the fallout in Italian politics, Sweden and Germany has increased difficulty in cooperation of the counties in counterterrorism operations with the U.S. intelligence. However, the extent of the drawback on intelligence and law enforcement front have been making the parties more reluctant to share information.   References Crane, M. (2005, Dec. 6). U.S. Treatment of Terror Suspects and U.S.-EU Relations. Council on Foreign Relations. Retrieved from http://www.cfr.org/terrorism-and-the-law/us-treatment-terror-suspects-us-eu-relations/p9350

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1459793-us-practice-of-rendering-and-interrogating-terrorist-suspects-in-foreign-countries
(U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1459793-us-practice-of-rendering-and-interrogating-terrorist-suspects-in-foreign-countries.
“U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1459793-us-practice-of-rendering-and-interrogating-terrorist-suspects-in-foreign-countries.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF U.S. Practice of Rendering and Interrogating Terrorist Suspects in Foreign Countries

International Obligations and Responsibilities of Governments

The act involves arrest of a suspect from a foreign soil after which one is transported to a foreign detention facility without observing the available legal channels.... In most cases, the suspects are tried by foreign governments and sometimes executed.... Human Rights Law Extra ordinary rendition refers to apprehension of suspects for extrajudicial transfer from one state to another.... hellip; The arrest is conducted without the knowledge of the suspects' family or the individual himself....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Post 9/11 Government Involvement and Constitutional Liberties have changed

The new act was to change the existing laws such as the foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978.... Until this new law, the law enforcement officer needed to inform the cause that the suspect was an agent sitting somewhere in far off country; however, the new act allowed tapping to collect evidence for a criminal involvement of the suspect without having a cause of a foreign intelligence.... Post 9/11, the Bush government pledged to identify and grab the terrorist groups on the US land....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

How effective is terrorism legislation with regards to restraining terrorists

Totalitarian countries tend to be remarkably free of terrorism because a police state does not allow such groups to even begin to form.... If the choice is between living in a police state free of terrorism and living in a free society in which terrorism may occur, the vast majority of the British people (as in all free countries) will choose the latter.... The terrorist is portrayed as a kind of distillation of all that is evil in human beings....
31 Pages (7750 words) Dissertation

The Moral Issues Of War On Terrorism

Democracy with civil liberties at its core is the pride of Western societies, particularly the USA.... The paper "The Moral Issues Of War On Terrorism" discusses terrorism as a new form of global terror and tighter security measures in the name of national security.... hellip; More than that, there was a dramatic increase in incidences showing anti-terror laws' promote racism, especially against Blacks and Asians....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Counterterrorism Tracking Terrorist Assets

The freezing of terrorist's assets involves blocking all property and interests belonging to persons committing or posing a significant threat to citizens, national security, foreign policy, or economy.... ounterterrorism efforts of tracking assets are directed at thwarting an individual, group, or state providing material support or resources to both domestic, as well as foreign terrorist organizations (Brzoska, 2011).... "Counterterrorism Tracking terrorist Assets" paper states that effective execution of policies directed at tracking terrorist assets demands cooperation between all parties....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Should Guantanamo Bay Be Shut Down or Not

The paper “Should Guantanamo Bay Be Shut Down or Not?... rdquo; describes a few points of view about the place adopted for the detention of prisoners of war.... Someones suggest that Guantanamo Bay has tarnished the US image, diminished its ideals, and its establishment was unforgivable policy, to begin with....
18 Pages (4500 words) Research Paper

Countering Terrorism: Examining the Tactics of Rendition and Extraordinary Rendition of the US

It also examines the use of rendition by the USA in trying to combating terrorism in conjunction with other foreign countries.... It analyses the pressing need of the USA and other countries in dealing with the growing threats and attacks of terrorism.... Although statistics might indicate that there has been a reduction in terrorist incidents, there is still a pressing need for countries to combat international as well as domestic terrorism and wage a war against global terrorism....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Torture of Suspected Terrorists

The author of the paper titled "The Torture of Suspected Terrorists" discusses whether torture of suspected terrorists is justified or not in the context of anti-terrorism laws framed in western countries after the September 11, 2001 terror attacks.... Various anti-terrorism laws were passed in several countries.... Other western countries, particularly the United Kingdom and Australia, followed suit and passed rigid anti-terrorism laws as well....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us