StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States" focuses on the iconic case of the 1983 Motor Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association versus State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company and the issue of Modified Standard 208 by the ordinance of NHTSA…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States"

The facts in question in the iconic case of the 1983 Motor Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association versus State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company are, briefly, as follows. The issue of Modified Standard 208 by the ordinance of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) made the incorporation of passive restraints such as airbags and passive seatbelts mandatory in all automobiles manufactured after September 1982 to ensure better public as well as occupant safety. However, before this new regulation could come into effect, a new Secretary of Transportation assumed office and the implementation of the Standard was delayed for one year. NHTSA, then, called a public hearing after reopening the rulemaking process, where forth the Modified Standard 208 was retracted. Their claim stated that the utilitarian values of airbags and passive seatbelts are no longer justifiable in automobile security given, questioning the benefits of passive restraints. However, this withdrawal of the rule indicated that the decision was not a result of the proven ineffectiveness of passive restraints but rather one based on the interests of large automobile companies. As was duly shown, a staggering 99% of the motor vehicle industry was at that time incorporating automatic seatbelts into their models that could be easily detached. Motor Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association (MVMA) of the United States demanded a court review of the rulemaking on parameters less ‘arbitrary and capricious. The petitioners were represented by Solicitor Rex E. Lee (U.S Department of Transportation) and Mr. Lloyd N. Cutler (MVMA) while James F. Fitzpatrick spoke on the behalf of the respondents.

 

Brief Assessment

 

Solicitor Lee’s opening statement gave a comprehensive account of the facts in question regarding the case as well as a general assessment of the motivating factors behind Secretary Coleman’s and his successor Secretary Adam’s attitudes towards Standard 208.

He petitioned, on the behalf of State Farm Mutual, who requested a review of the agency’s decision to retract Standard 208. In his turn, Mr. Cutler presented his argument with gusto, clarity backed by relevant statistics and figures to show that the public reception of passive restraints was not only negative but that detachable seatbelt, in cases of accidents, was safer for the occupant. I find both sides were convincing and clear enough in presenting their points. The questions by the judges were crucial, and to some extent, indicated a slight incredulity towards the justification of the repealing of the restrictive regulation stipulated under Standard 208.

The court was to review and issue a ruling based on whether “facts found and the choices made” were relational or truly “arbitrary and capricious”. The court ruled the facts directing the previous rescinding to be insufficient and inconclusive in indicating that passive restraints were not preventive of accidents. I believe, to an extent, the agency’s decision to rescind the Standard may have been a result of bureaucratic politics, a natural consequence of the change of power as the new Secretary of Transportation assumed office. However, it is indubitable that the court could find no “direct evidence” to justify the retraction of Standard 208 and was unbiased in its ruling.

 

Impact and Significance

 

The historical Marbury vs. Madison case of 1803 initiated a momentous change in the US legal system by establishing the ground for judicial review in assessing the constitutional applicability and integrity of legislations. The ideological and constitutional effect of the Marbury vs. Madison case has been enduring. The key importance of the MVMA versus State Farm Mutual Insurance Company lies in the fact that this case throws into sharp relief the pitfalls as well as the effectiveness of the judicial review system. It is also significant in its relational position with several other similar cases.

From the early 1930s, the interrelated socio-economic and technical aspects and market impacts of governmental regulation and judicial reviews have been much studied and analyzed (Breyer 363). The MVMA vs. State Farm Mutual is a vital case in point. Related instances of contested judicial reviews and motor safety regulations are Chevron U.S.A Inc vs. Natural Resources Defense Council Inc. of 1984, and Patricia M. Wood et al. vs. General Motors Corporation of 1989 respectively.

My primary focus must be on the crux of the conflict. The original judicial review that rescinded the restrictive regulation Standard 208 drew jurisdiction from the NHTSA act of 1966. It is a vitally important act in the justice system of the USA. It marks the confluence of two distinct movements – the political movement for the reform of federal administrative regulations and the reshaping of automobile safety regulations. (Marshaw and Harfst 257) It created a nationwide pro-active regulative effort to ensure public transportation safety. The impact of the stated arbitrariness and capriciousness, as revealed in the rescission of standard 208, shows the implicit loopholes in the regulatory practices of the government.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States vs. State Essay”, n.d.)
Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States vs. State Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1489507-motor-vehicle-manufacturers-association-of-united-states-vs-state-farm-mutual-automobile-insurance-company
(Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States Vs. State Essay)
Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States Vs. State Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1489507-motor-vehicle-manufacturers-association-of-united-states-vs-state-farm-mutual-automobile-insurance-company.
“Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States Vs. State Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1489507-motor-vehicle-manufacturers-association-of-united-states-vs-state-farm-mutual-automobile-insurance-company.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Motor Vehicle Manufacturers Association of United States

Marketing Strategy of Hyundai Motor in America

The company has a marked presence in the states of Alabama, Michigan and California, which house our manufacturing facility, engineering facility, proving grounds and design and research center respectively (Hyundai Motors, 2011).... Hyundai's association with USA goes deeper than just selling cars in the country.... It is currently among the top four foreign car manufacturers in the country.... However, the company is also threatened by the rapid progress of global rival Suzuki Motors as well as upcoming names such as Tata Motors and Fiat who are looking to gain a strong foothold in the US market after faring well in the Asian and European markets in identical vehicle segments....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Non-Tariff Barriers in South Korean Automobile Market

Recent South Korea-united states FTA (KORUS FTA) renegotiations concerning an automobile industry trade issue can be regarded as a result of aggressive regionalism which represents a series of age-old bilateral trade conflicts and difficulties of solving the problem in a whole scale manner between the two long-time allies.... The essay "Non-Tariff Barriers in South Korean Automobile Market" examines the updated trade patterns and determinant of complete passenger and road vehicle trade between the U....
36 Pages (9000 words) Essay

Financial Analysis of Tesla Motors

The company headquarters is located at Palo Alto, California, in the united states.... The Tesla Motors, Inc is presently listed in the National association of Securities Dealers Automated Quotations.... The company specializes in the design, manufacture, and sale of electric cars and electric vehicle power train components.... This present research paper is based on a scenario whereby there are two possible options that an investor can exploit: of which it is either to invest in Tesla Motors, Inc or Ford motor Company....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

South Korean Automobile Market - Non-Tariff Barriers

Recent South Korea-united states FTA (KORUS FTA) renegotiations concerning an automobile industry trade issue can be regarded as a result of aggressive regionalism which represents a series of age-old bilateral trade conflicts and difficulties of solving the problem in a whole scale manner between the two long-time allies.... The essay "South Korean Automobile Market-Non-Tariff Barriers" examines the updated trade patterns and determinant of complete passenger and road vehicle trade between the U....
36 Pages (9000 words) Essay

The Aspects of International Marketing Affected TATA Motors Cars in the United States Market

rom the perspective of American Marketing association (AMA), international marketing is the global practice of planning and manipulating the inherent strategies of an organization along with the pricing strategies, strategies of promotion and allocation of products, services or ideas that satisfy the consumers along with the organization goals (Onkvisit & Shaw, 'International Marketing: Analysis and Strategy')....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

The US Automotive Industry

In addition to manufacturing plants, several manufacturers have opened transmission and engine plants that are working in research and development, design, and testing in the united states.... percent Gross Domestic Products (GDP) of the united states.... uring 1900 and 1930, Detroit experienced record growth in comparison to any other city in the united states.... According to the study conducted by Motor & Equipment manufacturers association and Information Handling Services, overall automobile industry's direct employment generation was 3....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Why the American Automobile Companies are not Successful in Thailand

The author explains how have the American Automobile manufacturers been able to tap into the Thailand Automobile industry, and has this tapping in being successful .... This dissertation is aimed at reviewing a background of the Thailand Automobile industry and its giants.... ... ...
20 Pages (5000 words) Dissertation

Environmental Impacts Associated with the Production and Consumption of Motor Vehicles

According to the International Organization of motor vehicle manufacturers, the past few years have witnessed a steady increase in global vehicle manufacturing (OICA, 2016a).... The conference defined the rights of individuals to have a healthy and productive environment, sound housing, safe water, and adequate food (united Nations Conference on Sustainable Development 2011).... The UN adopted measures such as the World Charter for Nature and the World Commission on Environment and Development to introduce changes related to economic, social, environmental, and cultural issues (united Nations Conference on Sustainable Development 2011)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us