StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The current extended interpretation of the Commerce Clause - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
How, for example, is commerce to be defined? What constitutes commerce among the several states? What are the proper functions and powers of the respective state and federal governments under the commerce…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful
The current extended interpretation of the Commerce Clause
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The current extended interpretation of the Commerce Clause"

Interpretations of the Commerce Clause Interpretations of the Commerce Clause The Commerce Clause raises several interpretive and normative questions. How, for example, is commerce to be defined? What constitutes commerce among the several states? What are the proper functions and powers of the respective state and federal governments under the commerce clause? What weight should original intent, current values or modern conditions of trade have in construing the commerce clause?During the constituting era, the implication of a word in any legal document was postulated to be its ordinary, conventional meaning (Branch, 1753; Natelson & Kopel , 2011).

There is little doubt that the conventional and accepted common meaning of commerce both in common discourse as well as in legal language, was mercantile trade and the additionally associated activities (Natelson & Kopel, 2011).There are at least four possible interpretations which have been proposed in interpretation of the Commercial Clause (Scheb & Stephens, 2007, pg. 100). First it has been advocated that the clause bestows upon the Congress the absolute power to control commerce. Under this construal, states are deprived off power to check interstate commerce.

Secondly, it has been interprated that theclause gives Congress and the states contemporaneous powers to regulate commerce. Under this interpretation, state regulation of commerce is unenforceable only in cases where it is pre-empted by federal laws (Exploring Constitutional Conflicts, 2011).Third, the Commerce Clause has been interpreted to imply that both the congress and the states each have their own mutually exclusive zones of regulatory power. Under this construal, it becomes the responsibility of the judicial system to determine whether one sovereign has invaded the exclusive regulatory zone of the other.

The last interpretation that has been advanced is that the clause by its own force dissociates states the power to regulate commerce in certain ways, but both the Congress and States retain coexisting power to control commerce in many other respects. This forth interpretation, is a complicated and convoluted hybrid of two others, and it is the approach employed by the courts in their decision while interpreting the commerce clause.According to Marshall (Kommers, Finn, & Jacobsohn, 2004, pg. 301), as long as any aspect of commerce implicated or involved more than one state, such as transportation or the exchange of commodities across state lines, congress may regulate it.

The power to regulate, however, is equally broad. He added, this power, like all others vested in congress is complete in itself, may be execised to its utmost extent and acknowledges no limitations, other than are prescribed in the constitution.. Marshall stated that the national government was limited to some specified objects, but the power to regulate those obljects – interstste commerce being one of them- was vested in congress as absolutely as it would be in a single unitary government.

Whereas commerce among the states is clearly subject to congressional legislation, commerce within the states is subject to state regulation. Justice Willium Johnson, posited Congress’s exclusive authority over commerce and denied any significant difference in commerce among and within the states. This power in his words, “can reside but in one potentate and hence the grant of this power carries with it the whole subject, leaving nothing for the sttae to act upon (Kommers, Finn, & Jacobsohn, 2004, pg. 302). Having stated the various interpretation of the Commerce Clause.

A more practical interpretation of this clause is that it should return to dual federalism that is implicit in the States’ rights account of the constitution. The Commerce Clause has for long been used as a weapon to limit the ability of the federal government to regulate the national economy ReferencesExploring Constitutional Conflicts. (2011, March 1). Commerce Clause Limitations on State Regulation. Retrieved November 17, 2011, from Exploring Constitutional Conflicts: http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/statecommerce.

htmKommers, D. P., Finn, J. E., & Jacobsohn, G. J. (2004). American constitutional law: Governmental powers and democracy (2, illustrated ed.). Rowman & Littlefield.Natelson, R. G., & Kopel , D. (2011). Commerce in the Commerce Clause: A Response to Jack Balkin. Retrieved November 17, 2011, from Michigan Law Review: http://www.michiganlawreview.org/articles/commerce-in-the-commerce-clause-a-response-to-jack-balkinScheb, J. M., & Stephens, O. H. (2007). American Constitutional Law: Sources Of Power And Restraint.

Cengage Learning.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The current extended interpretation of the Commerce Clause Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1584486-the-current-extended-interpretation-of-the-commerce-clause
(The Current Extended Interpretation of the Commerce Clause Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/law/1584486-the-current-extended-interpretation-of-the-commerce-clause.
“The Current Extended Interpretation of the Commerce Clause Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1584486-the-current-extended-interpretation-of-the-commerce-clause.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The current extended interpretation of the Commerce Clause

The Regulation of Commerce with the Indian Tribes

Between them there are regulating commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes, establishing an process of uniform rule of naturalization, and uniform laws on the subject of bankruptcies throughout the United States,establishing post-offices and post-roads, promoting the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries, defining and punishing piracies and felonies committed on the high seas, and offences against the law of nations. … The regulation of commerce with the Indian tribes, as distinguished from foreign nations, seems, in some degree, to be founded upon this principle, that those tribes which are not settled within the limits of any particular state, could only be regarded as tributary to the United States in their federal capacity; as to those who reside within the limits of particular states, it was thought necessary to unfetter them from two limitations in the articles of confederation which rendered the provision obscure, and perhaps contradictory....
22 Pages (5500 words) Essay

Fundamental Theories of Supply and Demand

nbsp; The fact is that Marshall's interpretation of demand and consumer surplus, or his reworking of either has led to a debate among economists.... arshall "translates" this "law of diminishing utility," following a behavioralist interpretation, in terms of price....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Extent Exclusion Clauses in Holiday Insurance Contracts

In the context of recent judgment in bankers insurance company V Patrick South and Ian Gardener, the efficiency of unfair contract terms act 1977, unfair terms in consumer contracts regulations act 1999 and other related acts as far as the accurate interpretation of exclusion clauses has to be discussed.... Exclusion clause may be defined as a clause which may be inserted into a contract which aims to exclude or limit one partys liability for breach of contract or negligence....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Product Safety and Product Liability

Whereas the Roman II Regulations were meant to issue directives on the harmonization of product liability laws, the harmonization has acted to impose unfavorable business environment.... This is because the regulations act one-sidedly to protect the consumer while disregarding the rights of the producers and the business fraternity....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Issue of Multiculturalism

The increased amount of exposure a child can receive in a small, confined and poorly ventilated Whether or not a law prohibiting smoking in cars containing minors could be passed in the US would ultimately depend on the law's constitutionality under the commerce clause of the US constitution.... the commerce clause allows congress “to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several states” and has long been an issue of political and social debate....
1 Pages (250 words) Scholarship Essay

New Federalism in USA

The congress could use the commerce clause in this instance to link this law to the interstate commerce.... Under the commerce clause, as stated the congress has the power to regulate all economic activities that involve the different states.... the commerce clause has brought in a lot of debate on the powers of the congress and whether the courts can limit the same powers.... This clause gives the congress broad powers over all the commercial interests of the nation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The Term Knowledge Worker in The Context of Todays Business World

The aim of the essay "The Term Knowledge Worker in The Context of Today's Business World" defines the nature of the knowledge worker in the business.... Furthermore, the essay would provide an investigation of the contributions of average knowledge worker effectively for the company.... hellip; A Knowledge Worker is a person who contributes to the work environment through his or knowledge as a multi-subject matter specialist....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Institute Cargo Clauses

This objective will be achieved by critically discussing literature pertaining to the interpretation of the clause and complementing this with information from related cases.... This literature review "The Institute Cargo Clauses" discusses the Institute Cargo Clauses, terms specifying the type of cargo covered by insurance policies, and elucidates that contrary to its claim, this clause does not actually cover all risks.... In its definitive opening, clause (A) asserts that it offers insurance to all risks of loss of or damage to the subject-matter insured except as excluded by the provisions of Clauses 4, 5, 6 and 7 (ICC, 2009; Soady, 2013)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us