StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Max Weber and Catholic Doctrine - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Max Weber and Catholic Doctrine " it is clear that generally, according to Marx, having a religion only manifests veering away from criticality and rational thinking based on its failed function to serve the general masses throughout history…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Max Weber and Catholic Doctrine
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Max Weber and Catholic Doctrine"

Max Weber Max Weber, the of numerous books about sociology of religion greatly focused on the role of religion in modern society since played a great function in historic and autonomous development of the modern economic ethic. Significantly, religion according to Weber constitutes modern process and features of power relations, social and political administration, socio-economic structures, social status and stratification, and others. For instance, Catholic doctrine as formulated by Aquinas differs from earliest Christianity and Stoicism in the viewpoint concerning equality of all human beings. This doctrine greatly influenced power relations in modern society metaphysically where human beings suffer either because of the original sin, individual causality of karma, or the corruption of the dualistic world. In which case, human beings suffer violence, strife, and differences in worldly social status and position. This in return created various and modern castes and stratifications "that have been providentially ordained, and each of them has been assigned some specific, indispensable task desired by god or determined by the impersonal world order, so that different ethical obligations devolve upon each." (Weber 1993). These castes were maintained because of the regard for divinely ordained authoritarian relationship which contributes to the kind of modern social and political administration we have today. This in accordance discourage or condemn any revolt or rebellion against the authority as it only means creaturely arrogance or pride against the sanctity of God-built social order. Meanwhile, submitting to the established organic organization and functioning based from the assigned task will give person happiness in the world and in the life to come. Meanwhile, Islamic doctrine holds no regard to salvation and thus the kind of 'rulership' rejected universalism that leaves the people to decide upon any indifference to the Islamic regulations. On the other hand, social castes present in Hinduism justify discrimination and outcasts since the doctrine chiefly depends on person's fulfillment of his cast function to achieve higher chances of higher status in the next life. This can be manifested to the doctrine's affirmation to social discrimination since it believes to the idea that people who were in the lowest castes and sacrificed much can gain more in any of transmigration of souls. As Weber pointed out, political power struggle evolved to order of legal sate because of its increasing objectification. However, he also pointed that political power struggle in religion's perspective "is merely the most effective camouflage of brutality, for all politics is oriented to the reason of state, the pragmatic and self-purposive sustenance of the external and internal distribution of power. These goals must necessarily seem completely meaningless from the religious point of view. Yet only in this way does the realm of politics acquire a peculiarly rational power of its own, once formulated by Napoleon, which appears as thoroughly alien to every ethic of brotherliness as do the rationalized economic orders." (Weber 1993). Also influential is the religious antipathy to sexual acts that can be seen in cultic chastity meaningfully developed in place of the various types of magical motivation. The doctrine believes that sexual abstinence is a fundamental factor to achieve salvation. This can be done through contemplative withdrawal from worldly pleasures. Moreover, sexual drive and other related pleasures constitute the most powerful temptation that will only strengthen the hold of 'animality' to human. This religious convention greatly regarded modern sexual act as irrational and are only brought about by animalistic tendencies of human. Acts to subjugate sexual acts legitimizes marriage as a regulatory process for sexual intercourse and used the idea of legitimate child rearing to impose action fiercely against prostitution and extra-marital affairs. Karl Marx According to Karl Marx, religion depends its existence upon "the material and economic realities in a given society." Just like other social institutions. As it has no independent history and is only collectivity of human productive forces, Marx argued that religion "is but the reflex of the real world." By relating religion to other social systems and economic structures of society, religion can be understood as very dependent to economics. He argued that religion and other religious doctrines are irrelevant since economics and other social institution mold the features and processes of religion in the given society. As he clearly pointed out as interpreting religion in a in functionalist point of view, "understanding religion is dependent upon what social purpose religion itself serves, not the content of its beliefs." That is, given that religion functions not independent to different social institutions, its role to society becomes dependent to the political, social and economic structure of the society the country whishes to be served. In Marx's opinion, religion is just an illusory institution that gives the society an excuse and reasons to keep its functions and role intact. As an analogy, he used capitalism to distinguish religion as the representation of the society's highest ideals. This creates alienation of human to their value same as alienating humans from their highest aspirations which is then portrayed onto an alien and unknowable being called a god. Marx believes that religion is irrational since it constitutes delusion and worship of a being that defies appearance and veers away from underlying reality and recognition. Moreover, religion discourages and counters human pursuit for full potential and leaves the people to render incapable, servile and consistently amenable to status quo or socio-political and economic structures. He believes that the humans' creation of God to be worshipped can only leave the society to a being who "do not recognize man's self-consciousness as the highest divinity." Additionally, the valuable attitude of unity promoted by religion becomes irrelevant since it consistently created a hypocritical principle and doctrine. For instance, the Christianity taught of Jesus as being servant of the people advocating valuable principles like helping the poor. However, this was defeated by the Christian church merged with the oppressive Roman state to enslave people for centuries. Also, the concept of Christians about the glory of heaven only gave them an outright possibility to acquire property and power during the Middle Ages. In addition, Lutherian encouraged the capability of every human to interpret the teachings of Bible but ironically sided with aristocrats and encouraged the abuse and oppression of people and defies social and economic equality. The Hindu castes support the social order where people in lowest can be oppressed and discriminated which sustains the political relation and social structure governed by higher castes. Spiritual influence and the presence of religion only justify the iniquity characterized by oppression of the outcasts by promising greater gains in the next life. From a critique of Marx to Hegel's Philosophy of Law, he argued that "religious distress is at the same time the expression of real distress and the protest against real distress. Religion is the heart of a heartless world, just as it is the spirit of a spiritless situation. It is the opium of the people." By recognizing that religion through the history only make the people amenable to social, economic and political oppression and discrimination, its abolition will give the people the real happiness. Religion has sedated the society to denounce any change that will pursue them to full human potential. That is, according to Marx, having a religion only manifests veering away from criticality and rational thinking based from its failed function to serve the general masses throughout history. Emile Durkheim Durkheim believes that the essentiality given by religion in a society is brought about by the idea that society is the soul of religion. In his writing of Individualism and Intellectuals, he described modern religion as not necessarily implying "symbols and rites, properly speaking, or temples and priests. This whole exterior apparatus is only the superficial part. Essentially, it is nothing other than a body of collective beliefs and practices endowed with a certain authority." (Durkheim 1973) Additionally, his last writing which was the The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life, establishes that religion is not divinely or supernaturally inspired but rather a product of society. According to Durkheim, "This system of conceptions is not purely imaginary and hallucinatory, for the moral forces that these things awaken in us are quite real-as real as the ideas that words recall to us after they have served to form the ideas." (Durkheim 1973). Studying the case of Australian aborigines which for him substantially represented the most basic, elementary forms of religion within a culture, he found out that religion and religious beliefs take emphasis and affect the product of social life within a society. His finding on the relation of religion to society can be best described from an excerpt in his book "Religion is something eminently social. Religious representations are collective representations which express collective realities; the rites are a manner of acting which take rise in the midst of assembled groups and which are destined to excite, maintain, or recreate certain mental states in these groups. So if the categories are of religious origin, they ought to participate in this nature common to all religious facts; they should be social affairs and the product of collective thought. At least-for in the actual condition of our knowledge of these matters, one should be careful to avoid all radical and exclusive statements-it is allowable to suppose that they are rich in social elements." (Thompson 1982). Additionally, Durkheim pointed out that relative to sacred things, religion is a unified system of beliefs and practices. "that is to say, things set apart and forbidden-beliefs and practices which unite into one single moral community called a Church, all those who adhere to them."(Durkheim 1982). Moreover, he believes that religion is the main source of solidarity and identification for the individual members of the society. This case can be manifested especially when it functions as a part of mechanical solidarity systems or organic solidarity in its lesser context. It also reinforces morals and social norms held collectively to provide meaning of life for an individual in a given society. Despite tagging religion as a mere fantasy because of its natural origin, Durkheim recognizes its function in establishing a critical social system. It functions to achieve and provide social control, cohesion, purpose for people, much as a means of communication and individual interaction, organization and reaffirmation of social norms. Durkheim also argued that religion primarily functions as a source of national cohesion that is pulling together people in mental and physical aspect through religious services or assemblies. In return, religion gives the possible reaffirmation of the society's collective morals and beliefs. This function, according to him becomes almost imperative since individual beliefs and convictions need reinforcement which without it disintegrates when left for a considerable span of time. Whereas society continually has common norm and belief, religion maintains the concrete influence of it to society. Lastly, he maintained that "Since it [religion] is in spiritual ways that social pressure exercises itself, it could not fail to give men the idea that outside themselves there exist one or several powers, both moral and, at the same time, efficacious, upon which they depend." (Durkheim 1973). References: Wexler, P. & Stein, P. Durkheim, Social Revitalization, Education and Religion. Geoffrey Walford, & W. S. F. Pickering. Durkheim and Modern Education. England: Routledge Taylor and Francis Group. 1998. Bellah, Robert N. Emile Durkheim: On Morality and Society, Selected Writings. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. 1973. Thompson, Kenneth. Emile Durkheim. London: Tavistock Publications. 1982. Beyer, P. Religions in Cross Cultural Perspective. Fenn, R.K. The Blackwell Companion to Sociology of Religion. Blackwell Publishing. 2001. Tole, L.A. Durkheim and French Society. Hamilton, P. Emile Durkheim. England: Taylor and Francis. 1994. Marx, K. Introduction to A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right. 1844. Retrieved last 10 May 2008. http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1843/critique-hpr/intro.htm Cline, A. Karl Marx's Analysis of Religion. About.com, http://atheism.about.com/od/philosophyofreligion/a/marx.htm Weber, Max. Sociology of Religion. 1993. Beacon Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Max Weber Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503094-max-weber
(Max Weber Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503094-max-weber.
“Max Weber Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503094-max-weber.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Max Weber and Catholic Doctrine

British Secularization: Observation on Religion Itself

The classic sociological theorists of religion, Marx, weber, and Durkheim, deserve discussion and application here.... While Durkheim, weber, and Marx were all very different theorists, they shared some primary assumptions (Crabtree, 2008; Giddens, 1997).... 'The three 'classical' sociological theorists, Marx, Durkheim, and weber [all] thought that the significance of religion would decrease in modern times....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Pragmatic and Relatable Model of the Development of Capitalist Society

weber and his contemporaries had been witnesses to astounding progress in the field of technology.... max weber, Sr.... weber reckoned without the effect that advancing technology would have on the capitalist power structure, the relationship between labor and capital and the means of production.... Born into an affluent family, weber's father was trained as an attorney, held a prominent position in the civil service and was a member of the National Liberal Party....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Cultural Significance Of The Reformation During The Renaissance

The changes were also a result of protest against the evil that people saw in the catholic Church for example rampant corruption.... The result of criticism against the catholic Church was a loss in its authority and the emergence of new protestant churches and sects.... The renaissance was therefore a successful weapon for countering the fight against pagan civilization by the catholic Church....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

The Role of Religion in Contemporary Irish Society

max weber, Émile Durkheim and other early proponents of the new discipline of sociology described evidence of a shift away from religion and towards rationalisation.... From the Neolithic monuments to the medieval monasteries and the modern institution of the catholic Church, there are visible traces on the Irish landscape that testify to this historical preoccupation with organised religious beliefs and practices.... From the Neolithic monuments to the medieval monasteries and the modern institution of the catholic Church, there are visible traces on the Irish landscape that testify to this historical preoccupation with organised religious beliefs and practices....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Karl Marxs Ethnographic Report of the New Planet

This discussion, The New Planet, outlines that the humanoids residing on the newly discovered planet can be closely compared with the human beings of our earth.... The development of humanoid society could be contributed to the same reason as that of man.... ... ... ... According to the report to satisfy the basic needs of survival; food, cloth and shelter, the humanoids started productions activities that would help provide the subsistence....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Webers Protestant Ethics

max weber, realizing the influence of religion on individuals, sought to analyze how much power affected how individuals perceived the economy and business in general.... n his theory, max weber attempts to elucidate the emergence of Europe and its uniqueness as a dominant economic force globally.... The paper 'weber's Protestant Ethics' focuses on one of the most influential sociological books that seek to explain the relationship between religion and the economy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analysis of the Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism by Max Weber

"Analysis of the Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism by Max Weber" paper presents a brief biography of max weber and a discussion of his thoughts that are presented in his famous collection of essays entitled 'The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism'.... max weber commenced his higher education at the University of Heidelberg in 1882, but his university education was interrupted after two years by his one year of military service at Strasbourg....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

Secularization and Fundamentalist Reactions

The focus of Sarvodaya Shramadana's doctrine was an emphasis on development of harmony among different ethnic groups, revitalization of Sri Lankan culture, preservation of bio-diversity, community economics, and self-reliant organic farming with the village at the center (Bond, 196).... In addition, I will illuminate the two cases using weber's analysis of power in 'Class Status and Society'.... While Bond and Rutherford view secular religion as an indicator of collective uprising, weber, on the other hand, views power as directly correlated with social status and class....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us