StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Peter Singer, who played a pioneering role in the founding of Animal Liberation Movement, posits strong argumentative tactics that vindicate his convictions in his…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective"

Download file to see previous pages

Roger Scruton’s “The Moral Status of Animals” follows a similar line of argument that defends all life forms on the face of the earth and reveals his intense convictions in ideological and environmental thought. Singer’s comprehensive analysis brings to light many aspects of what Richard D. Ryder has termed ‘speciesism’. Drawing comparisons to the liberations movements of the sixties and the debate around the concept of equality among human beings, Singer emphasizes on the need to take animals too into consideration in such debates.

He attacks the norm that animals can be excluded from the debate on equal rights because they lack the moral, rational powers than humans possess. Singer points out that there exists an essential difference among human beings based on race, gender and demographical specifics, but the equal rights theorists overcome this by stressing on the basic human qualities. The equal rights theories also highlight the individual differences among human beings on which the concept of personal rights is based.

Singer uses a systematic analytical strategy to break down these arguments one by one. Singer alludes to the publication of Mary Wollstonecraft’s monumental treatise, Vindication of the Rights of Women in 1792 and how “they were satirized in an anonymous publication entitled A Vindication of the Rights of Brutes”, actually written by Thomas Taylor, a Cambridge philosopher. Taylor refuted Wollstonecraft’s by trivializing her demands for the equal treatment of women on moral, philosophical and social realms by proposing that in fact one should go another step further and treat dogs, cats and horses in the similar manner.

This argument was an absurd one at that time, and Taylor’s attempt was to prove that Wollstonecraft’s arguments regarding the rights of women were also absurd, as it questioned a specific order in nature. Singer’s overview of Taylor’s argument

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective Essay”, n.d.)
An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1540691-an-analysis-of-the-animal-rights-debate-from-an-ethics-perspective
(An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective Essay)
An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1540691-an-analysis-of-the-animal-rights-debate-from-an-ethics-perspective.
“An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1540691-an-analysis-of-the-animal-rights-debate-from-an-ethics-perspective.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective

An Analysis of Animal Experimentation Papers

hellip; The content of the two articles, focusing on two different sides of the animal experimentation debate, clearly highlight that the topic is a societal and moral issue instead of a problem.... Appendix B an analysis of Animal Experimentation articles 1.... The two articles appear to be fairly reliable and credible sources of information regarding the animal experimentation debate.... the animal experimentation debate is saddled with a number of issues concerning morality and ethics....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Summary response paper

hellip; These ethical concerns have been the subject of debates or discussions among animal rights advocates and the scientific and medical communities too.... His succinct explanations debunked the two arguments put forward by animal rights advocates on the basis of animals having no rights at all because they have no moral capacity to make any choices or give consent, and secondly, the animals “are not capable of grasping the generality of an ethical premise in a practical syllogism” and it is only humans who can think at a highly abstract level (Cohen 96)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ethical Treatment of Animals and Animal Rights

animal rights is the idea that all animals are entitled to certain rights because they also possess moral rights, as a result of which those rights should be recognized within the framework of the law.... Animal interests should also be considered on an equal basis with those of… mans, and excluding animals from such consideration would be tantamount to a form of discrimination known as specicism.... ??3 As a result, no distinction is to be made between the rights of human beings and the right of animals, and according preferential treatment to human beings as opposed to animals would be morally and ethically a wrong principle....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Is it safe to keep wild animals as pets

Amid much debate and controversy over the ethics and dangers of keeping wild animals as pets, people are known to keep wild animals in their homes as pets (Bell, 2001).... The debate over the dangers and ethics of keeping wild animals as pets is represented by two philosophical perspectives.... Capture stats from Captive Wild Animal Protection Coalition and Euro Group for Animals.... Mankind has a history of wanting to own and cultivate wild animals and this may be a trait inherited from our ancestors who were hunters (Bell, 2001)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Environmental Ethics Assignment 2

From this description, the major functions of zoos are to maintain the animal species contained therein for safeguarding, learning, or display to the general community.... Additionally, the care provided at the zoo may not be what the animal actually needs (Lee and Holder 2007, p.... In order to fully understand the issue, the purpose and justification for zoos needs to be viewed, as it is from this perspective that the immorality, or otherwise, of the zoos… As such, zoos are primarily aimed at ensuring that wild life is preserved, and at the same time the forms of life preserved there are put in such a manner that they can easily be studied and observed by enthusiasts and any other party that may be interested in them 111)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Viewpoint of Leopold and Schweitzer about Artificial Destruction of Ecosystem Centers

The moral obligation of man towards the non-living objects and other living organisms has been proposed by two environmental thinkers in a divergent perspective but convergent basis.... Various ideas about artificial destruction of ecosystem centers on ethics as a tool of human conscience.... and ethics is used by Leopold to emphasize the need for a moral conscience of man in his relationship with soil....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Stakeholder Analysis

the animal rights debate.... The proponents of this argument constitute the animal rights activists, religious leaders and Stakeholder Analysis Who are the stakeholders?... The proponents of this argument constitute the animal rights activists, religious leaders and a section of the public (Cohen and Tom 69).... The core stakeholders are animal rights activists, scientists, government agencies, religious groups and general public....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Universal Ethical Egoism Theory

Universal ethical egoism theory states that it is a perspective doctrine that all individuals have to act from their own self-interests.... Two ethical theories relating to this paper are Universal Ethical Egoism and Confucian Role ethics.... from the theory, the partiality not to feed on meat is because of the act of killing the animals is in itself a messy business and this cuts short the life of animals slaughtered.... Societies that have learned that eating meat is simply custom and a habit that people have developed and acquired from generation to generation since time immemorial are allowed to continue with such acts (Jenkins 2003)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us