StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Native American and Australian Aborigines Land Ownership - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Native American and Australian Aborigines Land Ownership" is about the problem with both Native American and Aborigine land ownership rights is the definition of ownership. The European definition is different than the native definition…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Native American and Australian Aborigines Land Ownership
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Native American and Australian Aborigines Land Ownership"

Native Americans in North America and Australian Aborigines suffered under European colonization. Death, disease, and resettlement were experienced by both. This occurred uniquely in each country. However, geographically both the Native Americans and Aborigines had land taken from them. Both groups were resettled to undesired parts of each individual country. Only in recent years have both groups gained rights to the lands that their ancestors held. This paper will briefly compare and contrast land ownership issues of Native Americans and Australian Aborigines.

In 1788, Australian Aborigines were introduced to British colonization (Chesterman and Galligan 199). The effects were immediate. Smallpox and other white men’s diseases killed over half of the Aborigines. This was followed by the loss of land and water resources. Finally, resistance against the British decimated the Aborigine population. Due to a loss of almost eighty percent of Aboriginal lives during 1788-1901, the British took over the arable land, sending the natives to undesired parts of Australia (Chesterman and Galligan 199).

The Americans were colonized over a longer period of time, due to the landmass being colonized. The first proven date of colonization was dated back to 1492 (Wunder 349). Although the process took longer, the effects were the same. Disease, war, and resettlement conquered the Native Americans, taking their lands. In America, the government created treaties promising the Native Americans monetary and land for generations.

Both the Aborigines and Native Americans held different views than Europeans about land. Europeans believed men could own land. Aborigines and Native Americans held a more sacred view of the land. The land was spiritual, which could not be owned by one. This created a further division when deciding land ownership issues.

In recent years, Australian Aborigines have been making limited progress in the return of land. The issue has been the Aborigines want to have communal land, but the Australian government “believe that it’s not poverty that’s holding Indigenous Australians back—it’s their land” (Snowdon). The government wants the Aborigines to divide their land in order to become more prosperous. This shows that European and native views on land ownership are directly opposite. An Aborigine believes they are here to care for the land, not own it. Yet, the Australian government has begun passing laws in order to divide the land for the betterment of the natives. This has been the motive of many governments. The result will be the same; Aborigines losing more land and resources.

In the United States, Indian (Native American) land does not fall under state law. Indian land falls under federal laws. Native American agencies, depending on the tribe, rule their land. This land can be a reservation or individually owned land. This allows Native Americans to allow gambling and casinos on their land, whereas the state might not allow gambling (Johansen 31). The Native Americans have agencies, government, and Native Americans to help with land ownership issues, elections, laws, and even their own government. This Native American government is regulated by the United States Federal government.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Native American Topic: Geographic Evolution in N. America, Compare & Essay”, n.d.)
Native American Topic: Geographic Evolution in N. America, Compare & Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1543863-native-american-topic-geographic-evolution-in-n-america-compare-contrast-with-australian-aborigines-land-ownership-issues
(Native American Topic: Geographic Evolution in N. America, Compare & Essay)
Native American Topic: Geographic Evolution in N. America, Compare & Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1543863-native-american-topic-geographic-evolution-in-n-america-compare-contrast-with-australian-aborigines-land-ownership-issues.
“Native American Topic: Geographic Evolution in N. America, Compare & Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1543863-native-american-topic-geographic-evolution-in-n-america-compare-contrast-with-australian-aborigines-land-ownership-issues.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Native American and Australian Aborigines Land Ownership

Introduction to Indigenous Australia

australian aborigines Progressive Association (AAPA) became founded in 1927 by Maynard and Lacey.... Introduction to Indigenous Australia Name Institution land rights are the honest claim of a long historical movement, championed by the Aboriginal who resisted dispossession from their land, and supported by other non Aboriginal Australians.... The opposing team together with narrow designed legal argument and thoughts of the role of labor has developed myths about the land rights in Australia....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Social and Political Rights of Aboriginal People in Australia

Policies which Deprived Aboriginal People of their Rights as CitizensFor several decades Australian Aboriginal people were 'citizens without rights' in their own land.... he defining of citizenship for the Aboriginal people and the treatment of aborigines were based on constitutional provision, legislative explanation, administrative practice, and judicial determination.... Although the national government did not have the specific power to pass laws with respect to Aboriginal people, the Commonwealth could have improved the status of aborigines by including them in all the rights and entitlements that it controlled such as 'the Commonwealth franchise, sickness and disability pensions, and maternity benefits' (Chesterman & Galligan 1997: 6)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Anthropologists Response to Colonialism

This essay "Anthropologists' Response to Colonialism" talks about the colonial era which binds modern anthropology practices and origin.... However, the eighteenth age of European enlightenment was the cause of the colonialism that characterized the nineteenth century.... ... ... ... The anthropologists were intrigued to articulate passive subjects in an essential manner because of the industrial revolution in the 19th century and its retrenchment....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

John Lockes View of Ownership in Context with the Mabo versus Queensland

This report "John Locke's View of ownership in Context with the Mabo versus Queensland" discusses the issue of 'native right' in the light of Locke's perception that Locke never favored commonwealth judgments.... In this case, the reason for not constituting native title and indigenous land as proper ownership by Locke is clear for the basic perceptions Locke provided with the European political thought.... Chapter V of the Second Treatise defines 'property' as land according to Locke and can be examined in two different ways....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Constitutional Protection of Aboriginal Rights in Canada vs in Australia

Both the australian constitution and the Canadian constitution recognize the aboriginal community and the Torres Strait Islanders.... n the contrary, the australian constitution fails to demonstrate the protection of Indigenous rights.... Kruger's case is one of the historical instances where the protection of the indigenous rights by the australian constitution did not merit (Castan, 2011: 12-17)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Changes That Court Decision Brought to the Australian Land Laws

The act declared that the annexation of the islands in the Torres Strait in 1879 transferred the ownership of the lands therein to the state of Queensland.... The study "The Changes That Court Decision Brought to the Australian land Laws" states the impact of the court decision in the case of Mabo is far-reaching and only time will tell as to how deep and how broad are the consequences of the court's decision to overturn the doctrine of terra nullius.... Three main issues that may have the greatest impact on Australian land laws....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Explanations for the Occurrence of Racism and Xenophobia

It discusses issues like the racist attitudes of the australian whites towards the indigenous blacks and the distressing conditions of the Aboriginals.... Racial discrimination and xenophobia are issues that should be addressed by the australian government with immediate effect.... While discussing the context of Australia the discrimination the australian aboriginals are subjected to is discussed first.... The essay further addresses the immigration issues and the White australian Policy....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Aboriginal Communities: Self Determination

land councils and representations have significantly contributed to the advancement of rights.... land, health, education are amongst the most significant issues that are addressed as they improved since 1970 through self-determination.... Though Aboriginal activists started lobbying for self-determination back in 1925 with the formation of the australian Aboriginal Progressive Association, self-determination was, however, first expressed in 1972 with the abolishment of White Australia Policy and introduction of a policy of self-determination by the Whitlam government (Kowal 2008)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us