StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Criticizing Augustine's Account of Natural and Moral Evil - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Name of Professor Criticizing Augustine’s Account of Natural and Moral Evil Introduction The major issues of St. Augustine’s The City of God, specifically Books XI-XIV, are the creation of the universe, the fall of Adam and Eve, and the problem of evil or, more specifically, the difference between natural and moral evil…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Criticizing Augustines Account of Natural and Moral Evil
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Criticizing Augustine's Account of Natural and Moral Evil"

Download file to see previous pages

A number of mortals will be saved by the love and compassion of God, and others will be denounced to endless suffering. Ultimately, the justice and goodness of God are expressed. After reading the City of God, particularly Books XI-XIV, I came to oppose Augustine’s explanation of the roots and of the ultimate nature of moral evil. It is argued that the concept of temporarily faultless entities intentionally giving in to sin is meaningless and paradoxical. A genuinely faultless entity, albeit free to commit transgressions, would ideally or, in truth, never commit even one sin.

To point the root of evil to the intentional wrongdoing of a faultless entity is hence to claim the ultimate irony that evil has shaped itself out of nothing. Moreover, there seems to be a dissonance between this theological account and the canon of predestination of Augustine, which effectively creates the root of moral evil within the liability and intention of God. The canon of Augustine talks about the descending of angels. Augustine introduced the notion of Natural and Moral evil. The former are the occurrences that resemble evil, like war, flood, earthquakes, etc.

They resemble evil because human beings are ruled by selfishness, have an imperfect consciousness and understanding and are not capable of discerning the ‘grand purpose’ of the unraveling play of God. Hence, when seen in the point of view of God’s grand purpose, natural evils cease to appear evil in any way. In contrast, moral evil is the outcome of human action and will. These are the blameworthy outcomes of a resolve that has become tied to mundane or inferior principles and activities, viewing them as though they were greater.

Basically, moral evil is the deviation of the will from God and relating itself to lower principles as though they were greater. My purpose in this paper is to argue against Augustine’s account of the Natural evil and Moral evil or, more particularly, the problem of evil. The Flaws of Augustine’s Natural Evil and Moral Evil I mostly disagree to the notion that God granted good being the liberty to commit sin. If a creature is faultless in its righteousness it would in no way commit any transgression even though it is free to do so.

Evil would therefore have to form itself out of nothing, which is absurd. Nevertheless, it is not logical that moral faultlessness essentially involves indisputability. Moreover, Augustine’s dispute of the Manichean’s notion of the human soul as Light’s divided component would eradicate the vital difference between the maker and the created (Jones 1969). In addition, it would weaken the responsibility of human beings for the perpetration of sin. The argument of Augustine, by eliminating the essence of Satan as a contributory factor, makes all the arguments of the Manicheans illogical (Jones 1969).

Similar to all excellent critiques Augustine prevails by eliminating the core principle that the argument of the Manicheans is rooted in: “God, being supremely real, is supremely good. God’s creatures, being in varying degrees less real than God, are in corresponding degrees less good. Their so-called evil is simply the absence of goodness and reality; it is the inevitable consequence of their status as creature” (Jones 1969, 95). Moreover, Natural evil is the outcome of human weaknesses, more particularly, human beings’

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Criticizing Augustine's Account of Natural and Moral Evil Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1426320-defend-or-criticize-augustine-s-explanation-of
(Criticizing Augustine'S Account of Natural and Moral Evil Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1426320-defend-or-criticize-augustine-s-explanation-of.
“Criticizing Augustine'S Account of Natural and Moral Evil Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1426320-defend-or-criticize-augustine-s-explanation-of.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Criticizing Augustine's Account of Natural and Moral Evil

Martin Luther King Jr,s Letter from a Birmingham Jail, Critical Analysis

Thirdly, he gives an account of the preparation for non-violent protest.... His repeated allusions to Christian belief and personalities, including his references to the Apostles and Christ, serve to reiterate his commitment to the church and vouch for his good moral character.... He cleverly equates the segregation statute with unjust laws and puts the moral law of the Church above it.... hellip; This open letter was King's response to a newspaper column inserted by a group of local clergymen in the Birmingham News, criticizing the direct-action form of his protest campaign....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Can Politics Ever Be Considered Just for Augustine

The fact that he was influenced by the Manichaean sect in the belief that human beings are balanced by both good and evil characteristics may have played a role in the political philosophy that he developed later in his life.... Free will is absolutely essential to human nature as this is what determines what individuals do with their live, whether good or evil.... hellip; Most of augustine's political thought was based on the Platonic school and for most of his active life in the church; he attempted to propagate Plato's teachings through Cicero into the basic teachings of the church....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Audustine's Confessions

However, to some extent it seems that augustine's philosophy demonstrates a hard to define confluence between pre-destination and free-will that have led some scholars to argue that there are actually two different Augustinian philosophies, themselves mutually contradictory (Rist 1972).... Adequate research into Augustine demonstrates that these concepts are not necessarily mutually exclusive, as augustine's understanding reveals subtle characterizations that bind their philosophic elements in hybrid...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Augustines Confessions

augustine's movements from Thagate and Carthage and between Rome and Milan did not free him from doubts about Catholicism and its doctrines.... Augustine narrates about his life in the first nine chapters.... The chapters assess his life from birth (354 A.... ) to the time he changed… He recounts about his life experience through the autobiography....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Conversion in Saint Augustine's Confessions

In this paper, I will argue that Monica (augustine's mother) is the most important First, Monica's outstanding obedience to her husband influenced Augustines conversion.... Monica played a significant role in the conversion of Patricius (augustine's father) and Augustine....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Saint Augustine's Confession

augustine's strong conviction to the Christian world originated Monica.... Her marvelous traits inform augustine's strong need for conversion.... ??2 From here, we realize that it was the mother that firstly drew augustine's attentions towards the Lord.... Monica became so amiable to augustine's father and vowed never to have a quarrel with her husband....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Augustine's Concept of Will

The paper "augustine's Concept of Will" explores famous philosophic ideas indicative of later Protestant formulations, yet perhaps not as extreme.... In order to fully understand augustine's concept of the will it's necessary to gain an understanding of the motivations and occurrences in his life that influenced and shaped his philosophy.... The Manichaean's were a religious sect that stood in direct philosophic distinction from the Christian faith that augustine's mother held in high esteem....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Dewey's Library Intention with Respect to Philosophy

Like any honest social scientist, he finds the presence and the influence of natural science in Western culture today both its distinctive trait and its greatest achievement.... Discuss why Dewey thinks it is not helpful to try to restore traditional beliefs in our time (with regard to the regulating of society and morality), Is he arguing that we should have no moral problems?... Men do not, in their natural estate, think when they have no troubles to cope with, no difficulties to overcome" (Dewey139)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us